Any rumors or gossip if there's going to be more Full Metal Panic?

[DanielJr]

I would love to see a continuation. Perhaps even a clincher to the romantic tension between you know who.

I decided to watch an episode on Comcast's OnDemand service for the hell of it and decided to re-watch my DVD sets. I forgot how much I loved this series. After the Second Raid, I think there's potential for plenty of more material.

[Fencedude]

I would love to see a continuation. Perhaps even a clincher to the romantic tension between you know who.

I decided to watch an episode on Comcast's OnDemand service for the hell of it and decided to re-watch my DVD sets. I forgot how much I loved this series. After the Second Raid, I think there's potential for plenty of more material.

The novels are wrapping up within the next volume or so, prevailing theory is that they are waiting for them to finish so they can just do the entire rest of the story at once.

[populuxe]

The novels are wrapping up within the next volume or so, prevailing theory is that they are waiting for them to finish so they can just do the entire rest of the story at once.

I'm martialstax and I approve this message.

I'd love more FMP. It never disappoints me.

[Lego]

The novels are wrapping up within the next volume or so, prevailing theory is that they are waiting for them to finish so they can just do the entire rest of the story at once.

I'm martialstax and I approve this message.

I'd love more FMP. It never disappoints me.

Now we just hope Kyo Ani has an open work schedule ;)

[Westlo]

I would love to see a continuation. Perhaps even a clincher to the romantic tension between you know who.

I decided to watch an episode on Comcast's OnDemand service for the hell of it and decided to re-watch my DVD sets. I forgot how much I loved this series. After the Second Raid, I think there's potential for plenty of more material.

The novels are wrapping up within the next volume or so, prevailing theory is that they are waiting for them to finish so they can just do the entire rest of the story at once.

Not saying you're wrong but are you sure? I've been seeing this statement for the last few novels...

[Draneor]

Now we just hope Kyo Ani has an open work schedule ;)

Full Metal Panic has been KyoAni's worst selling show so far (R2--Fumoffu did a lot better than TSR). It did decent enough, but nowhere near Key/Haruhi/Lucky☆Star numbers.

I'd like to see more of it though. But not before I get to see Little Busters!.

[Classical]

I recently finished the first FMP! series and I loved it. I haven't seen FUMOFFU and TSR yet (I plan to) but more FMP would always be welcome from me.

[HitokiriShadow]

Not saying you're wrong but are you sure? I've been seeing this statement for the last few novels...

"Prevailing theory" = fan speculation. There has been nothing remotely official stated as far as I know.

I'd love to see more FMP, but I've given up on it. It would be a nice surprise to see another FMP series, but I don't expect it to happen.

[Zalis]

Now we just hope Kyo Ani has an open work schedule ;)

Full Metal Panic has been KyoAni's worst selling show so far (R2--Fumoffu did a lot better than TSR). It did decent enough, but nowhere near Key/Haruhi/Lucky☆Star numbers.

I'd like to see more of it though. But not before I get to see Little Busters!.I say bring back GONZO for the 4th (and final?) FMP anime. That way KyoAni can concentrate on the Haruhi/LuckyStar-ish comedies and the Key adaptations. Haven't Japanese fans been hankering for a real adaptation of ONE for awhile?

One episode of Lucky Star had some teasers/hints about a possible new FMP anime, but that's about the extent of it.

[DanielJr]

One episode of Lucky Star had some teasers/hints about a possible new FMP anime, but that's about the extent of it.
Eh? Care to elaborate?

[HitokiriShadow]

One episode of Lucky Star had some teasers/hints about a possible new FMP anime, but that's about the extent of it.

I've always felt that people where reading way too much into that. It referenced a bazillion things, including other Kyoto Animation projects. I really don't see how that one scene was any sort of hint or had any implications beyond simply referencing a project Kyoto Animation had done.

[HitokiriShadow]

Eh? Care to elaborate?

If I recall correctly, Konata was watching TV and made some sort of comment that seemed to be referring to Full Metal Panic. I don't recall what she said though.

[Fencedude]

One episode of Lucky Star had some teasers/hints about a possible new FMP anime, but that's about the extent of it.

I've always felt that people where reading way too much into that. It referenced a bazillion things, including other Kyoto Animation projects. I really don't see how that one scene was any sort of hint or had any implications beyond simply referencing a project Kyoto Animation had done.

Kagami was referenced on several occasions as a fan of the Full Metal Panic novels, which brings the discussion more into perspective.

