Azumanga Daioh Complete Collection (2009 Edition) - Mania.com



Anime/Manga

Mania Grade: B+

2 Comments | Add

 

Rate & Share:

 

Related Links:

 

Info:

  • Audio Rating: B+
  • Video Rating: A
  • Packaging Rating: C+
  • Menus Rating: B
  • Extras Rating: B
  • Age Rating: 13 and Up
  • Region: 1 - North America
  • Released By: ADV Films
  • MSRP: 49.98
  • Running time: 650
  • Aspect Ratio: 1.33:1
  • Disc Resolution: 480i/p
  • Disc Encoding: MPEG-2
  • Series: Azumanga Daioh

Azumanga Daioh Complete Collection (2009 Edition)

A template for short form comedy

By Chris Beveridge     August 19, 2009
Release Date: May 26, 2009


Azumanga Daioh Complete Collection (2009 Edition)
© ADV Films

Get it together, anime fans, and don’t be like Osaka!

What They Say
In Miss Yukari's English class, every day is an adventure. First off, there's the teacher herself. A bit of an air-head, she may have graduated from high school, but she sure hasn't left. And with the arrival of not one, but two transfer students - one ten-year-old prodigy and one space cadet - it's going to be an interesting year!

The Review!
Audio:

The bilingual presentation for Azumanga Daioh was fairly standard for ADV Films during the time it was originally released as the English language mix gets a good 5.1 mix at 448kbps while the original Japanese language is in stereo at 224kbps. Over time, the 5.1 mixes began to disappear for a lot of titles, but especially for ones like this where it really doesn’t add all that much since it’s a basic comedy. The dialogue is certainly cleaner and better placed in the 5.1 mix here, but it’s not something that makes a huge difference in comparison to the original stereo mix that we have for the Japanese language track. In the end, it comes down to language preference more than anything else as both tracks are solid presentations that are clean and clear of problems such as dropouts or distortions.

Video:
Originally airing in 2002, the transfer for this TV series is presented in its original full frame aspect ratio. Last year’s collection was one where it repackaged the previous collection which had no extras to it. This edition brings out the original six individual volumes in one set which means the extras are included and the encoding is the same as we saw years earlier. The video quality doesn’t seem to suffer much though as the series has a good set of source materials and colors maintain a solid and pleasing feeling to them. There is a certain softness to it at times but beyond that it’s a clean and vibrant looking show. There are numerous scenes where it’s pretty still and quiet and that helps to keep the bitrate low so they can pump it up later when necessary. For the most part, this feels comparable to what we got on the six volumes of single releases that came out a few years back.

Packaging:

This edition is one of the recent STACKpack releases win which it’s an oversized black keepcase with a single spindle to hold all six DVDs on. There is thankfully a piece of foam inside to help keep them in place as once we opened up the set, the first two discs slid right out even when held just slightly angled. The front cover artwork is really nice as it has the main cast all arrayed around the logo, some of them in seeming freefall, which is representative of the opening sequence. The white background draws you to it more since the colors are appealing and the characters themselves draw the eye. The back cover has a bit of a school feel to it with a blackboard as the main background and plenty of text, be it plugs for the show or the decent summary. They push the episode and disc count nicely as well as the extras, though no mention of the vid-notes which I found curious. And that’s because for some reason they didn’t get ported over to this set, which is a loss once again. The remainder of the cover is given over to the production credits and a clean technical grid.

Menu:
The menu design for Azumanga Daioh is familiar as it works with the cute image of seeing Sakaki from behind as she’s trying to wave off the cat that’s bitten her hand. The split of the yellow on the left and white on the right for the background is a bit off-putting at first but it fits within the color scheme used in the show at times and it does keep it all rather bright and attractive. The navigation along the left is straightforward with top level episode access – a plus in my book – as well as language selection. This release seemed to be about 50/50 for reading our player presets as the odd numbered discs all worked fine but the even numbered ones defaulted to English with sign/song subtitles. Submenus, when you need to use them, load quickly and without a problem and moving about is a breeze.

Extras:
With this generally being very close to the same thing that we got with the singles, the extras mirror it here as well. There are the basics to be had such as production sketches and clean opening and closing sequences. There is also a series of character artwork pieces included and a plus in the form of the short mini-movie. Sadly, the vid-notes didn’t make it onto this edition either which to me is a huge loss and one of the reasons that these collections won’t replace any of my singles.

Content: (please note that content portions of a review may contain spoilers)
Based on the four panel comic strip by Kiyohiko Azuma that ran from 1999 to 2002, Azumanga Daioh is an entirely pleasant little comedic romp that follows the lives of several high school girls through all three years. The series has seen a collection previously and we watched the original singles, but it felt like it was time to revisit it. Doing this while in the midst of watching Lucky Star is certainly interesting since they have several commonalities to them.

The story of Azumanga Daioh is really straightforward and simple in that we see a group of girls starting their first year of high school. Moving between the seasons, we see them grown and change throughout the three years that go on here, with some summer activities and various holidays here and there. The only downside to it is that there really isn’t all that much in the way of physical changes among the students other than a haircut here and there and the change in uniforms depending on the season. And while not a downside, the repetition issue can be a bit problematic when viewed in quick order as well, something we found even when watching the spaced out singles. When you have the students going through the motions of the culture fest and the sports fest across each of the years, it can get a little familiar, especially on top of so many other series that cover the same things.

