Identifying the Magical Girls

[ooks]

As a response to something in the Pretty Cure Max Heart Thread, Mimi Masuko gave me an idea to start a thread trying to identify each and every magical girl in the picture. So, here (http://pya.cc/pyaimg/pimg.php?imgid=21798) is the link. If you have any magical girls to add, that'd also be great. Let's get started!

[something]

::looks at bottom right-center, points to avatar, then to sig::

A lot of them are familiar, if not by name then by series or just having seen pcitures before, but I doubt I could name any that everyone else couldn't as well. I just had to point out Mitsuki because, of course, she's awesome.

[Suwako Moriya]

*Copy and Paste from the said thread*

The very top left is Comet-san from Cosmic Baton Girl Comet San. Next to her is Komugi from Magical Nurse Witch Komugi. I have no idea who is next to her. Below those three are girls that look familiar, but I can't place them. Nor can I place the girls on the top right.

Below the girls that I could not identify that are blow Comet-san herself is a blonde girl I can't identify. However below her is Fuu, Hikaru, and Umi from Magic Knight Rayearth. To the right are the girls from Tokyo Mew Mew. I don't know who the girls above them are.

To the right of Tokyo Mew Mew and the girls I'm not certain about are set of images from series I don't recognize. To the right of that is of course Sailor Moon and the Inner Senshi. Below Sailor Moon you can see Wedding Peach. To the right of Wedding Peach are girls I can't recognize. Directly below Wedding Peach, but on the left is the main girl of Saint Tail. No idea who the girl to the left of her is. Going even further right I can't recognize any more of the girls.

Below the Magic Knight Rayearth girls is Jeanne of Kamikaze Kaitou Saint Jeanne. Below her are the girls from Powerpuff Girls Z. Heh I wonder how far along that is. I'm not sure who the girl to the right is. To the right of her is Nagisa and Honoka from Pretty Cure. To the right of them is Sakura from Cardcaptor Sakura. No idea who the girl next to her is.

The girl below the Powerpuff Girls, I don't recognize. I don't recognize the girl to the right of her either. However to the right of that girl is Raine and Fine from Futago Hime. To the right of them is the girls from Magical Doremi.

Below the girl I can't recognize who is below the Powerpuff Girls. She's of course Chacha from Akazukin Chacha. To the top right of her are Chocolate and Vanilla from Sugar Rune. Below Chocolate is the main female of "My Wife is a Magical Girl". Below Vanilla is Sasami of Magical Project S and below her is Nanoha from Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha.

I have no idea who is below the girls from Futago Hime. However to the right of her and below the Doremi girls as already mentioned are the girls from Mahou Tsukai Tai. As already mentioned I can't tell who is to the right of those girls.

Below Chacha is Hime from Hime-chan no Ribbon I believe. To the left of her are girls I can't recognize. Below them are Eva, Alice, and Shiela from Mahou Shoujo Tai Alice. To the right of them is Kiki from Kiki's Delivery Service. To the right of her is Mitsuki from Full Moon Wo Sagashite. To the right of her is Kanzaki Meirin from Dr. Rin ni Kiitemite! aka Ask Dr. Rin

Finally to the right of Kanzaki Meirin is The Legendary Nurse Angel herself. Yes Ririka from Nurse Angel Ririka S.O.S. Now worship her awesomeoness. What?

Edit: Okay I edited the post from the original version somewhat.

[AbeChinchilla]

Okay... from top to bottom (left to right), this is what I got:

Top - Kogumi (Nurse Witch Kogumi)
Top right - Honey Kisaragi (Cutey Honey)

Row 3 - (right) Sailor Soldiers (Sailor Moon)
Row 3 - (far right) Honey Kisaragi (Cutey Honey Flash)

Row 4 - (far left) Rayearth (Magic Knights Rayearth)
Row 4 - Tokyo Mew Mew
Row 4 - (center-ish) Wedding Peach
Row 4 - (under Wedding Peach) St. Tail

Row 5 - Powerpuff Girls (anime)
Row 5 - Pretty Cute (center)
Row 5 - Sakura Kinomoto (Cardcaptor Sakura) (right)

Row 7 - Pretty Sammy (Magical Project S) (very small pic)
Row 7 - (right) the girls of Magical Girls' Club

Row 8 - Kiki (Kiki's Delivery Service) (center)

[Isuzu Inugami]

[ QUOTE ]
Mimi Masuko said:
To the right of them is Sakura from Cardcaptor Sakura. No idea who the girl next to her is.

