The Mumbling Kitsune


Anime's Best, Sort Of (Part One)

By: Nadia Oxford, Columnist
Date: Thursday, January 24, 2008

First, it would be appropriate to warn all you good readers that there are various spoilers afoot in today's column. Second, it's vital to warn everyone to take this list with a grain of salt.

I was commissioned elsewhere to put together a video list of "Anime's Ten Best Moments" (link pending). I'm really a wuss when it comes to bullying people into thinking my way. I'm one of those people who mumble, "Well shucks, I guess everyone has their own preferences." It's true. Even I have guilty pleasures like Waterworld.

 

Anime's been around for a long time, so fishing out and deciding on the ten "best" moments was no small task. Adding to the complication is the fact that I had to provide a working video link for each selection. Some anime (Neon Genesis Evangelion for example) is hard to find on YouTube, because even three-minute clips are hunted down and shot off the server.

Long story short: I did the best I could and I wasn't allowed to weasel the list into a collection of "Ten Greatest Moments in Anime."

Well, what's life without controversy? Here are my first five choices. Next week we'll count down from four to one--unless I decide to stick it to the Man by mixing up the numbers or something.

10. The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya - The Ending Dance

Believe it or not, The Melancholy of etc. is an anime I have yet to fully indulge in. When it comes to comedy anime, I'm hit or miss. I loved the high school exploits in Azumanga (I loved the manga even more), but for the most part I'm not interested in visual gags and puns, which anime relies heavily upon.

I do know, however, that I love the now-famous dance that ends the anime. It's so bloody cheerful, it perks me right up no matter how foul of a mood I'm in. It earns its place on this list.

9. The Big O - Big O versus Big Duo

Mecha is a staple of anime, and not surprisingly the genre is oversaturated. A lot of great stuff has gone unnoticed in favour of Evangelion and Escaflowne, and one of those forgotten heroes is The Big O. Imagine Batman: The Animated Series with steampunk mechs. Pretty good stuff. Definitely unusual. The Big O hosted some great fight scenes as well as some great music. The final battle of Season One was a particular favourite of mine.

8. South Park - Let's Fighting Love

 

"Hey, that's not!--"

Yeah, I know. South Park ain't anime. South Park is … well, hard to describe, but it's certainly its own thing. Still, I couldn't in good conscience exclude the classic fight scene from the episode "Fun With Weapons;" It's probably the greatest parody of anime in existence. Most anime parodies are content to give their characters big watery eyes and bad voices, but Trey Parker and Matt Stone take it far beyond that with a cheesy J-pop song that combines Japanese and nonsensical English (all sung by Stone, who studied in Japan) in an unholy union familiar to any fan of the medium. What's more, South Park has always portrayed the dark side of childhood with eerie accuracy, and Fun With Weapons especially nails it. The boys "transform" into their anime personas when their imagination submerges them in their ninja fantasy, but the illusion quickly shatters when adults are present. It's like a reverse Calvin and Hobbes.

7. Dragon Ball Z - Gohan Goes Super Saiyan

Logically, you can substitute this scene for any transformation scene in the Dragon Ball or Dragon Ball Z series--I think most of them equally rock because they're all so fun and ridiculous. I actually scoured the Internet for a movie of Goku's first transition into a man-eating oozaru, but I couldn't find one. A shame, that…it's an excellent dark twist in an otherwise lighthearted anime.

When it came down to the wire though, I narrowed my favourite Super Saiyan moments to Gohan's and Trunks. With Trunks, it gets messy because he has two futures that branch depending on the status of the Androids that take over the world in the Cell Saga. In the "good" future, Trunks literally goes Super Saiyan for the hell of it, much to the astonishment of his father, Vegeta. In the "bad" future, he goes Super Saiyan with the death of Gohan, his mentor. In the end I got a headache after too much thinking and just went with Gohan.

6. The Last Unicorn - Opening Montage

I did an extensive write-up of The Last Unicorn some months ago for Mania (I also met Peter Beagle at 2007's Otakon, and I nearly flew to the moon). The movie does qualify as anime, having been animated by the precursor of Miyazaki's Studio Ghibli. It's also one of the most beloved animated movies of all time and well-remembered, particularly the opening's creative use of the Unicorn Tapestries.

The truth is, the majority of animated fantasy movies suck eggs. The quality of Last Unicorn remains something of a legend in itself, something I came to realise as I sat through the painfully mediocre Dragonlance movie. Sigh…

5. Kimba The White Lion - Kimba Swims Home

Of course, I had to include something by Osamu Tezuka, the father of manga. If you're less than forty years old, you probably didn't grow up with Kimba, but the animation quality for the era was pretty impressive. In the clip, Kimba escapes captivity and swims home to Africa with some moral assurance from his mother's ghost. It's a touching scene on its own (God only knows what lurks below the ocean surface in blackest night), but there's a scratchy, retro charm to the animation and soundtrack that can't be denied. I can just imagine my father sitting and watching Kimba struggling against weariness and loneliness…except I don't think my father watched much television as a child. Way he tells me, he spent his early years starting a lot of fires.

