TV Review
29 Comments | Add a Comment

2


BATTLESTAR GALACTICA: Six of One

By: Stephen Lackey
Date: Tuesday, April 15, 2008

It’s about time the thematic element of “this has happened before and it will happen again”, come into direct play for the Cylons. It seems that the raider’s meeting with Anders in the season premiere prompted an evolution in the Centurions. They begin developing higher brain functionality, becoming more than simple machines working for the advanced models of Cylon. Right away, Cevil wants to lobotomize the Centurions forcing the evolution to stop. Isn’t this the same issue they have with the humans from Caprica? Yes, it is happening again but for the Cylons it may be coming from an unexpected enemy, themselves.

The Cylons outnumber the humans - they have better technology and weapons, but this sudden divide between the different models may help explain why they can never seem to get the job done when it comes to stopping the humans or at least getting ahead of them. Sure, there’s plenty of unrest among the humans, but they are used to living with unrest, the machines expect order and work the best in that situation.

The tables seem to have turned for Adama and Roslin and it does pose an area of concern for the development of these characters. Roslin started this series as a representative of the religious beliefs of her people and she followed those beliefs through space dragging the caravan of ships along with her. Adama was always the voice of logic, the military man not willing to take chances with his ships and people on what he considered wild goose chases with only religious writings as evidence. Now, even though Roslin continues to see miracles all around her she seems to have looked away from the potential miracle that is Starbuck. Roslin is dying again so if the series led her character on a bitter path of rejecting her religious beliefs I could buy her resistance to Starbuck more. At this point, she just seems to be stubborn. Adama has changed throughout the seasons accepting that things happen that he can’t always fully understand, even if he still doesn’t buy the whole religious prophecy stuff. Adama’s eventual decision on how to handle Starbuck makes the most sense. The chips are down and Galactica can’t afford to let any potential solution to their search fade away without some investigation. 

The four Cylons continue to meet in secret with the goal of finding the fifth Cylon. Why are they so certain the fifth one is a part of their group? Could the fifth one not be on the Cylon base ship? At any rate, they are looking and they believe that Baltar may hold answers whether he knows it or not. So, Tory is asked to take on for the team and in the end she doesn’t appear to be too disappointed. What would the repercussions be on their group if Tory were to fall in line with Baltar’s religious zealots? The connection the five Cylons have to Baltar, if he himself isn’t one, may be more important than you think. Baltar is preaching the religion of the Cylons, the idea of only one God.

There’s a great deal of setup in this episode, preparing for the adventure that is yet to come. Starbuck is on her on in a ship that recycles waste; the Cylons are at the beginning of a Civil War; and the four Cylons are on a search for the fifth. Set up for such complex and epic story is necessary even if it feels a bit anticlimactic in comparison to other episodes in the series. This episode wasn’t action packed but it was dramatic: Lee Adama leaving the military for a political career is an apt evolution of his character and the scenes made for palpable drama, especially between him and his father and between him and Kara. So, while this episode isn’t much of a space opera, it is necessary viewing. The groundwork has been laid for some fascinating storytelling over the remainder of this last season.



Related Products
Comments/Responses
1 2 3 > >>
wasradone • Apr 15, 2008, 01:56am •
Hmmm...I wouldn't give it an 'A' maybe a 'B-'. It was a good episode with Roslin and Adama changing philosophies regarding logic and faith. Baltar's quest is pretty lame even with him seeing himself instead of Six. Lee's becoming a civilian was a letdown and beyond logic considering they are still fighting for their lives and others in the fleet are stuck with the jobs they have and the crappy living quarters proving Baltar's theories of an Aristocracy correct.

The highlight of the show was the Centurian's becoming aware and Six opening a can of whoop ass.

rexxdart • Apr 15, 2008, 04:13am •
I believe it was the raiders that became aware and that were threatened with lobotomization.

The centurians were modified by the Six faction.

rexxdart • Apr 15, 2008, 04:14am •
I believe it was the raiders that became aware and that were threatened with lobotomization.

The centurians were modified by the Six faction.

rexxdart • Apr 15, 2008, 04:15am •
*centurions.


sorry, no edit button anymore.

rexxdart • Apr 15, 2008, 04:16am •
wow, and apparently we are afflicted with multiple post syndrome now too!

macgawd • Apr 15, 2008, 07:05am •
Sadly, I've lost all interest in BSG. It has become too mired in its own metaphysical nonsense, illogical plot twists, and Melrose Place-like melodrama for me to care what happens anymore.

The great scenes like the interaction between Roslin and Adama are too few and far between, and with Moore's insistence upon disintegrating any distinction between Human and Cylon, what's the point? If Moore is going to force the contrivance that the Humans and Cylons ultimately have the same goal, and in the end learn to live together in peace and harmony, then IMO, the entire show was a waste of time.

ponyboy76 • Apr 15, 2008, 07:55am •
Dude, every time there is an article about BSG, you comment on how you don`t like it. Stop watching the damn show! If you don`t get what the shows about and aren`t entertained by their sort of thing than just change the channel. No one is forcing to watch it. Sheesh!
Best show on television, bar none. This episode like Lackey mentions while not action packed was an awesome setup of what is to come. The ramifications of what happened on the Cylon Baseship will definitely be felt by everyone. I had a feeling Adama wouldn`t let Starbuck down and it was a shame to see Apollo leave for gov`t work, although it made sense giving his character development. I do believe Roslin is finally become blinded by her own mortality or she would have believed Starbuck instead of taking a shot at her. The only boring part of the episode was the interaction between Baltar and Roslin`s assistant.Although, it is kind of weird that Baltar is now seeing himself.

chemikillgod • Apr 15, 2008, 08:17am •
People just like to bitch about things. Over and over and over again. It's like they pursue feeling annoyed about something that people like. Apparently, in his view, for it to be a perfect Adama and Roslin should just be stuck at the hip bitching or interacting like married couple all the time. While the entire cast just talks about superficial crap that must be all plot driven, with a lack of character driven pieces (no drama or 'metaphysics'). With the Cylons and Humans just fighting all the time every episode with barely any reason or cause.

That sounds AWESOME.

pekstrand • Apr 15, 2008, 08:36am •
I seldom comment on anything, preferring instead to simply enjoy the rants of others, but regarding BSG I must say I completely agree with Ponyboy. The show is outstanding. It's everything a good TV show is supposed to be. It has all the elements, including great action, great melodrama, wonderful characters and excellent writing. This latest episode continues to solidify it's place as top notch entertainment. I was actually a bit concerned with the direction of the Starbuck character, however after this week the writers have once again shown they know what they're doing. I would also give it an A.

macgawd • Apr 15, 2008, 09:04am •
Ponyboy,

As someone who originally loved BSG, I have the right to comment on what I don't like about the direction of the show. You don't like it? Suck it.


That said, anyone who thinks that the season 3 and season 4 so far is great television "bar none" must be easily entertained by watching paint dry. There is nothing interesting or compelling about the utterly predictable direction the show is taking, and it makes me sad. I keep watching, because I keep hoping to be pleasantly surprised. Ill also keep commenting on what sucks, because there's got to be someone to take the alternative view from those like you who fawn over the shit sandwich that Moore keeps feeding you.

1 2 3 > >>
Login to post a comment!