Comic Review


"Civil War: The Initiative"

By: Kurt Amacker
Review Date: Saturday, March 17, 2007

Civil War: The Initiative sets up the next four months of stories within the Marvel Universe.  The war has ended, Tony Stark has taken over as director of S.H.I.E.L.D., and the 50-state initiative has begun.  But, a few loose ends remain.  Alpha Flight is still taking a dirt nap after facing Michael Pointer, the host of the entity Xorn, who controlled the collective energy signatures of all of the mutants that died at the end of House of M.  Several unregistered superhumans remain at large.  And, Stark still has to rebuild the Avengers – The Mighty Avengers, that is.  Warren Ellis also treats us to a brief interlude that shows the Thunderbolts doing their job – catching wayward superheroes and doing so in a very nasty manner. 

This issue stands less as a cohesive story and more as a series of vignettes to set the stage for the future of the Marvel Universe.  Most of the story rightfully focuses on Stark, which, typical of Brian Michael Bendis, uses dialogue balloons and terse, chatty conversations generously.  I hardly count myself among Bendis’s greatest fans, but he writes well enough.  This issue allows Stark some welcome breathing room after Civil War, but it fails to provide the reader much insight beyond his desire to move his brave new world forward.  This week’s Civil War: The Confession – also by Bendis – offers the reader a more personal look at Stark in the aftermath of both the war and Captain America’s death.  And, for those concerned about Ms. Marvel’s assertion that Steve Rogers survived the shooting, I can assure you that he remains quite dead. 


Marc Silvestri’s art looks like it usually does – left over from the 1990s boom, with lots of detail lines, exaggerated proportions, and not a woman alive without breast enlargement surgery.  Silvestri’s hyper-stylized art and that of others like him has done little to legitimize comics as a medium.  This is the kind of stuff that belongs on t-shirts and posters and little else.  Still, he draws with more restraint than he did on Hunter-Killer 

Other than the mediocre art, Civil War: The Initiative works well enough.  But, it best serves those that read several Marvel Universe titles and want a primer for forthcoming stories. 

Questions? Comments? Let us know what you think at comicscape@mania.com.




More From Mania

More Sellouts: Civil War: Battle Damage Report and Marvel Spotlight: Civil War Aftermath

Means and Ends
(Wednesday, March 28, 2007)
"Civil War: The Confession"
(Friday, March 23, 2007)
Civil War and the Road Ahead
(Wednesday, February 28, 2007)
PAUL JENKINS CIVIL WARS & SIDEKICKS
(Tuesday, September 26, 2006)
CIVIL WAR: FRONTLINE
(Friday, August 11, 2006)
CIVIL WAR: FRONTLINE
(Friday, June 9, 2006)

See more related content
More Content By Kurt Amacker
Comments/Responses
1
Merin • Mar 17, 2007, 10:18am •
A big blech. This book, like a lot of Bendis, was a waste of time.
I'm glad I didn't spend the cash on it. Almost did. I think a lot of my Marvel reading is going to be borrowing from friends until even that level of interest wears out.

I did like Tony's suffering in Confession - that admission at the end must have been so hard to do to a corpse with no one listening. I keep wondering if when he heart condition was solved if they didn't replace Stark's heart with that of Victor Von Doom.

VerbalKent • Mar 17, 2007, 10:40am •
Personally, I thought Silvestri's art was fantastic. I wish he was able to draw more books than he does. Hunter-Killer hasn't been the same since he stopped drawing it. Of course, it's also been mysteriously shipping on schedule. Go figure.

lister • Mar 17, 2007, 01:47pm •
OK I get the idea that in the new regime there will be 50 teams of Avengers, one in each state. But with that many super-teams, it seems unlikely that anyone could stage a real assault on the good guys, the U.S., financial institutions, et. al.

I mean, what chance will the Brotherhood of Evil Mutants have of pulling off some caper if, once they defeat one Avengers team, ten more show up as backup.

I am curious to see what kind of dramatic tension they intend to create for this new state of affairs. It seems unlikely that I could buy into any new team of villains as a real threat knowing there are 49 super-teams waiting in the wings to face them once they defeat, say, the Idaho Avengers.

1
Login to post a comment!