The Anime Dilemma - Mania.com



DVD Shopping Bag

15 Comments | Add

 

Rate & Share:

 

Related Links:

 

Info:

  • Series:

The Anime Dilemma

Featuring the 1960's Gigantor

By Robert T. Trate     June 02, 2009


Gigantor from E1 Entertainment
© Mania.com/Robert Trate

 

In writing this column over the past two yeas I have written about everything from Richie Rich to Frankenstein Meets the Wolfman and Star Wars to Star Trek. Okay that isn’t that much of a leap but I have nonetheless covered a lot of topics. The one that I have been always incredibly shy on is Anime. Mania’s own Anime and Manga section is a hotbed of activity but one I have always been afraid to venture into. Why is that? I was a huge fan of Star Blazers (1979) as a kid and liked Gatchaman (1972) a lot too. They were remnants of another age recycled for the new Star Wars generation of the late seventies and early eighties but nonetheless were my first introduction to that style of animation and the storytelling. Perhaps it is because in high school and friend of mine introduced me to Urotsukidoji: Legend of the Overfiend. His older brother had given it to him and it had been required watching at his art school. Gone were the heroes, cool vehicles and epic quests. Replacing it was a lot of sex and strange sex at that. Since then all Anime has had a stigma to it for me. It probably also didn’t help that two slimy guys I used to work with raved about Anime all the time either. It just has never been something that I have had any real success with. I always seem to find the wrong thing to watch.
 
I do cover the releases each week for the Anime titles in this column but I have never had the chance to actually pick one up and review it. The reason for this is they are all part of series or have a number other than one next to their name. A week or so ago I jumped at a title called Gigantor (1964) because the first volume was being released.
 
E1 Entertainment released their first volume of the series encompassing the first 26 fully restored episodes. I am sure it is not nearly on the same level as Bubblegum Crisis or Dragon Ball Z but it had a one next to it and since it was from a simpler time, the sixties, I was sure as not to encounter any Nazi rape machines like in Urotsukidoji: Legend of the Overfiend.
 
Gigantor is a super robot, think Voltron with only one driver and even then controlled by remote control, who helps Jimmy Sparks (Billie Lou Watt)and his band of do gooders stop madmen all over the world. This band of do gooders is your typical crop of heroes from a simpler age of television. As I mentioned before there is Jimmy whose father designed and built Gigantor, Inspector Blooper (Ray Owens) our bungling yet courageous detective, Professor Bob Brilliant (Gilbert Mack) the science guy and mentor to Jimmy and of course Dick Strong (Peter Fernandez) the team’s spy. Whether they are battling The Spider or Doctor Catsmeow fear not they will perpetually prevail.
 
The first 26 episodes are all in black white and very vanilla. By vanilla I mean the stories were incredibly bland. Sure there were a few clever moments and the animation did pack a few surprises but nothing to get me super excited for volume two. The opening theme song is classic television at its best and the full 25 minute episodes pack in enough twists and turns to keep a small child thoroughly entertained. On a whole it didn’t really do anything for me. Much like an Anime fan watching Paul Leni’s The Man Who Laughs (1928) you can appreciate the art form at its very roots but it is still an old black and white film.
 
If you are a fan of Anime or even classic cartoons like Astro Boy (also voice directed by Gigantor’s Fred Ladd’s) I would recommend Gigantor. The commentary alone by Fred Ladd was incredibly enlightening as he spoke about the production costs, turn around and recording schedule of this converted low budget Japanese animated series.
 
So now I will open it up to all you Maniacs: What are some really good Anime movies and series to get into?
 
ACTION / ADVENTURE / KUNG FU/ THRILLERS / WESTERNS
 
Air Force One [Blu-ray] ~ Harrison Ford, Gary Oldman, Glenn Close, and Wendy Crewson
 
Avenging Angelo (Steelbook Packaging) ~ Sylvester Stallone, Anthony Quinn, Madeleine Stowe, and Andy Garcia
 
Dark Blue [Blu-ray] ~ Khandi Alexander, Jonathan Banks, Graham Beckel, and Eloy Casados
 
Defiance~ Daniel Craig
 
Defiance [Blu-ray]
 
Direct Contact [Blu-ray] ~ Dolph Lundgren
 
Direct Contact
 
Inside Man [Blu-ray] ~ Denzel Washington, Clive Owen, Jodie Foster, and Christopher Plummer
 
Out of Time [Blu-ray] ~ Ed Amatrudo, John Billingsley, Evelyn Brooks, and Parris Buckner
 
Rollerball [Blu-ray] ~ Damir Andrei, Naveen Andrews, Peter Blake, and Andrew Bryniarski
 