[something]

I say bring back GONZO for the 4th (and final?) FMP anime. That way KyoAni can concentrate on the Haruhi/LuckyStar-ish comedies and the Key adaptations. Haven't Japanese fans been hankering for a real adaptation of ONE for awhile?
Nooooo. While there are things I'd rather see KyoAni do than FMP, I'd still like them to handle a fourth series, especially if it winds up being the last one. At the very least, there are plenty of studios they could go to other than Gonzo, if KyoAni is too busy.

[Draneor]

Nooooo. While there are things I'd rather see KyoAni do than FMP, I'd still like them to handle a fourth series, especially if it winds up being the last one. At the very least, there are plenty of studios they could go to other than Gonzo, if KyoAni is too busy.

But the first season of Full Metal Panic had all that beautiful CG... ;)

[something]

But the first season of Full Metal Panic had all that beautiful CG... ;)
Die in a fire =P

That said, I *did* like the first FMP... it's just that Fumoffu and TSR utterly outclass it. And while I like many of their shows and so am not a Gonzo hater (usually), I really don't want to see the franchise return to their hands. I don't think there's any studio who could do it as well as KyoAni, but some could come close, and certainly outshine what Gonzo would do.

You know, I wouldn't mind seeing any future FMP thrown to A-1 Pictures. I bet they could do some really good things with it, assuming they keep up the level of quality they've shown over the past two seasons.

[Draneor]

<--- Certified Gonzo hater.


You know, I wouldn't mind seeing any future FMP thrown to A-1 Pictures. I bet they could do some really good things with it, assuming they
keep up the level of quality they've shown over the past two seasons.

Honestly, until Kannagi, I had never heard of A-1 Pictures.

How about Shaft? I can see all the background text now. Realistically, J.C. Staff would do a good job with it, I think. Especially if they bring both their serious (Rescue Wings) and comedic (their more famous works) games. Certainly, they have the talent to do the action scenes well.

[Fencedude]

<--- Certified Gonzo hater.


You know, I wouldn't mind seeing any future FMP thrown to A-1 Pictures. I bet they could do some really good things with it, assuming they
keep up the level of quality they've shown over the past two seasons.

Honestly, until Kannagi, I had never heard of A-1 Pictures.

How about Shaft? I can see all the background text now. Realistically, J.C. Staff would do a good job with it, I think. Especially if they bring both their serious (Rescue Wings) and comedic (their more famous works) games.

Only if they bring someone in to sit on Shinbo the entire time.

[HitokiriShadow]

Shaft can do some great stuff.... but I really don't think FMP is a series for them. However, I wouldn't mind seeing Bones or Brains Base try it, along with the aforementioned A-1 Pictures.

[something]

Honestly, until Kannagi, I had never heard of A-1 Pictures.
They're pretty new overall. Their only relevant (they've done other kiddy stuff that doesn't really count) credits are:

Ookiku Furikabutte (TV) : Animation Production
Birdy the Mighty Decode (TV) : Animation Production
Kannagi: Crazy Shrine Maidens (TV) : Animation Production
Kuroshitsuji (TV) : Animation Production
Persona -trinity soul- (TV) : Animation Production

I haven't seen Oofuri for obvious reasons but for people who are into that sort of thing, I've heard nothing but the highest praise. Birdy the Mighty is where I first took note, but Kannagi really got my attention. Kuroshitsuji is pretty good too, though it's on a lower level overall and with a very different animation style. I'll, uh, conveniently ignore Persona or maybe just call it a learning experience.

Maybe their successes so far are a fluke, but if they keep it up I'll be quite happy. I'm watching them with a lot of interest. Their expert handling of Birdy's action sequences would translate well to FMP I feel, and thus far they haven't struck me as a studio who will cheap out and load their shows up with awful 3dcg.

How about Shaft? I can see all the background text now.
Heh. A non-serious comedic FMP spinoff (well ok that's been done already) could be pretty hilarious with the Shaft touch, but yeah, no way they would work for a real FMP series. Then again, who would have pegged Kyoto Animation as the studio that could do Full Metal Panic mecha action true justice? So you never know... but I wouldn't bet on a Shaft FMP working well. :sd:

Realistically, J.C. Staff would do a good job with it, I think.
Oh, certainly. They came to mind first actually, but I mentioned A-1 instead to get a fresh face into the conversation. But I have no doubt JC Staff could pull off an absolutely stellar FMP if they wanted to.

[Talyn]

Realistically, J.C. Staff would do a good job with it, I think.Oh, certainly. They came to mind first actually, but I mentioned A-1 instead to get a fresh face into the conversation. But I have no doubt JC Staff could pull off an absolutely stellar FMP if they wanted to.

