6 Movies That Didn't Meet the Hype - Mania.com

97 Comments | Add


Rate & Share:


Related Links:



  • Series:

6 Movies That Didn't Meet the Hype

The Bigger the Hype the Bigger the Fall

By Matt Hoffman     February 22, 2010

6 Movies That Didn't Meet the Hype
© Bob Trate


Making a good movie ain’t easy. Even the most talented and dedicated filmmakers sometimes produce subpar work; after all, they’re only human. However, when a big-budget franchise entry turns out kind of sucky, the Hollywood publicity machine still has to claim that it’s the best thing since Citizen Kane. Here, then, is a refresher course on recent movies that have generated big gaps between expectations and reality, and not in a good way. Enjoy, haters!

6 Underperforming Movies

6. Godzilla (1998)

The Hype:
First of all, the Godzilla remake relocated the franchise from Japan to New York City. This meant that Americans would finally receive the special honor of having one of their major cities get smashed to pieces by their favorite giant lizard. Also, said lizard would for the first time be created through modern CGI rather than the traditional method of putting an actor in a big rubber suit. Best of all, the film was directed by Roland Emmerich, who at the time was known more for Stargate and Independence Day than The Day After Tomorrow and 10,000 BC.
The Letdown:
Turns out that a computer-generated, non-humanoid Godzilla just isn’t the Godzilla we all know and love. At least this one wasn’t. Beyond that, the remake lacked the fearful symbolism of the original and the charming hokiness of many of the sequels. (One thing that was carried over from the original series, however, was a confusing inconsistency in just how big the monster is supposed to be.)

6 Underperforming Movies

5. Spider-Man 3 (2007)

The Hype:
Prior to this movie, director Sam Raimi’s Spider-Man series had been on a roll. The original film was fairly well-received, and Spider-Man 2 was so successful that Roger Ebert claimed it “may have defined the high point of the traditional film based on comic-book heroes.” Fans hoped that 3 would continue the saga’s upwards momentum, and why wouldn’t it? After all, it featured Venom, one of the comic’s most important villains.
The Letdown:
As it turned out,, Venom had to take a back seat to Sandman and the new incarnation of the Green Goblin. The screenplay couldn’t quite juggle all three villains effectively. Raimi also ended the film on an ambiguous note rather than taking the traditional genre trilogy route of wrapping everything up in film #3. The final product was so unpopular that the series is now being rebooted under the supervision of director Marc Webb. Today Spider-Man 3 is mainly remembered for its incongruous dance number and James Franco delivering a creepy line about pie.

6 Underperforming Movies

4. Superman Returns (2006)

The Hype:
Superman is arguably the most quintessential superhero in history. This movie marked his return to the silver screen for the first time in almost 20 years. The director in charge of bringing him back was Bryan Singer, whose acclaimed X-Men films had helped popularize comic-book adaptations in Hollywood. Plus, the TV show Smallville had been keeping the character of Superman active in 21st century pop culture.
The Letdown:
Actually, the reviews weren’t awful. However, the plot was light on action and seemed to lack the intangible oomph that makes for a classic superhero film—which was what Superman Returns pretty much needed to be in order to justify its $209 million budget. The movie made a profit, but not as much as Warner Bros. had hoped for. As a result, Superman, like Spider-Man, seems destined for a hasty reboot.

6 Underperforming Movies

3. The Matrix Reloaded (2003)

The Hype:
The Matrix used Gnostic philosophy, cyperpunk aesthetics and Star Wars-level mythologizing to create a unique fictional universe that begged to be expanded with additional stories. Fans had to wait an excruciating four years for that potential to be realized on the big screen. The delay occurred partly because creators Andy and Larry Wachowski filmed the two sequels concurrently, ensuring a unified story and tone between the two. Most importantly, Reloaded promised to supply a re-up of genuine Bullet Time action, hopefully putting to shame the imitators which had sprouted up after the original film’s release.
The Letdown:
Well, you can’t invent the wheel twice. The Matrix was successful partly because most people had never seen anything like it before. A sequel was never going to have that advantage. Beyond that, Reloaded was just bloated, with too many drawn-out action and dialogue scenes in which nothing really happened. (It did make a whole lotta money, though, and is currently the second-highest-grossing R-rated movie of all time, after The Passion of the Christ.) Revolutions was worse, but by then people more or less knew what to expect.