Shinobi No Mono, Vol. 4: Siege ~ Raizo Ichikawa, Yunosuke Ito, Ganjiro Nakamura, and Tomisaburo Wakayama
 
To Live and Die in L.A. [Blu-ray] ~ Christopher Allport, Anne Betancourt, Brian Bradley, and Dwier Brown
 
Treasure Raiders ~ Alexander Nevsky, David Carradine, Steven Brand, and Sherilyn Fenn
 
Walking Tall [Blu-ray] ~ John Beasley, Michael Bowen, Beverley Elliott, and Eric Keenleyside
 
ANIME
 
Chains Of Lust
 
Final Fantasy VII: Advent Children Complete [Blu-ray] ~ Takahiro Sakurai, Ayumi Ito, Shotaro Morikubo, and Maaya Sakamoto
 
Irresponsible Captain Tylor Complete TV Series Remastered DVD Collection
Maison Plaisir
 
Moribito: Guardian of the Spirit Volume 4
 
Sinners Paradise: Revelations Volume 2
 
CARTOONS
 
The Fairly Odd Parents: Season 1 (2-Disc Set)
 
The Fairly Odd Parents Season 2 (3 Disc Set)
 
Highlander: The Complete Animated Series
 
The Jetsons: Season Two, Vol. 1
 
Rugrats Season 1 (3 Disc Set)
 
Rugrats Season 2 (3 Disc Set)
 
Zeroman: The Complete Series ~ Ryan Reynolds, Leslie Nielsen, Kevin MacDonald, and Don Cherry
 
CLASSICS
 
Glory [Blu-ray] ~ Matthew Broderick, Morgan Freeman, Denzel Washington, and Andre Braugher
 
Road House [Blu-ray] ~ Laura Albert, Lisa Axelrod, Cheryl Baker, and Christopher Collins
 
COMEDY AND LOVE Mania Style
 
Bruce Almighty [Blu-ray] ~ Jim Carrey, Jennifer Aniston, Morgan Freeman, and Tony Bennett
 
Eddie Murphy: Delirious - 25th Anniversary ~ Eddie Murphy, Richard Tienken, and Robert Wachs
 
Fletch [Blu-ray] ~ Chevy Chase, Tim Matheson, Joe Don Baker, and Kareem Abdul-Jabbar
 
HORROR
 
Anacondas: Trail of Blood ~ Crystal Allen, Calin Stanciu, Linden Ashby, and Danny Midwinter
 
Elsewhere [Blu-ray] ~ Anna Kendrick, Paul Wesley, Jeff Phillips, and Shannon Holt
 
Elsewhere
 
The Legend of the Blood Castle ~ Ewa Aulin, Lucia Bosé, Lola Gaos, and Silvano Tranquilli
 
Monsturd ~ Paul Weiner, Beth West, and Dan Burr
 
Razortooth ~ Kathleen LaGue, Doug Swander, Matt Holly, and Brandon Breault
 
Retardead
 
The Secret of the Black Widow ~ Eddie Arent, Karin Dor, O.W. Fischer, and Klaus Kinski
 
Silent Venom
 
Stockholm Syndrome
 
Tied Up ~ Shelli Boone, Dana Fares, David Alan Graf, and Julia Morizawa
 
TV LAND
 
Cannon: Season Two, Vol. 1
 
The Complete Abbott And Costello Show ~ Bud Abbott
 
The Hunger: The Complete First Season ~ Daniel Craig, Lena Headey, and Jason Flemyng
 
Prison Break: Season 4 ~ Dominic Purcell, Wentworth Miller, Michael Rapaport, and Amaury Nolasco
 
Quincy, M.E.: Season 3 ~ Jack Klugman
 
Weeds - Season 4
 
Weeds: Season Four [Blu-ray]
 

COMMENTS AND RESPONSES

Showing items 1 - 10 of 15
1 2 >  >>  
StarlightGuard 6/2/2009 4:55:04 AM

well, since I'm here (and maelstrom isn't) I'll have to speak for him and myself when I spit out FINAL FANTASY ADVENT CHILDREN!!!!!!!!!! WHOOOOOOOO!!!!!!! ON BLU-RAY!!!!!!!!!! WHOOOOOOOOOO!

I posed a very similar question to Mania some months ago, movielord.

The Anime: Enlighten Me Please blog still has all of its comments where Jakester, Maelstrom, mbeckham and I had our back and forth.