What makes Azumanga Daioh work is the characters and the dynamic that exists between them. The series opens with a pair of interesting students arriving on the scene. One of them is the very smart Chiyo, affectionately known as Chiyo-chan, a ten year old girl who has skipped out of elementary school in order to go to high school where she’ll be properly challenged. She’s a bright eyed and cute girl who is entirely positive except when she’s trying to not let everyone else down. Because of her size, she feels like she can’t keep up with everyone when it comes to things like sports fests as well as the way they all stay up later and have more of a social life in certain ways. Complementing here is Kasuga, a transfer student from Osaka who has come here in order to “get it together” and make a break from her past. Osaka isn’t stupid but she’s not exactly altogether there either. She gets lost in dreams at times, some of them very fanciful and amusing, but more often than not she simply spaces out with whatever is on her mind. She never truly gets it together but is the kind of cute and snuggly character that you easily adore in a show like this.

While they’re certainly the less than normal kind of characters you’d find in real life, the rest of the main crew is pretty amusing in their own ways as well. The one I enjoy the most is Sakaki, a tall quiet young woman who has a real love for animals and for cats in particular. Her parents have issues with pets so she can’t have any so she tries to spend as much time as she can with them when she sees them. Unfortunately, they all seem to either flee from her or bite her, leaving her unable to extend the love she wants. With her quiet nature, it’s amusing to watch her trying to get closer to the animals. Opposite of her is Tomo, a firebrand of a character who is bad at everything but manages to scrape by in the end. She’s very outgoing, energetic and alive which drives everyone else nuts since she’s an act first think later kind of person. She tends to be the one to cause the most trouble but also gets the group motivated to do things with enthusiasm a lot of the time.

Rounding out the group of initial regulars is an amusing pair that have a very different feel from each other. Yomi is the smart girl of the class who ends up not feeling threatened by Chiyo when she arrives and in fact becomes good friends with her. She’s smart, a little self conscious and like everyone else is a part of the “Go Home” club. Yomi’s probably one of the least worked on characters in the show but she has some of the best expressions since her childhood friend is Tomo and that mean’s she’s put up with a whole lot in her life. On the flip side, and required in a series like this, is Kaorin. Kaorin is a cute girl who has a big sister crush on Sakaki and she continually dreams about her and does everything she can to get closer to her. Sometimes it’s all sweetness and light, but when necessary she plays rough as well. The way she dotes on the completely unaware Sakaki is quite cute for awhile though it’s something that never really gets anywhere with any merit unfortunately. In fact, it’s a good character turn when in their third year, she ends up in a different class altogether.

While the students make up most of the fun, the nice twist to Azumanga Daioh is the involvement of a group of the teachers. Most of the kids are in the same class under homeroom teacher Yukari. Yukari is kind of like the kid who was popular in school to a point and she never really wanted to leave, hence becoming a teacher. She’s kind of weird at times, very outgoing and brash and she ends up doing a lot of things that would get anyone else in trouble. Most of it is in relation to her fellow teacher, Minamo. Called by her nickname of Nyamo, she’s the PE instructor and homeroom teacher that Yukari competes with often. Nyamo has known her for an age since they went to school together and it has something of a similar relationship to that of Tomo and Yomi that’s been going on for longer. The interplay between the two is fun and Yukari really brings some amusing things to the table.

If there’s an area of the series that made me a little uncomfortable, partially because it took a good all ages show and made it harder to show younger viewers, is the teacher known as Kimura. This very thin and creepy looking guy has quite a thing for high school girls. He’s constantly coming up with ways to get them to wear their bloomers and spends time watching them at the pool. His looks and phrases at times really do put him in the proper pedo-stalker category, but one that’s (For now?) completely harmless. Some of it is creepier than other scenes but there is admittedly some good humor based around him at times. When we meet his wife and see pictures of his kid, it makes you look at him in a new way that’s hard to wrap your head around.

The transition from a four panel comic to this works well in that the humor is given a chance to shine but it’s not made to hold for an entire episode. Azumanga Daioh works well by having the smaller stories mixed throughout each overall episode. Not everything is completely linked either which is a plus, as it lets the stories flow in a natural way without being forced to continue gags from earlier. Some episodes have longer stories than others, going nearly the entire length for example with the dream ones, while others skip about pretty easily every few minutes with a new title and a different avenue to explore. It doesn’t feel forced and it allows a variety of characters to have some screen time without feeling like they’re shoehorning them into the episode’s main storyline in order to make sure that they’re there.

In Summary:
Revisiting the show after a few years and after all the hype has certainly been fun. It hasn’t exactly captured me the way it did the first time around, partially from familiarity and partially because of the loss of the vid-notes. Most of the show plays well without it, but there are moments when they’d be entirely too useful. I don’t think Azumanga Daioh is a show meant for marathoning unless it’s in a group setting with a drinking game involved, but it certainly is worth revisiting. This collection is more complete than some of the previous editions, but it’s not a “final complete” version to me simply because it lacks the vid-notes. But it is a lot of fun and kept me smiling in an almost nostalgic way. It’s good clean fun, unless Kimura is involved. Definitely still recommended after all these years.

Features
Japanese 2.0 Language, English 5.1 Language, English Subtitles

Review Equipment

Sony KDS-R70XBR2 70" LCoS 1080P HDTV, Sony PlayStation3 Blu-ray player via HDMI set to 1080p, Onkyo TX-SR605 Receiver and Panasonic SB-TP20S Multi-Channel Speaker System With 100-Watt Subwoofer.

COMMENTS AND RESPONSES

Showing items 1 - 2 of 2
1 
epicgears 5/26/2009 5:12:49 PM

Hooray!

My favorite school comedy. Rock on Osaka.

zaldar 8/20/2009 6:30:58 PM

Wow not an A?  This is really the funniest anime show I have ever scene...yes the lack of the vid notes in this version is to bad but I wouldn't give it a B because of that.  Though if they make another version INCLUDE THE VID NOTES!  Or at least reprint the singles with them...I lost the original vid notes and I would buy the show again (and sell my old dvds) to get them back.

1 

ADD A COMMENT

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Please click here to login.

POPULAR TOPICS