BATMAN-GOTHAM KNIGHT (Two-Disc Collector's Edition) - Mania.com



DVD Review

Mania Grade: B-

19 Comments | Add

 

Rate & Share:

 

Related Links:

 

Info:

  • DVD: Batman - Gotham Knight (Two-Disc Collector's Edition)
  • Rating: PG-13
  • Starring (Voices): Corey Burton, Kevin Conroy, Gary Dourdan, Jason Marsden, David McCallum
  • Written By: Bob Kane(characters), Brian Azzarello, Alan Burnett, Jordan Goldberg, David S. Goyer, Josh Olson, Greg Rucka
  • Directed By: Yasuhiro Aoki, Shojiro Nishimi, Hiroshi Morioka, Futoshi Higashide, Toshiyuki Kubooka
  • Distributor: Warner Home Video
  • Original Year of Release: 2008
  • Extras: Four episodes of the Batman Animated Series picked by producer Bruce Timm, Two documentaries Batman and Me: The Bob Kane Story and A Mirror for the Bat: Exploring the Evil Denizens of Gotham City, Wonder Woman Sneak Peek, Multiple Commentaries

BATMAN-GOTHAM KNIGHT (Two-Disc Collector's Edition)

Is it worth all the hype?

By Robert T. Trate     July 11, 2008


Batman - Gotham Knight (Two-Disc Collector's Edition) (2008)
© Warner Home Video
Warner Premiere’s Batman - Gotham Knight (Two-Disc Collector's Edition) is a bridge between Batman Begins and its sequel The Dark Knight. It is also the best animation for a movie tie-in DVD since The Animatrix. Batman - Gotham Knight sets a new bar for American released animated films. What falls flat is the storytelling. Outside of two exceptional stories and the animation, the rest of the Batman - Gotham Knight is not worth all the hype.
 
"Have I Got a Story For You" written by Josh Olson and directed by Shoujirou Nishimi is not very original in concept. Several teenagers regale each other with their Batman encounters. Each sees what they want, adds to the story and, as an audience, we see an over exaggeration of Batman. The segment is entertaining and a great chance for the animators to have fun with Batman and draw him outside the confines of his normal cape and cowl. However, this story was done in the 1970’s by DC Comics scribe Frank Robbins and drawn by Dick Giordano titled “Nobody Knows” (available in the Greatest Batman Stories Ever Told TPB). Furthermore the same style of story was done on the now classic Batman The Animated Series titled “Legends of the Dark Knight”. It may not have been original in concept but it paid homage to the other reincarnations of Batman that have come before. The Dark Knight Returns segment alone shines brighter than most of the stories on this DVD (look for it on the second disc). It seems every generation will have this type of Batman story. Unfortunately, this one is a step down.
 
"Crossfire" stayed true to its Gotham Central roots. It should considering it was written by Gotham Central scribe Greg Rucka. The story is a brilliant reflection of the Eisner and Harvey Award Winning comic. Detective Allen (Gary Dourdan) doesn’t the trust the Batman. His partner Detective Anna Ramirez (Ana Ortiz) is a believer in the Batman and sees the difference he has already made in Gotham. The story is almost too short. A few more minutes of realism mixed with some more interdepartmental camaraderie could have played out better. Instead it gives way to the action. This story does bring a lot of information to the surface about what happened to the narrows after Batman Begins and Arkham Asylum.
 
"Field Test" and "In Darkness Dwells" really develop the relationship between Batman and James Gordon. Though played out against some killer action sequences and villains (Scarecrow and Killer Croc) this segment only faulted in one respect, Kevin Conroy should not play Batman as a young man. Behind the mask it works but as a young anime Bruce Wayne it is as foreign sounding as a Sicilian voice coming out of an Aborigine. These two stories were the bulk of Batman - Gotham Knight.
 
"Working Through Pain" is a flashback story told as Batman is wounded in the sewers trying to make his way towards Alfred. Brian Azzarello places Bruce Wayne in India trying to master a technique that will help him control his pain. Azzarello humanizes Batman even further by making him fail to see the point of his master’s teachings. It is a brilliant story and one that illustrates Azzarelo’s hold on the character. For all the action and stylized animation that exists in Batman - Gotham Knight this simple story is the best of the lot. 
 
"Deadshot" really is in the vein of Batman Begins. A realistic portrayal of Deadshot is given and his ego definitely has the upper hand when it comes to his judgment. Batman - Gotham Knight builds to this sequence and it is worth the wait. 
 
Unlike the Animatrix,which explored the world of The Matrix revealing so much, Batman - Gotham Knight has only a few bits and pieces of new information about Batman. Sure the character has been around for almost seventy years but each month the writers and DC Comics bring something new to the character. Here was a chance to blend Western Comic Book mythology with Eastern Animation. Instead it just felt like a movie gimmick instead of comic book brought to life.