Maelstrom and Mbeckham had a lot to say on this...plus a few related ideas.

hanso 6/2/2009 8:14:43 AM

Isn't anime just japanese school girls getting banged by aliens?

zaldar 6/2/2009 12:26:47 PM

Sigh...as I doubt chris will ever venture over here or much of the anime section...since most of them go pretty much straight to the forum I'll chime in.  Really the sex stuff is really easy to stay away from just stay away from anything with hentai in it.  Yes there will be fan service at some point but not nearly anythin up to the level of legend of the overfiend...shiver...that is some NASTY stuff.  I am an anime fiend and it is nasty to me.  Most anime is no where NEAR that level.  Really most of what makes anime good for me is the intelligent plots that actually make you think.

Several suggestions, if you are looking for good thought provoking action pick up Ghost in the Shell the first movie, great stuff and very thought provoking.  If you like that move onto the series Evangelion but be prepared to spend a lot of time scratching your head.

For comedy some of the best stuff is El-Hazard.  Incredibly funny and not to over the top.  Head over to the AOD recommends section for some great reccomendations on various types, we are always willing to help people find good stuff on the forums as well.  Do tell us what you watch and what you think of it, would be an interesting conversation driver and interesting to see it again for the first time through anothers eyes.

themovielord 6/2/2009 1:08:04 PM

Zaldar, thanks... I really thought there would be more recommendations. ~ Robert (column writer)

kirarakim_home 6/2/2009 1:35:54 PM

So now I will open it up to all you Maniacs: What are some really good Anime movies and series to get into?

The most important thing to understand about anime is it is not a genre but a medium made up of many genres (some that are unfortunately not well represented in the US such as anime geared towards a female audience) I can understand being shocked by something like Legend of the Overfiend (I personally have never seen it as I avoid titles like that but I know of it). But judging anime by that would be the same thing as someone who never saw any live action movies and the first one they saw was some pornographic movie and thinking all movies are like that. You see what I am getting at.

Anyways some good introductory titles: Cowboy Bebop, Any Studio Ghibli Movie (just look it up on Wiki for a full list) Fullmetal Alchemist seem to be good things to start with as they are pretty mainstream and accessible. The Girl Who Leapt Through Time is also a well done movie that recently came out.

As for something that is less mainstream but good and very realistic science fiction try Planetes

A good fantasy/romance adventure series combined with mecha from the 90's is Vision of Escaflowne. Although it does seem to be a hit or miss with many people. But then again that is true for pretty much every anime. Contrary to what some people might think anime fans opinions vary quite a bit.

If you like philosophy or a series that is more than meets the eye Kino's Journey is a very good one.

Mushi-shi is also a fairly recent well done series that explores man's relationship with nature and his environment. It is a slow moving series as a warning but it is definitely very original & unique and feels very much like a Japanese folk tale. You can actually watch this Online for free on Hulu.

Well I hope those suggestions help. There is no guarantee that you will like these series/movies but I hope they help demonstrate that anime is actually very diverse and not just Pokemon, extreme violence or animated porn.

 

hanso 6/2/2009 2:14:08 PM

The only anime I've ever enjoyed is Kenshin Himura Legend of the Wandering Samurai aka Samurai X.

That shit was hella sweet. 

Laton 6/2/2009 2:22:00 PM

 Kirarakim already mentioned a good variety of anime titles, so I just wanted to add a few thoughts on getting into anime.
I started into anime seven years ago. I didn't saw pokemon, sailor moon or any other show on TV before that. Anime was almost non existing for me.
So what got me into anime was an internet search for a music video. I never found what I was looking for, but I downloaded a few anime music videos for fun. "Tainted Donuts" was at fault. :-) The music video took pieces of tho anime shows, Cowboy Bebop and Trigun, and I was thinking: "Hey, this looks interesting!"
So, looked up a few fan subs and... was sold! It only took me two days to consider it and I bought both collection boxes of Cowboy Bebop and Trigun. (About 400$ at that time! *gulp*)
But I never regreted my decision. My husband and I were sold on anime, completely! We bought about 800 DVDs in the last seven years, and I'm still looking for new interesting titles to buy.
I also got a few friends into anime. Cowboy Bebop and Trigun worked really well for them too. But it really depends on personal preference. Some titles are great, but you will only understand them after watching other anime titles. 
In the end anime is not really a genre, but more of a medium. Using animation anything is possible from comedy to horror to science fiction to slice of life shows and so on. You just have to find the right title for you. (And as pointed out earlier, the list of kirakarim is great way to start out.)
So, just give it a try, it's really worth it! :-)

Kellory 6/2/2009 2:27:12 PM

As Kirarakim said, Anime is a medium.  Just like US TV has a variety of different types of shows, so does Anime.  It is not limited to just a few genre's, it encompasses many different ones from Action to Romance to Horror.  There are thousands of discs available and that doesnt even include the Hentai stuff.  I've got over 800 different titles and there isnt a single hentai disc in the entire collection.  We have an entire forum dedicated to that here at Mania.  Just drop down the Anime/Manga tab to the Forums.

