TV Review


"Battlestar Galactica: Rapture"

By: STEPHEN LACKEY
Review Date: Wednesday, January 24, 2007

Before I dig into what happened in the spring premiere I have to comment on the poor ad campaign running for the series.  The ads are like a schmaltzy Smallville rip off with some horrible pop balad that just makes the series appear flaccid and shallow.  These terrible ads just don’t do the series justice and that pop song is atrocious.  Now that I’ve gotten that off my chest, let’s take a look at the spring premiere. 

When last we saw the crew of BSG, they were embroiled in a standoff with the Cylons over the Eye of Jupiter, an artifact that apparently has something to do with the way to Earth.  A few soldiers and several civilians are trapped down on a planet where they were harvesting algae that could be processed into food when the Chief found the temple that according to ancient religious text was to house the Eye of Jupiter.  Lee Adama, Starbuck, Sam, and Dee, were ordered to protect the temple as long as they could from a Cylon invasion while Chief and his crew searched for the Eye.  Meanwhile in orbit, Galactica was facing a standoff with the Cylons, if the Cylons sent ships to the planet’s surface Galactica would launch nukes destroying the temple and anything else on the surface of the planet. The Cylons did launch some ships and Adama prepared to launch his nukes.  On the planet, the Cylons had already sent an advanced force down on the planet and they shot Starbuck’s ship down and were moving in for the attack.  Oh, did I mention that all of this was happening in the shadow of a star that could go nova at any time destroying any nearby ships and ravaging the planet? 


The writers packed a ton of story into this one little episode and a few scenes do suffer for it but overall this was another exhilarating episode of BSG.  In order to keep Sam leading his people into battle on the planet’s surface Lee decides to send Dee and her red shirt partner on a mission to save Starbuck.  There’s very little cover between Dee and Starbuck’s crashed ship and right away Dee’s backup is killed.  She is shocked and hurt that her husband, Lee, would put her life on the line to save Starbuck but she does as she is ordered.  Meanwhile, Lee and Sam lead the few soldiers and the civilians into a plan to stop, or at least slow down the Cylons to give Chief time to find the eye.  With the battle not going well, Lee orders the destruction of the temple, so Chief and his people finish setting up the explosives and leave the temple. 

The Cylons had sent a group of ships headed for the surface of the planet and in response Galactica prepped its nukes.  The Cylons voted and outnumbered 3 and decided to pull the ships back.  She only partially complied by pulling back all of the ships but one, the one carrying D’Anna and Baltar.  Inside the temple, D’Anna is able to see the final five Cylons and she recognizes one of them before dying in Baltar’s arms.  When Chief realizes something is wrong and the bombs don’t go off they, along with Lee, re-enter the temple only to find Baltar and arrest him. 

While all of this is happening Sharon and Helo are still reeling from the news that their child is still alive and on the nearby base ship.  After some convincing, Helo agrees to shoot Sharon allowing her to be reborn on the base ship where she can retrieve her daughter.  On the ship, she’s met by Caprica who helps her get her daughter off the ship, believing that the baby is the future of the Cylon race and that she should survive at any cost. 

In the closing moments of the episode the star goes nova and all the ships just magically reappear on Galactica.  There are some scenes of the world getting pummeled by the exploding star but everything happens quick, easy, and clean.  Adama commands the rescue mission be launched and we cut to everyone exiting their ships on the hangar bay.  Starbuck and Dee, the people down on the planet, and Caprica and Sharon all land on Galactica.  These stories tie up way too easily for me.  It felt like we might be into a new story arc with Sharon on board the base ship, but no she and Caprica get away no problem.  While I’m complaining let me just say that the Dee/Lee Starbuck/Sam story arc is getting tiresome and for me it’s dragging the pace of the series down a bit.  They need to get this story over with ASAP.  There is light at the end of the tunnel because it looks as though a new story arc is kicking in for Starbuck when Helo discovers that Starbuck had painted an image back in her apartment on Caprica that matched an image from the temple.  Is she a religious prophet or a Cylon?  Who knows, but it’s sure to be interesting to find out.  She needs a deeper storyline to give her character more dimension and the writers seem to be right on top of it here. 

The creators recently revealed that they have no problem and in fact enjoy turning the series upside down and that we should buckle up for a wild ride and that we can expect to see main characters die.  Funny, I read that just before watching this episode only to see the number 3 line get “boxed” as it were.  When D’Anna is reborn with the knowledge of what the final 5 look like she is shut down and locked away.  This knowledge is one of the central themes to the story so we probably won’t be seeing Lucy Lawless again for quite a long time. 