[/ QUOTE ]

That's Miho from Fancy Lala! I have no idea about the other unknowns, though.

[Suwako Moriya]

[ QUOTE ]
Shimauma said:That's Miho from Fancy Lala! I have no idea about the other unknowns, though.

[/ QUOTE ]

Thanks. Well we're getting closer to identifying all the girls. At least I was able to figure out most of them. I'm not sure if that's a good sign or a bad sign.

[ooks]

Row 1: Comet, Komugi, Yui, Akko, Lalabel, LunLun, Meg, Honey

2: Pelsia Emi Yumi Mami

3: Maribel, Girls from MMMPP, Minky Momo, Sailor Moon and the Inner senshi, Cutey Honey

4: Rayearth, Mew Mew, Fun Fun Pharmacy, Minky Momo, (under) Sally, Wedding Peach, (under) I think it's something with 'Abuki', next to that is Saint Tail, then two pictures of Akko-chan

5: Jeanne, (under) Powerpuff Girls, next one looks like somebody from Youkoso Yoko, Pretty Cure, CardCaptor Sakura, Miho/Fancy Lala

6: Sweet Mint, Esper Mami, Fine and Rain, Doremi Girls

7: ChaCha, Sugar Sugar Rune, Okusama wa Mahou Shoujo, Pretty Sammy, Nanoha, Tickle, Sally, Mahou Tsukai Tai!, another title I don't know..

8: Himeko, Chappy, Arisu girls, Mako-chan, Kiki, Mitsuki/Full Moon, Dr. Rin, Ririka

...Wow...I didn't know I could do that. lol.

[ayareiko]

Added Yui of Corrector Yui, she to the right of Komugi

A summery:

Uppermost group--

Top left: Comet-san of "Cosmic Baton Girl Comet San", Komugi of "Nurse Witch Komugi", Yui of "Corrector Yui"
Bottom left: ??
Right: "Cutey Honey"

2nd Uppermost group--
Far left Top: ??
Far left Bottom: "Magic Knight Rayearth"
Left-Center Top: ??
Left-Center Bottom: "Tokyo Mew Mew"
Right Top: ??, "Sailormoon", ??
Right-Center Bottom (Clockwise from left): ??, ??, "Wedding Peach", ??, "Saint Tail", ??, ??
Far Right: ??, ??

Center group--
Left (Clockwise from top-left): Jeanne of "Kamikaze Kaitou Saint Jeanne", ??, "Powerpuff Girls Z"
Center to Right: "Pretty Cure", "Cardcaptor Sakura", Miho of "Fancy Lala"

Bottom Left Group--
Top: ??, ??
Middle (Clockwise from left): Chacha of "Akazukin Chacha", Chocolate and Vanilla of "Sugar Rune", ??, Sasami of "Magical Project S" {above}, Nanoha of "Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha" {below}, Agnes of "My Wife is a Magical Girl"
Bottom (Clockwise from left): Hime of "Hime-chan no Ribbon", ??, ??, "Mahou Shoujo Tai Alice"

Bottom Center Group--
Top to Bottom: "Futago Hime", ??, Kiki of "Kiki's Delivery Service"

Bottom Right Group--
Top: "Magical Doremi"
Middle: "Magic Users Club", ??
Bottom: Mitsuki of "Full Moon wo Sagashite", Kanzaki Meirin of "Dr. Rin ni Kiitemite!", Ririka of "Nurse Angel Ririka S.O.S."

[TnAdct1]

The mahou shoujo that I can recognize:

Row 1: Comet-San, Nurse Witch Komugi, Cutey Honey (1970's)
Row 2: None
Row 3: Pichi Pichi Pitch, Sailor Moon, Cutey Honey (2000's)
Row 4: Tokyo Mew Mew, Fushigi Mahou Fan Fan Pharmacy, Wedding Peach
Row 5: Magic Knight Rayearth, Kaito St. Tail
Row 6: Kamikaze Kaito Jeanne, Precure, Cardcaptor Sakura
Row 7: Powerpuff Girls
Row 8: Fushigi Boshi, Ojamajo Doremi
Row 9: Akazukin Cha Cha
Row 10/11: My Wife is a Mahou Shoujo, Pretty Sammy, Mahou Shoujo Lyrcical Nanaho, Magic Users Club
Row 12: Kiki's Delivery Service, Full Moon no Sagashite

Girls that should be in this picture IMO: Negi's Pactio girls (at least Asuna and Nodoka), the mahou shoujo from Pani Poni Dash, and Yuki's mother from Megatokyo /images/graemlins/sdsmiley.gif

[something]

[ QUOTE ]
TnAdct1 said:
the mahou shoujo from Pani Poni Dash

[/ QUOTE ]

Behoimi! Haha, yes, she most certainly should be in any magical girl collage.