Indeed narrowing down what someone would like or recommend largely depends on one's tastes in shows, not just what is "good" or "bad" as one person's good is another person's bad. 

Pretty much any of the Studio Ghibli movies are good for starters though.  They are among the best of the movies.  But there are also OVA's that are similar.  An OVA is simply 1-6 episodes that may range from 20-60 minutes in length.  Occasionally you have longer OVA series, but most are short.  One of the better ones is Gunbuster which is an almost classic science fiction story.  Voices of a Distant Star is another good movie, this one in fact made by a single guy on a Macintosh alone over the course of a few years.  He has several other movies out such as Place Promised in Our Early Days and 5cm Per Second.  Voices is a movie about love across both space and time.  Place Promised is a story of fulfilling a promise made between friends.  And 5cm is a coming of age story.  They're all different and liking one does not necessarily mean you'll like the others, but many hold up to shows like UP or even Wall-E.

You have TV shows that talk about Existentialism like Ghost in the Shell.  Shows that look at what it is to be human, is it how you talk?  How you act?  Can a machine be human?  In many ways very Bladerunnerish.  And there are other shows like that as well.

Did you want horror?  Ghost Hunt is pretty much classic horror with a fair bit of humor mixed in appropriately.  It has a X-Files feel to it while keeping the horror aspect.  Then there is When They Cry which at first glance is often taken as a cutesy type show but is really horror/mystery as it runs through multiple arcs where the characters do things slightly differently over the same month period and end up with different results.  Very much like a horror version of Groundhog's Day.  With bats and machete's.

Have you ever wanted that insane teacher that none of the other teachers like, but somehow makes going to school fun because mentally he is your age?  Great Teacher Onizuka is just that.  An ex-gang member who just wants to get laid and make enough money to live on.  While imparting no life lessons on his students other than to live for themselves and not for some weird expectation. Which may be the greatest and hardest lesson to learn.

You have real drama shows like Rumbling Hearts which is about a guy and his girlfriend who gets into an accident and is in a coma for 5 years.  And how he and his girlfriend's best friend copes with it, and how his girlfiend has to cope with a new reality when she finally wakes up.  No punches are pulled in the show as mistakes are made and the consequences have to be faced later.

You have shows like Utena which focus less on the plot and more on symbolism.  In a manner that even many Indie films still struggle to this day.  David Lynch probably does not do it as well as Utena did.

You have your bloody blow them up type shows like Gantz and Elfen Lied.  You have romance shows like Emma which is set in the Victorian age between an upper class gentleman and a lower class maid, and the types of prejudice they have to face and the pressures from society and family.  You have shows like Aria which are just meant to be fun and cute and literally put you to sleep with a smile.  Crazy energetic shows like School Rumble or Azumanga Diaoh which are shorts that are just generally insane and comedic.  You have shows like Zegapain which is very much like the Matrix, but with more emphasis on what it means to be human, and loss.  Then there are shows like Zipang which is much like the old movie Final Countdown except from the Japanese point of view.  If you were a Japanese naval officer in command of a modern Aegis class destroyer and were sent back to World War II what would you do?  Knowing that Japan is better off today than it would have been, that the world is better off for the most part, but also knowing hundreds of thousands of your countrymen will die?  What would you do?

Then there are the shows like Death Note which is very much like a Sherlock Holmes mystery with two masterminds battling it out, both convinced they are both better than the other and on the side of right.  It is shows like this that shows the true face of evil.  Very much like how Darth Vader was not evil because he killed a lot of people, a bear can kill a lot of people, but it was his belief that he was right and how his beliefs were subverted that really made him evil.  Not beyond redemption of course, but evil in a way a mindless killer never could be.

So yes, Anime runs the gamut of dozens of genres and there are literally hundreds of titles to choose from within those genres.  None of which may have to do with sex or tentecles or porn, or are even for kids.  Many of these shows are not for children even if there is no sex or blood just due to the situations and the resolutions.  It's all entertainment of course, but even entertainment can have serious sides.

