Noein Volume 4

[Stargazemg]

Volume 4 of this terrific series has a defect about midway through episode 18. The disc will lock-up most progressive scan DVD players. Looking over the disc carefully, there is a hole through the label near the Title. This problem existed on all three discs, in exactly the same location, that I exchanged with my local Anime store. This store also had 5 other defective discs, besides the 2 I returned to them. I e-mailed Manga Entertainment about the problem, but to date, there has been no response.

[chloes_fork]

Hmmm. FWIW, my copy displayed no problems at all. Since my ancient player isn't progressive scan, however, that may be worth precisely nothing. :sweatdrop:

[Lain Of The Net]

I just looked over my copy. I put it in front of a very bright light and I seem to have no hole. It is playing fine on my players.

[Skywise]

Could everyone please list what players they're using? Saying "progressive players" isn't exactly very enlightening, nor does a player having a progressive output or not affect playback compatibility.

[chloes_fork]

As I mentioned, my player's ancient, a Panasonic DVD-RV30.

[Lain Of The Net]

I have played Volume 4 on two players:

Sony DVP - NS575P (progressive)

Curtis DVD 1043 (progressive)