Even with my complaints this episode of BSG offers up some great action in the form of the gunfights on the planet and solid drama between Sharon and Helo.  One of the better scenes in the episode is when Helo tells the President that he wouldn’t have had to shoot Sharon and put her, their baby, and the lives of every human in the colony in danger had she not lied to them and taken their baby.  The statement takes the President aback, and the second of silence before she replies to him speaks volumes.  Now we not only have Baltar back on Galactica but we have Caprica too.  Will Adama remember his previous encounter with a number 6?  This episode asks a lot of new questions and sets the stage for some fascinating storytelling.  Not the best episode of the series but still better than just about anything else on television.



More Content By STEPHEN LACKEY
PRISON BREAK: Scylla/Breaking and Entering
(Thursday, September 4, 2008)
TV Wasteland: What to Watch this Fall, or Not?
(Monday, September 1, 2008)
TV Wasteland: CBS Knows Best, or Do They?
(Monday, August 25, 2008)
BURN NOTICE: Rough Seas
(Friday, August 22, 2008)
EUREKA: I Do Over
(Thursday, August 21, 2008)
PRIMEVAL
(Tuesday, August 19, 2008)
TV Wasteland: Ron Moore Goes Virtual
(Monday, August 18, 2008)
EUREKA: Best in Faux
(Thursday, August 14, 2008)
TV Wasteland: Torchwood Audio Episode?
(Monday, August 11, 2008)
EUREKA: What About Bob?
(Thursday, August 7, 2008)
Comments/Responses
1 2 > >>
spyderr987 • Jan 24, 2007, 08:53am •
...

evilkerek • Jan 24, 2007, 08:55am •
I love this show, but I wish they'd ease up on all the hocus-pocus - it's suppose to be sci-fi and it's starting to get annoying. Anyway, a mostly good episode.

Helo. Ok, that's twice now he's pretty much said screw everyone else, I'm doing what works for me - and I mean everyone as in last of the human race.

It's insane he is still in uniform. He cannot be trusted. He will absolutely put himself before his duty and it matters not if his choice could end the human race.

He adds a lot of flavor because of what he does, but they need a good reason why he IS still where he can do damage.

mbeckham1 • Jan 24, 2007, 09:04am •
I know what you mean about the Starbuck, Lee, Sam, Dee love quadrangle or whatever you'd call it.

From the beginning I've pulled against Starbuck and Lee getting together. They play off each other too much like siblings, and seeing them make out is just creepy.

Pluse, their much more interesting apart and screwed up than they are together.

That said, I do like the tension between Lee and Sam, and between Dee and Starbuck. It made for some interestuing moments in these past two episodes and I'd like to see Dee and Starbuck get more screen time together.

I am very intrigued by the new Starbuck storyline, it has great potential. If she is a Cylon, it will be escpecially interesting to see what that does to her faith, since she's been portrayed as a pretty devout by-the-book fundamentalist wen it comes to the Gods(plural).

Take her stance on marriage. Hurting Sam, Dee, Lee or even herself matters less to her than breaking a sacriment to the gods would.

It would also be interesting to see how it affects the way she relates to Leoben. I have no idea if the writers intend to make her a Cylon but it is one of the more intriguing theories I've heard.

Other new potential storylines are looking interesting. Having Caprica Six on Galactica is rife with possibilities. Gods knows how Baltar's going to avoid execution, though no doubt he will.

The idea of Sharon Agathon trapped on the Basestar would have been great. Alternatively it would also have been interesting have both her and the other Sharon who used to bve a crew member on Galactica. But lacking either, it'll be interesting to see what they do with the baby now. Sorry to see Luvy Lawless go, her D'Anna was fast becoming the most interesting of Cylons, and it seemed like bit where seeing the baby was her first experience of love felt a little unresolved.

In any case. While I agree the ending felt a little rushed and I would have prefered a third episode to conclude the story, it did do a good job introducing a lot of new story lines and definitely succeeds in making me want to see what happens next.

