DVD Shopping Bag


Alternate Endings

By: Robert T. Trate
Date: Tuesday, March 25, 2008

We have had a week now to digest and dissect the Warner Brothers DVD release of I am Legend.  Depending on which version you bought you may or may not have seen the alternate “controversial” ending.  In case you haven’t seen it by now it is available on YouTube

What I thought was interesting, if not mind blowing, was that Warner Brothers and the powers that be decided to go with the darker ending where Robert Neville (Will Smith) gives Anna (Alice Braga) the cure and remains behind to take care of the infected (by taking care of I mean a grenade with its pin pulled out). I have conflicted feelings between the theatrical cut and this new alternate ending. At first I wanted to applaud Warner Brothers for going this route. I should applaud them because, in this era of mass marketing and prepackaged trilogies and spin offs, Warner Brothers didn’t use this alternate ending. The alternate ending guaranteed a sequel with one of the biggest stars in the world. For me, the original ending of I am Legend felt shallow and weak. After going on this emotional journey of one man’s fight against the world to stay alive both physically and emotionally he dies and we are handed two throw away characters who complete his journey of I am Legend.

I’m sure many of you feel the same was as I do. I heard many people grumbling about the ending as I walked out of the theater and now hear others grumbling at the water cooler because of the original ending on DVD. Why did they keep the original ending in the theatrical cut? Why not have Robert make it to some sort of sanctuary? His self sacrifice for Anna and Ethan (Charlie Tahan) felt meaningless. This alternate ending had Robert reach a kind of peace an understanding towards the infected that wasn’t accomplished in the theatrical cut. 

A sequel as been spoken about but without Will Smith the story is really going to have to be phenomenal (Check out Mania’s article). Of course, the alternate ending is, in essence, meaningless. Has any film ever made a sequel where the main character, who died, now survives in alternate ending then gets a sequel with him alive in it? No. 

ACTION / ADVENTURE / KUNG FU/ THRILLERS / WESTERNS

Black Legion

Bohachi Bushido: Code of the Forgotten Eight

Bonnie and Clyde (Two-Disc Special Edition)

Bonnie and Clyde - Ultimate Collector's Edition

The Breakout

Brother Orchid

Contour

Jungle Queen

Kiltro

Kings of the Sun

Lady Killer

Loaded

Lost Highway

Mad Dog Killer (aka Beast With A Gun)

Mayor of Hell

Men and Legends

PTU: Police Tactical Unit

Sharpshooter

Smart Money (1933)

Smokers

Steve's Journey

Taras Bulba

Violent City

Virus

Zorro's Fighting Legion - The Complete Serial

ANIME

Baki the Grappler : Season 2 Box Set

Black Blood Brothers, Chapter 2 - Emergence

Dyogrammaton, Vol. 2

Glass Fleet, Vol. 5

Kite Liberator

Naruto 22

Ozie Boo, Vol. 1/Ozie Boo, Vol. 2

Ragnarok: The Animation - Third Quest v.3

Ranma 1/2 Season Six: Random Rhapsody

Red Garden, Vol. 4: Blood and Thorns

Shuffle, Vol. 2

Slayers TRY - Season Three Set

The Third: The Girl with the Blue Eye, Vol. 5: Shadows of the Past

Variable Geo Neo, Vol. 1: The Games Begin

xxxHOLiC: Starter Set

xxxHOLiC: First Collection

CARTOONS

Frisky Dingo - Season 1

Jayce and the Wheeled Warriors, Vol. 1

Voltron: Defender of the Universe - Paradise Lost (2008)

COMEDY AND LOVE Mania Style

Best of the Price is Right

Tripping the Rift: The Movie

HORROR

April Fool's Day

Beliah

Black Mass

Blue Eyes of the Broken Doll (Special Edition)

Del Tenney Triple Feature

Demonic Splatter Fest: Future Kill/Funnyman

Door into Darkness

The Dracula Saga (Special Edition)

Fingerprints

The Haunting of Rebecca Verlaine

Human Beasts (Special Edition)

James Ellroy's Feast of Death

The Living and the Dead

The Mist (Two-Disc Collector's Edition)

The Mist

Naked Beneath the Water [Blu-ray]

Shrooms

The Sister of Ursula

Terror in the Pharaoh's Tomb

Them (a.k.a. Ils)

Torture Chamber of Dr. Sadism and Death Smiles on a Murderer

The Undertow

SCIENCE FICTION / FANTASY

Sir Gawain and the Green Knight

TV LAND

Dark Angel - The Complete Series

Day Break - The Complete Series

The Invisible Man: Season One

Noble House

Painkiller Jane (6pc)

The Shield - Season 4

Sliders: The Fourth Season

The Vice: The Complete First Season

Wings - The Sixth Season

BOX SETS

Grindhouse Horror Collection Vol. 1

(Carnival of Blood/The Undertaker and His Pals/Good Against Evil/The Severed Arm/House of the Living Dead/Terror at The Red Wolf Inn/Blood Tide/Moon of The Wolf)

Hoot Gibson Westerns Collection Vol. 1

(Boiling Point/The Cowboy Counselor/Fighting Parson/Frontier Justice/Hard Hombre/Lucky Terror/Riding Avenger/Sunset Range/Wild Horse)

Texas Rangers: Collection Vol. 1

(Dead Or Alive/Enemy of The Law/Guns of The Law/Gunsmoke Mesa/Return of The Rangers/Spook Town/Three in The Saddle/Whispering Skull)

Warner Gangsters Collection, Vol. 1

(The Public Enemy / White Heat / Angels with Dirty Faces / Little Caesar / The Petrified Forest / The Roaring Twenties)

Warner Gangsters Collection, Vol. 2

(Bullets or Ballots / City for Conquest / Each Dawn I Die / G Men / San Quentin / A Slight Case of Murder)

Warner Gangsters Collection, Vol. 3

(Smart Money / Picture Snatcher / The Mayor of Hell / Lady Killer / Black Legion / Brother Orchid)


More Content By Robert T. Trate
Comments/Responses
1 2 > >>
themovielord • Mar 24, 2008, 11:14pm •
Wow all those downloads and they pull the one I use?! Here is another:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sCTe7L59-SU

rexxdart • Mar 25, 2008, 05:26am •
"Has any film ever made a sequel where the main character, who died, now survives in alternate ending then gets a sequel with him alive in it?"