I would love to see J.C. Staff take a crack at FMP, I think they would do the franchise proud.... but not before they finish up Shana. :sd: I think I might need to checkout A-1....

[musouka]

I would love to see J.C. Staff take a crack at FMP, I think they would do the franchise proud.... but not before they finish up Shana. :sd: I think I might need to checkout A-1....

A-1 is great, but Oofuri is still the best thing they've done, and now that there's more manga to animate, they better get cracking after this Kannagi nonsense. :P

[Ty]

How about Shaft? I can see all the background text now. Realistically, J.C. Staff would do a good job with it, I think. Especially if they bring both their serious (Rescue Wings) and comedic (their more famous works) games. Certainly, they have the talent to do the action scenes well.

I think JC Staff would do it the most justice as well. Their style would suit FMP and it wouldn't bee too much of a shock from Kyani's presentation. It's truly a shame FMP didn't make more money for Kyani since it's such a good show within it's genre and it sort of offers something for just about everybody to like in one way or another.

[Classical]

Realistically, J.C. Staff would do a good job with it, I think. Especially if they bring both their serious (Rescue Wings) and comedic (their more famous works) games. Certainly, they have the talent to do the action scenes well.

I think JC Staff would do it the most justice as well. They're style would suit FMP and it wouldn't bee too much of a shock from Kyani's presentation. It's truly a shame FMP didn't make more money for Kyani since it's such a good show within it's genre and it sort of offers something for just about everybody to like in one way or another.

If Kyani doesn't wind up doing more Full Metal Panic then I also think J.C. Staff would be a good fit as well. I haven't watched it all but I've really been impressed with the work they've done on Shana.

[ArcticMech]

Sure any number of studios could probably do a fine job with FMP, but I'm holding out hope that KyoAni can squeeze it in somewhere in its busy production schedule. Maybe late 2010?

[dragonrider_cody]

Shaft can do some great stuff.... but I really don't think FMP is a series for them. However, I wouldn't mind seeing Bones or Brains Base try it, along with the aforementioned A-1 Pictures.

No Bones. If someone licenses it, it will take months to get the source material. I love Bones, especially for Kurau, but look at the problems everyone has had with them. I say stick with Kyoto, or JC Staff wouldn't be bad. I love JC, though they're work can be uneven, much like Gonzo. But they definitely have a broad range of styles and would suit FMP well.

[dragoon]

If there is an Anime god, please let there be a sequel. I recently finished TSR and am on held breath to find out what happens next! :)

I don't have any real preference, but I think Kyoto would be awesome given their recent record with the series, so I'd have to go for that. But I think any major and competent studio would do a good job, provided they have the budget for it.

[TornadoTatsumaki]

If there is an Anime god, please let there be a sequel. I recently finished TSR and am on held breath to find out what happens next! :)

I don't have any real preference, but I think Kyoto would be awesome given their recent record with the series, so I'd have to go for that. But I think any major and competent studio would do a good job, provided they have the budget for it.

I concur with Dragoon, being a big fan of the original series and Fumoffu and TSR another FMP incarnation would seem likely in 2010. I hope.

[Thomas Alan]

To be honest, I thought TSR was awful. I'm cool with Gonzo or someone else taking over. The original series I always thought knew best how to balance the drama with the comedy, though Fumoffu was great as well.


Now we just hope Kyo Ani has an open work schedule ;)

Full Metal Panic has been KyoAni's worst selling show so far (R2--Fumoffu did a lot better than TSR). It did decent enough, but nowhere near Key/Haruhi/Lucky☆Star numbers.

I'd like to see more of it though. But not before I get to see Little Busters!.

Isn't that like the worst player on an all-star team? These guys have been gold lately (though I don't quite understand what's so special about Lucky Star).

[something]

Isn't that like the worst player on an all-star team? These guys have been gold lately (though I don't quite understand what's so special about Lucky Star).
Well, it wasn't even close. TSR was ~4-5k/vol, as opposed to their Key titles (Kanon ~18k, AIR ~24k, Clannad ~24k) and other titles (~29k Lucky Star, ~40k+ Haruhi).

[Thomas Alan]

Would an animation company who wasn't on a role sneeze at those numbers though?

And would we expect sales to improve now that Kyoto Animation has established themselves as they have?

[Fencedude]

Would an animation company who wasn't on a role sneeze at those numbers though?