[Isuzu Inugami]

[ QUOTE ]
ooks said:
Cutey Honey



[/ QUOTE ]

Oh!
duh!
[beats self in the head with a magic stick]

[Suwako Moriya]

[ QUOTE ]
disarm said:Behoimi! Haha, yes, she most certainly should be in any magical girl collage.

[/ QUOTE ]

I third this wonderful choice. Also as a fan of the girls from Rabuge especially the five from Gedou Otome Tai. I would have liked to see them as well. Still I suspect several girls didn't make it in partially because of when the image was made. Still I guess each of us are happy some girls made it in. While yearning for more.

[ooks]

So right now, basically all we need is:

The girl below the Wedding Peach girls, next to Saint Tail (I feel like I have a pretty good idea of who she is...)

The girl in between the PuriKyua girls and Jeanne from Kamikaze Kaitou Jeanne (Once again, I think she's from Yokoso Youko)

The girl below the Doremi girls, next to the girls of Mahou Tsukai Tai! (I have no idea)

Help!

[rainking187]

If someone can read japanese, I believe this (http://pya.cc/pyaimg/pimg.php?imgid=22245&msgfull=yes) may identify them.

[Suwako Moriya]

[ QUOTE ]
rainking187 said:
If someone can read japanese, I believe this (http://pya.cc/pyaimg/pimg.php?imgid=22245&msgfull=yes) may identify them.

[/ QUOTE ]

Ah cool. Hopefully that will turn out to be the case, but since I can't read Japanese, I can't say for sure either way. At least hope has been given.

[Ty]

A lot of older shows in there, wow. They have a really nice pose for Sakura from CCS though. /images/graemlins/catgirl0.gif

[Fencedude]

The image fails for not having Nanoha and Fate.

[ooks]

[ QUOTE ]
Fencedude said:
The image fails for not having Nanoha and Fate.

[/ QUOTE ]

Do you mean together? Nanoha's in there, near Sammy.

[Fencedude]

[ QUOTE ]
ooks said:
[ QUOTE ]
Fencedude said:
The image fails for not having Nanoha and Fate.

[/ QUOTE ]

Do you mean together? Nanoha's in there, near Sammy.

[/ QUOTE ]

Jesus! I almost needed a magnifying glass to see that.

Ok, fails for no Fate and fails for making Nanoha microscopic.

[The Pirate Queen]

[ QUOTE ]
ooks said:
Akko, Lalabel, LunLun, Meg, Honey



[/ QUOTE ]

Bless you. I was feeling the lack of old-school love. /images/graemlins/catgirl0.gif

[ooks]

[ QUOTE ]
Dani said:
[ QUOTE ]
ooks said:
Akko, Lalabel, LunLun, Meg, Honey



[/ QUOTE ]

Bless you. I was feeling the lack of old-school love. /images/graemlins/catgirl0.gif

[/ QUOTE ]

I know how you feel, lol...

But the picture was missing two other old-school magical girls: Sarutobi Ecchan and Limit-chan.

[Suwako Moriya]

[ QUOTE ]
Fencedude said:Ok, fails for no Fate and fails for making Nanoha microscopic.

[/ QUOTE ]

Exactly! Although at least Nanoha made it on there. Although as stated before some people have to deal with the fact their girl is either not well known enough or the image was made before the girl existed.

Still at least I can give some of the magical girls I like a presence whenever I used the said girl as an avatar. Heh I've used several magical girls as avatars by now. Especially recently.

[EmperorBrandon]

Dangit!!! Can't see the picture here... Guess I'll have to wait until I get home in a few days...

[Mononoke]

[ QUOTE ]
rainking187 said:
If someone can read japanese, I believe this (http://pya.cc/pyaimg/pimg.php?imgid=22245&msgfull=yes) may identify them.