Godzilla...

and he didn't need any damn alternate ending.

he was just that much of a badass

8)

hanso • Mar 25, 2008, 05:30am •
"Has any film ever made a sequel where the main character, who died, now survives in alternate ending then gets a sequel with him alive in it?"

Jason, Freddy, Michael Myers?

Bernie, that guy got a sequel and he was dead throught both films.

EagleManiac • Mar 25, 2008, 05:53am •
I never saw I Am Legend in the theaters, and I bought the 2-Disc Collectors Edition at Best Buy. Well, now I know why I had no inclination to see that movie. Basically, to me, it SUCKED. I wasted $19.99 on THAT?!?!?!? What a total piece of garbage! Will wasn't as good as I expected, and the "ghouls" were terrible!! It never did anything for me, never shocked or terrified me. Nothing. I sat through the whole mess totally bored off my ass! Again, as with so many Hollywood "re-tellings" or "remakes", this one suffered from too much emphasis on the LOOK of the film and not enough on substance. The Omega Man with Heston(though somewhat butchered when it came to the original story), was far far more enjoyable, and a superior movie! And BIG DEAL about the "Alternate Controversial Ending". The original ending was bad, so I cared NOTHING for the "Alternate" one! I give the movie half a star out of 5, AT BEST. Bad bad bad bad bad!

goirish83 • Mar 25, 2008, 06:31am •
themovielord.......thanks for the link. I watched the alternate ending, and liked it a lot more than the theatrical ending. This was a pretty good movie, but I thought the CGI monsters were terrible, and wished they had used reglar actors. The Omega Man was far superior to this.

fft5305 • Mar 25, 2008, 07:22am •
Ok, I'm confused (granted, it doesn't take much). I never got around to seeing the movie in the theater. I just saw it this weekend on DVD, but it was the regular DVD from Netflix. Was the ending I saw (where he blows himself up and Anna takes the cure to Vermont) the theatrical ending or not? What was the alternate ending? Does the 2-disc DVD not give you a choice?

Also, maybe because I was expecting something terrible after hearing it slammed so much, but I thought the CGI creatures were actually quite good. They weren't perfect, but there wasn't a moment during the movie where they were even bad enough to take me out of the movie. I think the way they moved, it would not have worked right to have real actors. CGI was the way to go and I think it worked.

irascible • Mar 25, 2008, 07:38am •
The movie was mediocre at best even though WS did a pretty good job. They have yet to do that story justice. The ending was rushed... Plus - logically he wouldn't be a LEGEND if he survived right? (the loose way to tie it to the original story - blah) Does Robert need to have a happy ending on every movie he watches? IF you're basing your like/dislike on a happy ending - ugh.

doublec • Mar 25, 2008, 08:18am •
And WHICH ending is the darker one? The one where Will Smith dies but mankind is shown to survive or the one where Smith lives but mankind's future is still somewhat in doubt? Given the similar endings to both The Invasion and The Mist (contrived happy ending for the world, if not necessarily for the main character) I like the vagueness of the alternate ending. An end of the world movie is less fun if the world DOESN'T end after all!

Hobbs • Mar 25, 2008, 08:22am •
Thanks youtube, you saved me from having to borrow or rent it to see the alternate ending. This movie fails because it didn't follow the book...it used certain ideas but man, I was hugely disappointed with this. Hollywood can thumb its nose up at us and say look at the box office numbers but trust me it had more to do with hype, wil smith, and the hope it would follow the book. That was the only reason I saw it because I figured they would finally follow the novel but I'm still sorry to say the Omega Man was closer to the book then this was. Now before i get the haters remark on the Omega Man i don't deny it wasn't perfect and was more political than anything else but i thought it was more faithful.

mckracken • Mar 25, 2008, 10:28am •
fft5305, yes the version you saw was the theatrical ending.
The reason everybody is surprised is that warner Brothers opted out of an ending that left Neville alive and willing to return for a second go-round.
While I totally disagree with the statements that EagleManiac made against Will Smith's acting abilities, (who or what were you expecting by the way?) I agree that the CGI "ghouls" were terrible and usually i dont complain about the CGI in movies but when you have a city like this, with people... real people of all types, all shapes and sizes, all ages, all different professions like electricians and police and armed forces... why do they all look like identical cookie cutter images of each other? they are all bald, translucent skin, anemic and build with the same exact physique!? please.
Also the question arises "how did Neville know his dog was immune to the airborne virus but WASNT immune to the bites of the ghouls?" it was obvious the dog was immune to the airborne virus, (duh!!) but the dog had never been bitten before so how would he have known this fact?
Will Smith joined the ranks of fellow actors like Denzel Washington and Morgan Freeman. His acting abilities are VERY GOOD, So good that he accepted a movie without any co-stars at all... how amazing is that?
Forget Eddie Murphy, forget Chris Tucker, forget Chris Rock... Will Smith delivers.

1 2 > >>
Login to post a comment!