DVD Review

Mania Grade: B

9 Comments | Add

 

Rate & Share:

0
 

Related Links:

 

Info:

  • Title: Braveheart: Special 2 Disc Collector's Edition
  • Rated: R
  • Cast: Mel Gibson, Sophie Marceau, Patrick McGoohan
  • Writer: Randall Wallace
  • Director: Mel Gibson
  • Distributor: Paramount Home Entertainment
  • Original Year of Release: 1995
  • Extras: Commentary By Mel Gibson, The making of Braveheart, A Writer's Journey featurette, Tales of William Wallace Featurette, Archival interviews with the Cast, trailers

Braveheart: Special 2 Disc Collector's Edition

Tim's thoughts on the new CE...

By Tim Janson, Columnist     January 08, 2008


The coverart for the new 2 Disc Collector's Edition of BRAVEHEART.
© Paramount Home Entertainment

Braveheart is one of my favorite films of the 90’s but I had never purchased it on DVD because the original release was so skimpy in terms of extras. It had only a commentary track and a 30-minute making of feature. Paramount has finally beefed up the DVD with a two-disc set featuring several new extras. While it is not overflowing, it’s light years better than the original release. 

The film tells the story of 13th century Scottish patriot and rebel, William Wallace (Gibson) who unites the various clans of Scotland to fight for their freedom against the English. England had used the turmoil of the previous Scottish king’s death to gain a stronger foothold in the country. When an English Sheriff makes an example of Wallace’s love, Murron, by slitting her throat, Wallace leads a bloody revolt on the local garrison and exacts his revenge on the local magistrate. 

Wallace becomes the inspirational leader of the Scots, even though others have a greater claim to the Scottish throne, such as Robert the Bruce. Wallace leads his men on various guerilla raids against the English, culminating in one of the bloodiest battles ever filmed. Heads and limbs are severed, skulls are crushed, and arrows pierce throats. Rarely had the carnage of battle been so accurately and beautifully shot.

In many ways, Braveheart was like one of those grand Hollywood epics of the 50’s and 60’s like Spartacus or Ben-Hur. Outstanding performances and sweeping landscapes punctuate the film that won the Academy Award for Best Picture. Say what you want about Gibson’s politics and opinions on ethnic groups…he’ still one hell of a filmmaker. 

Certainly the film took liberties with history but even the real Wallace’s life is shrouded in mystery and much of it comes from a poet who wrote the tales over a hundred years after Wallace’s Death. As good as Gibson was in the lead role, my favorite performance was Patrick McGoohan as King Edward I. McGoohan’s crusty and callous portrayal cut an intimidating figure onscreen. He cannot contain his disdain for his homosexual son and in one memorable scene, tosses his son’s lover out a window to his death. This is an outstanding film that holds up view after view.

Now…as to the extras…

The Gibson commentary is back on this new DVD and is insightful because you’re not only getting commentary of the lead actor, but also of the Director and Producer as well as Gibson wore all three hats.

The original DVD had a 30-minute making of Documentary. The new disc has a 49-minute making of documentary. Having not seen the original, I don’t know if any of the material is repeated, but the new documentary has comments from Gibson both currently and from 1995 and he shares the fact that he originally passed on doing the film.

“A Writer’s Journey” is a 21:30 featurette about the writing of the story by Randall Wallace.

“Tales of William Wallace” is a 30 minute documentary about the true William Wallace with comments from various historians.

There is also a 14:30 featurette with interviews with the cast members done back while the film was shooting.

All in all, Paramount has finally given Braveheart fans a DVD release that is worthy of the film.

COMMENTS AND RESPONSES

Showing items 1 - 9 of 9
1 
hanso 1/8/2008 4:10:19 AM
The movie is great, but the original dvd release was weak. Glad to see it's getting a different treatment now, wished it would've gotten a Blu Ray release also. damn paramount.
jdnobody 1/8/2008 6:11:28 AM
It's about time this DVD came out, though it doesn't say anything about extra footage. The one thing I remember hearing was that Gibson had to cut out footage to get an "R" rating so I was expecting a "Director's Cut" of the film, but this will do. Don't even get me started on F'n Blu-Ray. JD www.moviesfornobodies.com
tjanson 1/8/2008 8:09:46 AM
JD... unortunately there is no director's cut or deleted scenes. that would have been nice.
isgrimner 1/8/2008 8:31:25 AM
Braveheart was the first movie I ever saw twice in the theater. I got bored and watched it by myself. Later I went with friends and actually had to convince them to watch Braveheart. I have the original DVD release, but I won't buy again unless it does come out on Blu-Ray. There are already rumors that Paramount has an out clause in their contract that stipulated that if Warner switchs to Blu exclusive they could also end their HD DVD exclusive agreement. Source http://www.engadgethd.com/2008/01/07/paramount-following-warner-out-the-hd-dvd-door/
almostunbiased 1/8/2008 12:55:42 PM
I love this movie, and apparently you do too, since you said "one of my favorite films of the 90’s", so why the B and not an A. You said you were happy about the extras this time. I don't understand. This is an A movie.
braveheart79 1/8/2008 1:42:53 PM
I think it's safe for me to say that this is one of my favorite movies of all time! It's at very least my number 2 It wasn't until 300 came along that I even considered anything could top this film. I totally agree. The origional DVD was weak. How can you have an amazing movie like Braveheart and only have about 32 minutes of extras? I'm with you Almostunbiased. A !!!
highdough 1/8/2008 9:25:44 PM
I can't believe the commentary is the same, if you found it informative. The commentary on the original release was SOOOO boring. There'd be like 10 minutes of silence and then a short comment. I don't recall anything insightful but I never made it through the whole commentary.
axia777 1/9/2008 2:51:23 PM
I absolutely love this movie in every way. paramount has better bring it to Blu ray disc and SOON.
almostunbiased 1/9/2008 5:31:17 PM
That made me think Axia. We should have a poll on this site to see what format we favor. Blu-ray vs HD dvd. I supposse we could just ask, but that would be filled with arguements and chatter. I just want a poll with a choice for one or the other. Just to know what the popular consent on this site is.
1