[/ QUOTE ]
It does. In order from L-R (though most of them you already know):

Row 1:
Comet-san
Komugi
Corrector Yui
Himitsu no Akko-chan
Mahou Shoujo Lalabel
Hana no Ko Lunlun
Majokko Meg-chan
Cutey Honey
Mahou no Yousei Persia
Mahou no Star Magical Emi
Pastel Yumi
Creamy Mami

Row 2:
Hana no Mahoutsukai Maribelle
Mermaid Princess Pichi Pichi Pitch
Sora Momo
Sailor Moon
Cutey Honey Flash

Row 3:
Rayearth
MewMew
Fun Fun Pharmacy
Umi Momo
Sally (series 2)
Wedding Peach
Hakushon Daimaou
Saint Tail
Akko-chan (series 3)
Akko-chan (series 2)

Row 4:
Kaitou Jeanne
Powerpuff Girls Z
Harbor Light Monogatari
Pretty Cure
CC Sakura
Fancy Lala (Miho)

Row 5:
Mahou Shoujo Sweet Mint
Esper Mami
Fushigiboshi no Futagohime
Ojamajo do-re-mi

Row 6:
Akazukin Chacha
Sugar Sugar Rune
Okusama wa Mahou Shoujo
Pretty Sammy
Nanoha
Majokko Tickle
Sally-chan (series 1)
Mahou Tsukai Tai!
Yadamon

Row 7:
Hime-chan no Ribbon
Mahoutsukai Chappy
Mahou shoujotai Arisu
Mahou no Mako-chan
Majo no Takkyuubin (Kiki's)
Full Moon o Sagashite
Dr. Rin
Nurse Angel Ririka SOS

[ooks]

[ QUOTE ]
Lamhirh of the Stars said:
[ QUOTE ]
rainking187 said:
If someone can read japanese, I believe this (http://pya.cc/pyaimg/pimg.php?imgid=22245&msgfull=yes) may identify them.

[/ QUOTE ]
It does. In order from L-R (though most of them you already know):


Row 3:
Hakushon Daimaou


Row 4:
Harbor Light Monogatari



Row 6:
Yadamon



[/ QUOTE ]


Nice job. Shoot, is it really Hakushon Daimaou? I thought it was: http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=2080

Man.

Harbor Light? Fancy Lala OVA? Oops...

Shoot! I knew that pic was of Yadamon...

Nice job!

[Mononoke]

[ QUOTE ]
ooks said:
Nice job. Shoot, is it really Hakushon Daimaou? I thought it was: http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=2080


[/ QUOTE ]
Thanks /images/graemlins/happy.gif.

I think you're right about the series -- good catch! You were more precise than the answer key. A little digging revealed that Akubi-chan belongs to the same "series family" about genies, a family that originated with Hakushon Daimaou. It seems the answer key was summarizing by giving the overall series family. The picture is definitely Akubi-chan: good going!

That wasn't the only "misleading but not wrong" discrepancy in the key, by the way, which lends further credence to your good call. For instance, the entry for Kiki was just "Takkyuubin" (delivery service)! I expanded that to the full movie title above, because I actually knew that one ahead of time /images/graemlins/happy.gif. But it could have been confusing otherwise!

[ooks]

[ QUOTE ]
Lamhirh of the Stars said:
[ QUOTE ]
ooks said:
Nice job. Shoot, is it really Hakushon Daimaou? I thought it was: http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=2080


[/ QUOTE ]
Thanks /images/graemlins/happy.gif.

I think you're right about the series -- good catch! You were more precise than the answer key. A little digging revealed that Akubi-chan belongs to the same "series family" about genies, a family that originated with Hakushon Daimaou. It seems the answer key was summarizing by giving the overall series family. The picture is definitely Akubi-chan: good going!

That wasn't the only "misleading but not wrong" discrepancy in the key, by the way, which lends further credence to your good call. For instance, the entry for Kiki was just "Takkyuubin" (delivery service)! I expanded that to the full movie title above, because I actually knew that one ahead of time /images/graemlins/happy.gif. But it could have been confusing otherwise!

[/ QUOTE ]

Oh, okay...I was right, yay! lol. I wonder if Hakushon Daimaou is magical girl, though...

Once again, you did an amazing job. Nice!

[EmperorBrandon]

Ok, I can see it now. Definitely a neat picture. Though I know a lot of them, looking at it goes to show how much I haven't seen at this point. Really hoping some of these series (that haven't yet) will be licensed at some point. /images/graemlins/happy.gif