P.S. Look Forward to hearing our thoughts on Monday's Heroes episode.

gazelle024 • Jan 24, 2007, 01:03pm •
To me this episode just quickly wrapped up a lot of loose ends. Yeah things felt rushed and too neat and tidy, but it also felt like they were brushing away this first half of the season that hadn't gone over all that well with fans for the new offerings to come. Lucy Lawless was always just a guest star anyway and it always felt that she'd come out of nowhere to have too important a role because of who she is personally only to lead to this way of getting her out of the way for a while or until we decide to have her back as a guest star. I don't know that I was looking forward to seeing Athena hanging around on the basestar. I think she would have been very limited in what she could have done. It was interesting for her to meet up with her former Galactica counterpart and see the extreme differences in their attitudes and then to see how this number six (called Caprica) reacts. It seems she had had enough of all the stuff D'Anna had been pulling with Baltar even though she just stood around and ate that #$%^. It always seemed that her priority was the baby even though she seemed to feel some jealousy about it. Now I think Caprica on the Galactica is more interesting than Athena on the cylon basestar so I can get over that neat and tidy plot twist. I think this series has always been full of that sort of plot points of convenience. Otherwise I see no reason to believe the cylons wouldn't have wiped them out long ago. I still believe they could do it whenever they chose to. I also thing the president should die before they get to earth. Assuming they ever do get to earth.

jetpackjesus • Jan 24, 2007, 01:41pm •
Apparently Katie Sackhoff has said she wants to leave the show because her character is basically a soap opera now (my friend was telling me he read this, or maybe heard on the podcast so I have no source to link to). My money is on her leaving because it turns out she was one of the final five. I'm mostly basing this on what D'Anna said when she saw the final five: "You? I had no idea. I'm so sorry."

The recognized character has to be someone D'Anna would know and that the Cylons would've done something terrible to, hence the apology. Kara has had her ovaries taken and had her mind fucked with for a year or two on New Caprica. This would also allow the creators to get rid of her character (if Sackhoff really wants out) without actually killing her off, allowing for future guest spots.

The only other options I can think of that fits what D'Anna said are Bill, who they nearly shot to death; and Tigh, whose eye they removed. I cannot, however, see this show working without Olmos or McDonnell, so I'm just going to pray neither of them are being lost. I could live without Tigh, though.

I'm with most others about the love quadrilateral being extremely annoying, mostly because I can't stand Starbuck anymore. However, I have been watching some of Season 2 again recently, and I'm actually seeing her twisted nature develop. A lot of bad stuff has happened to her character, and I think it's a credit to the writers that they actually gave the character a reason to be as messed up as she is now. While she pisses me off to no end right now, she has gone through substantial character development throughout the series, and when you go back you can really see her evolving through everything that happened to her. That's good television.

bdd • Jan 24, 2007, 06:59pm •
The rectangle of hell needs to end, it looks like I'm watching 90210 in space.

And it's the winter rpimere as the show will end it's season/series before spring.

kgatchel • Jan 25, 2007, 04:10pm •
I'm not a fan of the annoying pop ballads advirtising the Battlestar Galactica either. But, if it's one thing sci-fi shows need now (now that there are some good ones) is to appear accessible to the mainstream. Especially now that they've taken it off the eternal "geek night" (Friday) and thrown it up against every show on Sunday.

And although I worry that the ratings will tank on Sundays, it seems like the sort of risk you need to take to grow, not that Sci-Fi Channel is going to dump Battlestar Galactica anytime soon.

Now, if only they could promote Doctor Who as vigorously.

Vandervecken • Jan 26, 2007, 04:02pm •
How about the coming attraction snippets that show 1) what sure as heck looks like Boltar being executed, to me (the cage-like mask thing while he's screaming "noooooo") and 2) Boltar waking up in a Cylon resurrection tub?

I suppose it could all be dream sequence.

Btw, considering how much the Cylons must surely know about what happened on New Caprica, it's not beyond the realm of possibility that D’Anna knew what happened to Ellen. She surely had to know what Ellen was being forced to do by Cavil. I've been thinking that Ellen might be one of the final 5 for some time now.

Vandervecken • Jan 26, 2007, 04:31pm •
And although Lucy Lawless/D'Anna is undoubtedly out of the show for the season, the image of all the D'Anna models suddenly waking up in their storage units is just too priceless, I think, for the show to resist. All sorts of possibilities; it was a hybrid that steered D'Anna and Boltar toward the temple, which suggests to me that the hybrids, as a group, are in contact, and are up to something of their own. They seem like natural allies for D'Anna, and who know what powers they can truly exert? I disagree with evilkerek; I think the mysticism/prophey aspects adds a fascinating dimension to a science fiction show. Religion often figures in quality written science fiction (eg, Childhood's End, Lord of Light), and that most of the Cylons have a deep belief in God is also fascinating (and I am, personally, an atheist).

mbeckham1 • Jan 29, 2007, 11:01am •
I had a thought for one of the final five.

What about Doc Cottle. I'm actually not joking here. He's important, but in the background and I think he and D'Anna had some kind of exchange on Caprica, and maybe she was apologizing for not showing due humility.

1 2 > >>
Login to post a comment!