Ejanss_home 6/2/2009 9:22:35 PM

I'll second Kellory's post even though it was long, but then, there's a lot of issues here to talk about--

Some longtime fans may giggle at the article (no offense!), since it displays EVERY cliche of the First Time Anime Fan who's gotten a bum steer for advice and media perceptions--Let's review a few of the classics:

Perception #1: "I've heard of anime...I remember Battle of the Planets and Gigantor!"  - Well, I remember Battle of the Planets too--It was thirty years ago.  And Gigantor was forty.  (And Bubblegum Crisis was twenty!)  Think you may have guessed, things have changed a little since then, and if you only want to watch what you saw as a kid, well, that's on disk too. 

Perception #2:  "Anime?...Isn't that, like schoolgirls and tentacles, 'n stuff?" - Boy, haven't heard those since the anime-scare articles of the mid-90's, back when the mainstream didn't know what to make of anime, but assumed it had to be just as evil and foreign as Pokemon...  ;)  Fact is, like bad Skinemax direct-video thrillers make up a small and embarrassing percentage of American movies, "hentai" makes up a forgettable and very crappily made percentage of anime, since "real" anime is normally intended for movies and television, just as our animation is.  That's how industries work on both sides of the Pacific--Just that one makes a cooler shock-story in the news, and louder giggles from those who haven't heard about it.  (And if anyone recommends it to a first-timer, oh please, that joke went out years ago...)

Perception #3:  "Anime?...Cool, is it going to be all bloody, with samurais and ninjas 'n stuff?" - Maybe.   Or it could be sci-fi, or sports, or romantic drama, or kids fantasy, or even insane comedy.  Since it's just as big corporate industry as comics, anime is in the business of having Something for Everybody, and boy, does it ever.

And now that we've gotten those cliche's out of the way, let's talk about the bad recommendations:

Bad recommendation #1 - "Have you seen Akira/Ghost in the Shell yet?"  - Some fans are permanently trapped in 1996, back when only six or seven titles were on disk, and fans hypnotized themselves into believing this was the Required Reading list for anime, even into 2009.  Maybe they are classics...But there's a lot more on the shelf now, don't feel you HAVE to rush.

Bad recommendation #2:  "Have you seen Metropolis/Paprika/(bad inscrutable Sony arthouse movie) yet?" - Unfortunately, when fans get recommending, there is still a lot of the Blind Leading the Blind--Some fans haven't even gotten into DVD TV-series yet, and still believe that Anime is whatever arthouse movie Roger Ebert gives a 10 to.  Let's just say it's not a representative sample:  Since anime is "commercial", Japanese directors want to do "Art" for their big-budget features.  And sometimes, you just want good old fashioned mainstream genre junk food.  (The one thing the movie-onlies will also auto-recommend is the entire string of Disney-dubbed Studio Ghibli films by Hayao Miyazaki, and don't worry, they're okay--Absolutely painless, not to mention classics.  And while Disney owns Spirited Away, they don't happen to own The Castle of Cagliostro, so don't let that one slip by.)

Bad recommendation #3: "Are you watching (insert Cartoon Network show here)"  - Yes, you can get some anime for free on late-night CN.  I'm one of those fans who thinks what they get is not very GOOD:  CN tends to have only one taste, for noir action (since Bleach and Full Metal Alchemist are their ratings leaders), and tend to ignore all other genres..When CN does a comedy, they want it to be as stoner/pottymouthed as their own Swim shows, and probably aren't aware of some of the "normal" shows out there.  It's a pretty darn skewed sample on their channel too, and frankly, something about their "wacky" title cards suggest they don't seem to wild about the genre either.

Okay, so what CAN fans recommend?

Since it's mostly action and Blockbuster rentals on your list, we've had some good suggestions for Ghost Hunt and Death Note; they're as "American" genre as you can get and still stay in the Cool Anime zone.

And since nobody's recommended comedy yet, I'll throw in Azumanga Daioh (or "What if Charles Schulz wrote an anime, and turned the Peanuts gang into Tokyo high-school girls?)--In addition to being cute and silly, the gags in this one are maniacally original...Highly addictive, and just about the best ambassador for "Anime that still looks Japanese" out there.

(And in September, keep a lookout for Sgt. Frog, possibly one of the most insane G-rated anime comedies ever made.  Period.  And while it helps to know a few of the old-school robot-fleet epics like Gundam and Robotech aka Macross to truly appreciate the jokes, being geezer enough to remember Star Blazers should get by.)

Oh, and did we mention that Mania.com also hosts one of the legendary anime websites AnimeonDVD.com?  Yeah, we were the experts long before you had your site, pal, and when the call went out, its fans responded.  We've been helping first-timers from way back.  :)

themovielord 6/3/2009 10:15:35 AM

 

Aweome, thanks guys.. I am filling up the net flix queue...

1 2 >  >>  

ADD A COMMENT

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Please click here to login.

POPULAR TOPICS