Comic Book Review

Send to a Friend



To: (email)


To: (name)


From: (name)


Message:



ALL-STAR SUPERMAN #1

By: Kurt Amacker
Review Date: Friday, November 25, 2005

Allow me to first apologize for reviewing a book that came out last week. Normally, I try to write about books that just hit the shops, but I wasn't able to buy a copy of ALL-STAR SUPERMAN #1 until a few days ago because of the UPS debacle here in New Orleans (hurricane, flooding). Frankly, it would seem irresponsible for me to simply ignore this first issue, particularly in light of the promise it shows.


DC's All-Star line depicts "iconic" visions of their more popular characters, out of continuity with their main titles. These series present DC's most titular character in situations familiar not just to comic fans, but to most people. As such, when this first issue of SUPERMAN begins, Grant Morrison and Frank Quitley very succinctly repeat the Superman myth in a single page "Doomed planet. Desperate scientists. Last hope. Kindly couple." They quickly bring us to the issue's present, wherein our caped hero saves a mission to the sun gone awry (Lex Luthor, remote talking robot bomb). The Superman's arch-nemesis has recently betrayed the United States government that released him from prison in exchange for a more constructive scientific contribution. Unfortunately, our hero's too-close-for-comfort exposure to the sun's radiation drove his cell processes into overdrive, effectively making him terminally ill. By the time her returns to Earth, he must make several important decisions.


I applaud Grant Morrison's effort to spin a bit of substance into a story that could've been rife with origin clichés. While perplexing in a couple of parts, this first issue manages to offer a compelling, original story coupled with an "iconic" depiction of Superman. Unlike the series's Batman counterpart, Morrison plays it straight and the book reads all the better for it. Frank Quitely conveys motion within and between his panels far better than most artists. His realistic, minimally exaggerated characters portray both action and sentiment with an admirable level of detail. Jamie Grant's computer coloring only complements the entire enterprise further, and I'm usually curmudgeonly about anything to do with computers and art.


This first issue of ALL-STAR SUPERMAN is most certainly worth your time. But, you've probably heard that already.

Questions? Comments? Let us know what you think at comicscape@cinescape.com.


More Content By Kurt Amacker
NO FLY ZONE: Black and White vs. Color: The Struggle Continues
(Friday, November 28, 2008)
NO FLY ZONE: Comics You May Have Missed: Fun Home
(Friday, November 21, 2008)
NO FLY ZONE: Neverending Stories
(Friday, November 14, 2008)
Establishing a No-Fly Zone
(Friday, November 7, 2008)
Comicscape: Kurt’s Final Comicscape
(Wednesday, October 29, 2008)
Comicscape: Comic Books and the 2008 Election
(Wednesday, October 22, 2008)
Comicscape: A Bit of This and That
(Wednesday, October 15, 2008)
Comicscape: Something is Always in the Way
(Wednesday, October 8, 2008)
DAREDEVIL #110
(Wednesday, October 8, 2008)
Comicscape: The Kirkman vs. Bendis Steel Cage Match
(Wednesday, October 1, 2008)
Fandango Logo
Comments/Responses
1
• Nov 25, 2005, 04:38pm •
OK. UPS is evil incarnate, those damage packages and overcharge you on shipping and brokerage fees, but you really can't blame them for Katrina. There's never been any real evidence that they were behind all that -- at least none that was released to the public.

1
Login to post a comment!