And would we expect sales to improve now that Kyoto Animation has established themselves as they have?

I don't think it has much to do with "KyoAni", really...

[Draneor]

[T]hough I don't quite understand what's so special about Lucky☆Star).

The moe factor. If you don't get it, well I can't really help you to. Incidentally, all of KyoAni's popular works have it. Plus, it was based on a popular 4koma and has many otaku parodies and in-jokes.

[AstroNerdBoy]

Personally, I'd like to see at least one more comedy FMP series (there's enough material for another 13-episode series) and at least a 26-episode series on the main story. The comedy tale could go first and the serious one later (especially if the light novels do come to an end soon).

[iserlohn]

To be honest, I thought TSR was awful. I'm cool with Gonzo or someone else taking over. The original series I always thought knew best how to balance the drama with the comedy, though Fumoffu was great as well.

The big issue with balancing the funny and the serious at this point is that most of the comedy dried up in the source material by the corresponding novels for TSR came out ("End of Day By Day" 1/2). There's still a bit of it in the next book ("Dancing Very Merry Christmas") but after that it only gets darker from there. The funny stuff has been shunted off to the manga and the short stories.

Personally, I like the more serious (albeit OTT) military aspects, and would love to see another series along the lines of TSR. I'd also find it an excellent compromise to put a Fumoffu-esque OVA on each of the discs taken from the side materials.

[Thomas Alan]

[T]hough I don't quite understand what's so special about Lucky☆Star).

The moe factor. If you don't get it, well I can't really help you to. Incidentally, all of KyoAni's popular works have it. Plus, it was based on a popular 4koma and has many otaku parodies and in-jokes.

Huh. I thought I understood moe. Guess there's a layer to it that I've been missing these past few years.

The big issue with balancing the funny and the serious at this point is that most of the comedy dried up in the source material by the corresponding novels for TSR came out ("End of Day By Day" 1/2). There's still a bit of it in the next book ("Dancing Very Merry Christmas") but after that it only gets darker from there. The funny stuff has been shunted off to the manga and the short stories.

Oh, wasn't aware of that. In that case I don't mind if TSR is the last of it all.

[something]

Huh. I thought I understood moe. Guess there's a layer to it that I've been missing these past few years.
Well, no, just because a lot of people find it moe doesn't mean you will or have to or should. Personally I liked it as much for the comedy as for the bits that made me feel moe.

[Draneor]

Huh. I thought I understood moe. Guess there's a layer to it that I've been missing these past few years.

At least as far as Japanese fandom goes, Konata, Kagami, and Tsukasa have generated a phenomenal amount of character love, generated a lot of fan art and doujinshi, and also scored rather well on various polls and contests (for example, the final round of Saimoe 2008 was between Kagami and Tsukasa). It may not be logic to it, but the characters of Lucky☆Star have clicked with otaku. As far as its humor goes, it's mostly targeted humor, so I can understand why many who do not follow Japan as closely as some of us do may not find it funny. Lastly, there was a catchy dance. I admit I don't know why it became popular.

There are franchises popular in Japan that I don't get (Gundam, Kanokon, and Strike Witches) and ones I get that aren't (Nanatsuiro★Drops, Sola, and Wind - a Breath of Heart). Since we're not Japanese, there will always be differences in tastes and feelings, I guess. Well, of course there is a lot of variation among the Japanese otaku too. I just went off on a ramble.^^U

[Phaded]

Sorry to dig up old threads but from what i've been reading there is a possibility after the final novel is released this Summer, would love this to happen

[Fencedude]

Sorry to dig up old threads but from what i've been reading there is a possibility after the final novel is released this Summer, would love this to happen

I'm not going to hold my breath

[Draneor]

Has it really been a year? It seems like just yesterday... Anyway. In regards to what we know:

KyoAni is doing K-On! in spring 2010. Beyond that, they have not announced any plans. Since the last time we discussed this, they did SoraMiage, Haruhi 2, and K-On!. Of those, really only Haruhi was an obvious prediction (even if many gave up on it). Thus, given off seasons and surprise announcements, it's hard to predict what they intend to do.

Kadokawa has not announced any plans for more FMP anime. The final novel is being published shortly.

That's really about it.

[Betenoire]

That's really about it.

Well that and the rumor Hollywood was looking at the franchise from earlier this year.

[Phaded]

Well once the final novel is released, and hopefully there's some demand for it I see no reason why they can't or shouldn't make more FMP anime as the material is there for it. Even some material for another Fumoffu type offering.

Maybe we'll find out K-On! here's hoping