6 Underperforming Movies

2. Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull (2008)

The Hype:
Like Superman Returns, this film promised to bring back a classic American hero who had been out of theaters for almost two decades. Unlike Supes, though, Indy wouldn’t have to be recast or handed over to a new director. He would be played by the beloved Harrison Ford and shepherded onto the screen by legendary creators Steven Spielberg and George Lucas. It would be just like the good old days!
The Letdown:
You can decide for yourself where Indy 4 went wrong. Did it jump the shark right off the bat with the infamous nuking-the-fridge sequence? Were the aliens a bad idea? Or are Soviets just less innately hate-able than Nazis? Overall, this movie seemed to have too much silliness and not enough of the thrills that made the original trilogy so popular. We did get a pretty good South Park episode out of it, though.

1. The Dark Knight (2008)

Haha, just kidding.

6 Underperforming Movies

1. Star Wars: Episode I – The Phantom Menace (1999)

The Hype:
Audiences had been waiting for this ever since the words “Episode IV” first scrolled onto screens in 1977. A New Hope introduced the most fascinating fictional universe in the history of film. Two more movies (plus the sprawling “Expanded Universe” of comic books, video games, etc.) weren’t enough to satisfy fans. We wanted more. In 1993 (10 years after the release of Return of the Jedi) it was announced that the series’ “prequels” would be coming to fruition. This promise didn’t become reality until six years later, but that didn’t dampen enthusiasm. People lined up for tickets weeks in advance. Movie studios avoided releasing any new films in the vicinity of Episode I’s premiere. Countless students and workers played hooky on opening day. This was going to be big.
The Letdown:
To be fair, Episode I is not the worst film on this list. It is, however, far from perfect. Given the legacy it had to carry on its shoulders, far from perfect was not nearly good enough. If you want a detailed rundown of what was wrong with this movie, check out that 70-minute review that’s been floating around the internet. The important thing is that in 1999 mankind finally learned a sobering lesson about the value of hype and the folly of wishful thinking. We could never be fooled the same way again.
Of course, if you believe that, then you didn’t read items 2 through 5 of this list. By the way, we have a really awesome bridge you might be interested in… 
Love Movies, hate crappy ones? Read 6 Annoying Things Hollywood Needs to Stop Doing
Ok, love movies, want hope? Then try 8 Reasons to Believe In Hollywood Again


Become a Fan of Mania on Facebook: HERE

Follow Mania on Twitter

Subscribe to Mania's YouTube Channel



Showing items 1 - 10 of 97
1 2 3 4 >  >>  
swisshammer 2/22/2010 12:23:14 AM

Um... I'm not entirely sure, but the words "Episode IV" did NOT appear on the screens in 1977. The film was simply "Star Wars." There were plans for sequels, but the first one had to succeed before they could be made.

The rest of this article is decent, though.

ripum853 2/22/2010 12:39:08 AM

Whew, you had me hook, line, and sinker with the Dark Knight tease.  Well done haha.

DangermouseZilla 2/22/2010 1:41:21 AM

People will no doubt hate me for it, but...

Men in Black - it was an average-to-good film but was incredibly over-hyped.

ultrazilla2000 2/22/2010 1:54:23 AM

I didn't mind the alien aspect of Indy 4...just everything else! 