COMMENTS AND RESPONSES

Showing items 1 - 10 of 19
1 2 >  >>  
velgron 7/11/2008 5:30:05 AM
Tough sell. But It is hard to be compared to the Animatrix, which is better than the films that followed it. For the Animatrix, there was a lot of collaboration between the movie producers/writers/directors/brothers in the DVD development. But in the Batman case it seems that the connection was a little off. Nevertheless, if the film lives up to the hype, the DVD will not be as important as it was on the Matrix where a completely new universe was explained.
Flint521466 7/11/2008 5:46:41 AM
I caught this on-demand the other nite. I thought it sucked and sucked bad. Really disappointed.
CardinalSin 7/11/2008 6:11:10 AM
Hey Velgron, don't you mean "there was a lot of collaboration between the movie producers/writers/directors/brother-sister in the DVD...."?
velgron 7/11/2008 8:22:36 AM
I shall not go there...
hanso 7/11/2008 9:35:18 AM
Had some nice segments but would've preferred if it was a linear film in traditional animation instead of anime segments. Still failed to see how this bridges the gap between Begins & DK. They had some stuff in it but not much.
fft5305 7/11/2008 10:24:18 AM
And by "bridges the gap," they mean "capitalizes on the hype to make a grab for as much cash as possible".....
ALIEN 7/11/2008 1:20:15 PM
As much as I wanted to enjoy this movie, I have to be blunt, it was horrible. The animation, though "unique", felt rushed and inadequate. I cannot believe how great the back grounds looked, but the title characters were rubbish. It would have been much better if it were a Full length movie, with a solid story, it was loosely tied together and it made me bored. I loved the animation on the second segment, that was good....but the segment with the repelling bullets gizmo was atrocious! <br /> <br /> I HOPE the movie is much better as this does not give many people high hopes. I am a little annoyed I waste 15 on this movie. As I will never watch it again. EVER.
gauleyboy420 7/11/2008 2:36:06 PM
Holy Crap Batman! No not the DVD I thought it was great, but the reaction. I feel as though many of you had different expectations of what you should have. It was some Anime (which I usually hate) Batman stories. Nothing more, nothing less. The review here was fair, but I feel it was a bit nitpicky, and doesn’t highlight the good points of this DVD. I really enjoyed “Have I got a Story for You†,has it been done? Yeah, but it was a well done version of it here too. And lets be frank, it’s not like “Nobody Knows†was the first story told in different perspectives, so I don’t think it’s fair to be so judgmental. Again I think this is a great DVD The animation is fantastic, fluid, and it’s cool to see how a different culture views our heroes. If this is the way that WB want to grab some $$$ by tying it in to the release of TDK, GREAT This is the kind of marketing I want to see, NOT 200 Slusho websites. I recommend this to any Batman fan, and I like Kevin Conroy throughout the DVD. Maybe it was just the familiarity, but he is the definitive Batman. and has Played a young Bruce Wayne numerous times throughout Batman: TAS Still a B is a good grade BTW Velgon...I’ve been gone a while, and I come back you’ve changed from a cute cartoon character into a hot geek chic ...how long was I gone ;)
mckracken 7/11/2008 7:50:41 PM
Gotham Knight is definitly nowhere near on par with Animatrix but its a fun little watch, wont stand up to repeat viewings but I havent watched Transformers again since I bought it either. (or the Matrix sequels for that matter) How's Gotham Knight compare with that Highlander anime? the Pitch Black anime? I actually liked the Highlander anime. its interesting to watch the Batman Animated series episodes that were hand picked by Bruce Timm since the first one "Legends of the Dark Knight" starts off with the three kids each telling the others what it was like to witness The Batman first hand in action and its never accurate but its faithful to the Elseworlds Batman novels that get pretty weird with the girl Robin. (also the first fight with the Joker, Batman and Robin are drawn in the style of the 1940's Batman comics (which was the inspiration for the cartoon opening of the 1966 BATMAN live action WHAM BAM show...and they even shake hands like they did in the 1966 series opening... lol!!)) in any case, its hardly a "bridge" between movies... well we havent seen the end of the Batman Bridge yet, TDK might actually answer more questions from the anime, who knows.
mckracken 7/11/2008 7:52:48 PM
also I'd like to add that I actually enjoyed Batman vs Dracula MUCH more... plus Batman: Mystery of the Batwoman more than Gotham Knights... you have to take the good with the bad I guess.
1 2 >  >>  

ADD A COMMENT

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Please click here to login.

POPULAR TOPICS