PDA

View Full Version : [US DVD] Akane iro ni Somaru Saka Complete Collection Review


Chris Beveridge
03-08-2011, 05:48 AM
http://cdn-www.mania.com/content_pics/000006/07/64/e334a35d89c006de_thumb.jpgReview by Chris Beveridge (http://www.mania.com/akane-iro-ni-somaru-saka-complete-collection_article_126861.html)



Mania Grade: C




In Summary:
Akasaka is a show that definitely shows its gaming roots, but what its biggest problem turns out to be is that it doesn't exactly have all that interesting of a story to tell. None of the characters are all that interesting and the situations are fairly well forced throughout. It's the kind of show where even at twelve episodes, each one is largely forgettable after you see it. What isn't forgettable is the OVA that's included which actually calls itself a hardcore OVA as it puts all of the characters on a beach resort and proceeds to really raunch it up. It's actually pretty impressive the level of dirtiness that's used here, but it also shows just how bland the main show is. Akasaka is one of those rather disposable shows that doesn't have a lot gong for it beyond being competent at best. It's a show that's a hard sell in general and the lengthy title doesn't help it either, even if it doesn't translate well into English.

The Great Bear
03-08-2011, 06:38 AM
So this one would only be worth a rental, at best?

Suwako Moriya
03-08-2011, 08:46 AM
I think for the most part is the show worked fine as background noise. Not that's saying much to be honest.

I still think the real problem came with the ending. It would have worked better had there been proper build up to it. Instead it was a twist for the sake of having a twist.

pianocello
03-08-2011, 10:21 AM
So this one would only be worth a rental, at best?

Not the worst there is but this is truly a mediocre show not even worth a rental. I'd even hesitate recommending anyone to watch this for free.

Senku
03-10-2011, 08:04 PM
So this one would only be worth a rental, at best?

I'd say for fans of these types of shows, a rental or a purchase would be fine; as there are worse shows then this one in the genre.

But if you know the formula, and are looking for something that changes it up a bit, then I would steer clear and wouldn't worry about it too much.

superdry
03-10-2011, 10:36 PM
So this one would only be worth a rental, at best?

I'd say for fans of these types of shows, a rental or a purchase would be fine; as there are worse shows then this one in the genre.


Or, if you're a huge fan of Rie Kugimiya then it would be a purchase. =D

Suwako Moriya
03-10-2011, 10:45 PM
Or, if you're a huge fan of Rie Kugimiya then it would be a purchase. =D

I have to admit that's a good part of the reason I watched it. Darn it, three things could have improved it.

First, being two cour to give time for things to work.

Second, some episodes of substance and fleshing out some girls.

Third, an ending that was actually fitting in the context of what happened before.