Godzilla was the biggest let down for me personally.  At the time, I DID enjoy it...but after it all sank in, I realized that what I enjoyed was just a random giant monster movie with GOD AWFUL human characters and dialogue (and every other story aspect!).  Godzilla wasn't Godzilla...even in the slightest.  Godzilla does NOT lay hundreds of eggs.  Godzilla is NOT a radiated island iguana.  Godzilla breathes radioactive, blue fire...this thing only had two tacked on "normal" fire bellows AFTER fan outcry during production.  Godzilla smashes through the cities...NOT running down streets while the military does all the damage.  Godzilla does NOT run from humans in their military vehicles.   GODZILLA DOES NOT DIE FROM A COUPLE OF MISSILES!!!  Seriously...just call the movie something else!

sportwarrior 2/22/2010 2:19:25 AM

I'm not sure why Superman made this list.  Especially over a movie like, say, Dune... I enjoyed that movie (well after it's initial release) but my impression of the initial reaction upon its release was one incredible disappointment.

Superman was fine.  It wasn't great, but I don't think it was a bad movie by any means.  There are definitely movies out there that disappointed more than it did (looking at you, Star Trek: Nemesis).

karas1 2/22/2010 3:51:14 AM

You're right swisshammer, Episode IV did not appear on screens in 1977.  And the movie was just Star Wars, not A New Hope.

The biggest problem with The Phantom Menace was that it wasn't about jedi.  It was about Palpatine and how he set the stage to take over as Emperor.  But he got very little screen time in his own movie.  Instead we have Qui Gon Jin who was cool but got killed, Darth Maul who was really a paper tiger (he didn't seem to do much except stalk around and look menacing) a snotty, unlikable Obi Wan Kenobi, an animated, annoying offensive racial sterotype in Jar Jar and Anakin as a whiny brat.  Oh, and ther was Padme who was pretty forgetable. There was a pod race that was an extended commercial for a videogame and other extended FX sequences that didn't go anywhere.

Godzilla was cute.  Matthew Broderick is always likable.  But it was hardly what it should have been.  And Godzilla had been to New York before in Destroy All Monsters.

I didn't hate Indy IV as much as most people seem to.  It wasn't as good as Raiders or the one with the Holy Grail but it was fun.  The nuke the fridge sequence wasn't any more unbelievable than sequences from earlier films.  Remember in Raiders when Indy rode across the ocean on the outside of a submarine?  Or in Temple of Doom when he jumped out of a crashing airplane in a life raft and sledded down a mountain?  And I rather liked the relationship between Indy and his newfound son.  But I agree it wasn't as good as it could have been.

Spiderman 3 wasn't as good as 1 and 2 but it wasn't terrible either.  My mother and I were visiting my brother in Florida and it was 95 degrees and we wanted to spend a few hours in an airconditioned movie theater so we saw it together.  It was entertaining and the movie theater sold honey coated nuts as a snack so it was a fine time.  Not cinema history, but an agreeable way to waste a few hours.

The Matrix Reloaded was a confusing mess.  It confused extended FX sequences with storytelling.  Very disappointing.

Didn't see Superman Returns so I really can't comment.

Kara S

middlerealm 2/22/2010 3:58:26 AM

While I agree with all the above, especially Episode 1 and Matrix Reloaded, I'd like to add Blair Witch to the list... it was so over hyped here in the UK that I refused to go watch it because everyone was telling me that I just HAD to see it. When I finally did see it I was so glad I didn't waste money on it.

I thought Jurassic Park was the most over hyped film ever but it did pretty much prove itself to some degree as I did enjoy it.

karas1 2/22/2010 4:19:17 AM

Jurissic Park was very hyped, but it deserved the hype.  It was great!

Dazzler 2/22/2010 4:32:00 AM

I agree that dark knight is #1 for overhyped and failed to impress me anyway. 

Darkknight2280 2/22/2010 4:40:41 AM

I still enjoyed Episode 1 however, i would have enjoyed it more with a different kid Anakin actor and a different incarnation of Jar Jar ( a less over the top jar jar) 

1 2 3 4 >  >>  


You must be logged in to leave a comment. Please click here to login.