The first countdown is complete. Don't agree with me? Maybe you'll have better luck next week. In fact, I'm willing to bet on it, space cowboy. Until then…


More Content By Nadia Oxford, Columnist
Live Action Akira & More Cosplay
(Thursday, February 21, 2008)
MUSHISHI, VOLUME 3
(Tuesday, February 19, 2008)
MINIMA, VOLUME #1
(Monday, February 18, 2008)
Sympathy for the Cosplayer
(Thursday, February 14, 2008)
Robotech Retrospective
(Saturday, February 9, 2008)
V.B. Rose, Volume One
(Saturday, February 9, 2008)
Manga Sutra, Volume One
(Monday, February 4, 2008)
Le Chevalier d'Eon, Volume Three
(Saturday, February 2, 2008)
Shin Megami Tensei Kahn, Volume One
(Thursday, January 31, 2008)
The Best of Anime, Sort Of (Part Two)
(Thursday, January 31, 2008)
Comments/Responses
1
mbeckham1 • Jan 24, 2008, 06:58am •
I love Big O. I ran across it on Adult Swiim years ago when I got my first DVD recoder and was desperate to get some free anime. At the time at least cost of Anime series on DVD in America was ridiculous. And the look did indeed instantly remind me of Batman: The Animated Series, if anything evn more 1930s film noir goth.

Instantly loved all the main characters, particularly R. Dorthy Wayneright. Roger Smith's sarky narration set just the right tone and his friendship with Major Dastun as well as his relationships with Dorthy and his "bulter" Norman give him just the right degree of warmth and humanity.

Dorthy's persistent stoicism and unfailing loyalty have a charm all there own, whenever she's on screen, you won't want to take your eyes off her.

In addition to great characters intrgues abound in Paradigm City, the setting, and you'll never know what's what until the end, or possibly even after.

nadiaoxford • Jan 24, 2008, 07:29am •
I remember my husband taped the entire series one month when visiting the States, because we have yet to get the show in Canada (I'm not holding my breath, that's for sure). I loved how different it was--I believe hearing or reading at some point that it is an actual Japanese tribute to Batman: TAS. As far as Mecha goes, I prefer it over pretty much everything else; it has its silly moments, but it's still 100% dignified.

gauleyboy420 • Jan 24, 2008, 09:15am •
I can't believe Cowboy Beebop (the greatest Anime of all time IMHO) didn't get a mention, there are sooooo many top 10 moments in it.
Maybe I'm biased because it's one of the very few Anime shows I can watch. It's sooooo good.

Merin • Jan 24, 2008, 09:21am •
Big O is such an amazing show. Not the best out there, but so unique. It is like Blade Runner mixed with Dark City and, yes, the Batman Animated Series tossed in for good measure. All with a giant robot.

SO GOOD.

And the music, too. "Big O, Big O Big O Big O" Heh.

Last Unicorn is a classic, for certain.

Personally I cannot stand Dragonball anything, so I'll skip that.

(As you mentioned Azumanga, I'll also toss in a "awesome" in that direction. My wife and I were just watching a couple episodes of that last night!)

galaga51 • Jan 24, 2008, 12:55pm •
gauley... please note the lack of numbers 1 through 4, above, and the reference in the final sentence. But I'm with ya, if Bebop doesn't make the top 4, I'll ask Ed to fix that.

Side question: This article is currently located in the Books section... Am I missing something?

gauleyboy420 • Jan 24, 2008, 01:26pm •
Yeah I'm kinda out of it today, PLUS I just noticed the sign off, "Space Cowboy", sweeeeet

nadiaoxford • Jan 24, 2008, 01:55pm •
Merin: Azumanga is a lot of fun because it's cute and funny, but there's a good deal of realism in there, too. Sakaki, for instance, has a real "tough girl" vibe and everyone is a bit scared of her...but in reality she's actually very shy.

My favourite Azumanga moment is actually manga exclusive: Chiyo and Osaka work together at McDonalds, and the following exchange takes place between them:

Chiyo: "I think Miss Sakaki is more like a housecat than a jaguar."

Osaka: "...Is a jaguar like a tiger?"

Chiyo: "Huh? No, a jaguar is a jaguar."

Osaka: "...A cheetah?"

Chiyo: "No, a *jaguar.*"

BeerBastard • Jan 24, 2008, 04:42pm •
I hope to see some of these animes represented in the top 4:

Kenshin
Monster
Cowboy Bebop (seeing your article this seems to be the case)
Hellsing
One Piece
Hunter X Hunter
Kurau Phantom Memory
Full Metal Panic!
Fullmetal Alchemist
Hoshi no Koi (Voice from a Distant Star)
Twelve Kingdoms
Great Teacher Onizuka
Gurren Lagann
Ghost in the Shell
Hajime no Ippo

Well that's enough...

Merin • Jan 24, 2008, 09:12pm •
That is so totally Osaka. Wife and I just watched more Azumanga tonight. We've almost finished the series (for the third time, I believe.)

I'm more into some of the older (not VERY old, but older) series like Bubblegum Crisis, Ah! My Goddess, Kimagure Orange Road, and so on. As each year passes I like the current crop of anime less and less. I think the last series I picked up (still haven't finished it) was Scrapped Princess. It's ok, I'm enjoying it, but it doesn't compare to some of the stuff I really like.

Well, I hope to see a Lodoss Wars or a .Hack scene listed soon. I already know the Firefly of anime is coming (with an Edward scene, I hope.)

1
Login to post a comment!