Comic Book Review


Action Comics

By: Kurt Amacker
Review Date: Friday, October 27, 2006

This 844th issue of ACTION COMICS presents a nearly archetypical Superman tale penned by Geoff Johns and Richard Donner, the director of the first Superman film and part of the second. Virtually removed from any of the larger goings-on in the DC Universe, the story finds Superman at odds with the United States government when a young Kryptonian boy lands in Metropolis. It seems that the Last Son of Krypton might only be the second-to-last. It’s a concise, familiar story with characters and situations anyone will recognize. Superman speaks to the hologram of his father, Jor-El, in the Fortress of Solitude. Perry White yells at Jimmy Olsen over some botched photographs. Ma and Pa Kent once again find themselves with a boy from Krypton. This almost feels like ALL-STAR SUPERMAN. I say bring it on.

I often hear reviewers claim that they like Superman as an idea – the impression they have from childhood, left by years of comics, cartoons, and movies – but they can’t pinpoint a really great run featuring the character, other than John Byrne. Like ALL-STAR SUPERMAN, this issue of ACTION COMICS embodies that idea succinctly and accessibly. You don’t have to read INFINITE CRISIS or 52 to understand the context. This story occurs in the world of Superman, built in our collective imagination when we were young. And yet, by reveling in classic territory, Johns and Donner wield a double-edged sword. Readers searching for a trip down memory lane will thoroughly enjoy this. Anyone that eschews nostalgia and wants a forward-looking, evolving Superman will think “Been there, done that.”

Adam Kubert presents a detailed and nuanced, yet iconic vision of the prerequisite Superman locales. He admirably crams a lot of action into a little space, given the small, quick panels that litter the book. Donner’s influence shows here, as the panels convey a more cinematic feel as they repeatedly cut to different talking heads. Still Kubert manages to keep up with the brisk storytelling and maintain a balance between the iconic and the bland.

This is a great place for anyone to start reading ACTION COMICS, as long as you accept that you don’t have to read 843 issues worth of trades first.

Questions? Comments? Let us know what you think at comicscape@mania.com.



More Content By Kurt Amacker
Comicscape: Something is Always in the Way
(Wednesday, October 8, 2008)
DAREDEVIL #110
(Wednesday, October 8, 2008)
Comicscape: The Kirkman vs. Bendis Steel Cage Match
(Wednesday, October 1, 2008)
Comicscape: Saving Superman's House
(Wednesday, September 24, 2008)
Holy Shitaki, Batgirl
(Wednesday, September 17, 2008)
X-FORCE #6
(Wednesday, September 17, 2008)
PUNISHER: WAR JOURNAL #23
(Monday, September 15, 2008)
Comicscape: What Expands Must Contract
(Wednesday, September 10, 2008)
Comicscape: Warner Bros. Takes DC to the Movies
(Wednesday, August 27, 2008)
Comic Review: DRACULA MEETS THE WOLFMAN #1
(Monday, August 25, 2008)
Fandango Logo
Comments/Responses
1
stormseye • Oct 27, 2006, 11:40am •
Wow, it has been a long, long time since I picked up a Superman comic. I got a few issues of that Jim Lee run that were quite good; I'll probably buy the trade paperback for it sometime. Before that, the last Superman I picked up was when he returned from the dead; that whole storyline with Superman's death was so overblown and hyped up, I'm actually ashamed to own any of those issues. The John Byrne run was really good, but so was the Jerry Ordway run, around the time Gangbuster was introduced. The characterization and plots were quite good.
Actually, the reboot of these flagship DC characters since Infinite Crisis has lured me back. I've become a steady reader of the new Justice League and Wonder Woman. Justice was a must read of course. I also bought several issue of Batman/Superman in the last half year or so. If only my wallet could afford my going deeper back into this old addiction. Actually, I think DC and Marvel needs to create a low cost monthly subscription to all their comics in an online format.

1
Login to post a comment!