Defiance: I Just Wasnt Made for These Times Review -

Defiance Review

Mania Grade: B+

7 Comments | Add


Rate & Share:


Related Links:



  • Episode: I Just Wasnt Made for These Times (Season 1, Episode 9)
  • Starring: Grant Bowler, Julie Benz, Tony Curran, Jaime Murray, Stephanie Leonidas, Mia Kirshner
  • Written By: Clark Perry
  • Directed by: Allan Kroeker
  • Network: SyFy Channel
  • Series:

Defiance: I Just Wasnt Made for These Times Review

What is it that makes a man a man?

By Chuck Francisco     June 12, 2013

Full spoilers begin below

I am an absolute sucker for man out of time stories. Time travel or cryonics, there's something about a character trying to adapt to our present as history and technology that's unfamiliar which I find compellingly appealing. The previews at the end of last week's episode had already goosed my excitement, but this week's Defiance took that level and uppercut it into the clouds. I was so enthralled by Captain McClintock's story that I almost missed the more nuanced side plots. Luckily episode director Allen Kroeker smartly kept the secondary plot points evenly spaced and provocatively enticing. 

Jaime Murray and Mia Kirshner are both lovely creatures with compelling on screen chemistry as secret lovers Stahma and Kenya, but I've got serious concerns about the future of their relationship. Kenya has taken one step too far beyond professional and into romantic longing, which dangerously complicates the situation. In an incredible miscalculation, she spurns Datak in a fruitless attempt manipulate him into being a better husband to her lover. She's playing with a lit stick of dynamite over a woman who may not even lover her in return. This is going to end badly, likely more so the longer the charade continues. Datak is not, after all, renowned for his mercy.

The Indogenes, as a species, have long fascinated me. Technologically the most advanced of the Votan races, each has a number of artificial modifications implanted. They're long lived, possessed of genius level intellect, and visually interesting. As the primary scientists among the Votans, it was the Indogenes aboard scout ships who conducted brutal medical research on humans. The insinuation is made that this was being done before open hostilities broke out, which would prove that the Votans were offering peace with one hand while hiding a club behind their back in the other (a fact which does not escape slimy E-Rep ambassador Connor). 

The hints were dropped a few episodes back by Pol Madis that Doc Yewll's hands were incredibly dirty, but the extent of that wouldn't really hit home until Captain McClintock leaked silver Indogene blood. In a devious plot straight out of The Manchurian Candidate, McClintock is actually one of the aliens. He was physically altered to appear human and then implanted with the real McClintock's memories (the extraction process is lethal). There are a number of fascinating angles to this. 

The first being that the Indogenes made it appear that McClintock's vessel exploded on reentry. The cultural impact this had on Earth is startling to learn about in retrospect. The crew of the ISS Bravery were hailed as heroes with books and films written about them. A generation of children grow up idolizing him, every bit of his life is studied and made public knowledge. The scene at Rafe's house, as the three older townsfolk recount all of the events McClintock has missed over drinks, is a lot of fun. He asks the question I think everyone of us would: who played me in the movie? I found the handling of the Twilight jokes hysterical; they hit just the right notes and the Amanda's pause was spot on. Side note: I'd never noticed that Rafe's house is practically the only one which is classically appointed before Nolan mentioned it.

The other, more compelling question McClintock's existence brings up is "What decides the nature of a man?". Addressed in plenty of science fiction before it, Defiance leans on a heavily humanistic approach to make the decision a squarely internal one. Graham Greene is let loose to really drive the scene above the cavernous underground lake, and it's his beat moment in the series to date. Rafe is a very compelling character when he's given more to do than snarl and menace others. Here he brings deep, measured introspection. The music works strongly in concert to score the conversation and I was generally moved. I'll admit to being fooled by both McClintock's aiming of Nolan's pistol and of his decision to carry on. His reunion with his aged wife was very touching and pulled at the heart strings much stronger in the wake of the scene with Rafe.

This is a great dose of science fiction, which blends cool technology with exploration of the human soul (what it means to be a man). One of these alone is enough to prove interesting, and so combining them ups the ante. If that weren't enough, there's also political intrigue by way of Connor and the E-Rep, world building through the eyes of McClintock (for whom all of this is new, like us), and father daughter drama as Nolan works to salvage his relationship with Irisa. This show continues to give me reasons to return. If you've read all this and aren't watching the show, I strongly urge you to reconsider. 

Chuck Francisco is a columnist and critic for Mania, writing Wednesday's Shock-O-Rama, the weekly look into classic cult, horror and sci-fi. He is a co-curator of several repertoire film series at the world famous  Colonial Theatre  in Phoenixville, PA. You can hear him drop nerd knowledge on weekly podcast You've Got Geek or think him a fool of a Took on Twitter.


Showing items 1 - 7 of 7
Iridan 6/12/2013 5:45:03 AM

I think it was the best episode so far. I could do without the love triangle (or might it be quad) but I hope it pays off.

I'm not sure why you give the episode such high praise but then it's a B .

redhairs99 6/12/2013 7:45:56 AM

Maybe I'm just being naive but it seems odd to me that they seemed to have dropped the Kenya/Nolan relationship in favor of the Kenya/Datak/Stahma angle.  Of course they could always turn this into a quad-angle romance plot, but Kenya's latching onto Stahma seems out of place given her feelings for Nolan.  I guess we shall see how this all plays out.

I'm glad they have seemly wrapped up this story for the McClintock character.  I didn't find the actor quite as annoying as I did on SG: Universe, of course, I really despised that show overall, but in particular this actor's character in it.  

I can't say that I didn't see that little bit coming at the end with him returning to his long-lost love.  They ended the scene in the caves in a way where we didn't see him jump, so I just assumed that he didn't die and wondered if anyone would ask the question of Rafe "So you're the only one who knows for sure?"  Thankfully they actually had Nolan address it.  Most shows would just let it go with no acknowledgement by other characters.

Iridan 6/12/2013 8:14:35 AM

Yeah, that ending was a little too sappy for me, but I felt it was a strong episode.

redvector 6/12/2013 12:52:00 PM

I'm glad I'm not the only one who didn't like Stargate: Universe. Why create a new Stargate show when they'd canceled Atlantis with no resolution to the storyline? 

redhairs99 6/12/2013 1:24:56 PM

Well, as with Deadwood, we, the fans, were promised a series of direct to DVD movies, which never came to fruition.   I watched the entire run of Universe but it was utterly terrible and not Stargate at all.  I may stop there before I tread into trolling territory ala a former poster that was mentioned on another thread recently that involved how new BSG was only BSG in name only and how great the original BSG was.  

redvector 6/12/2013 1:51:10 PM

It's funny that you mention Deadwood that's the vibe that I get from Defiance. Both towns have a resource that everyone wants. Deadwood had massive amounts of gold and with Defiance it's the golonite. Both town's struggle to maintain their independence in the face of increasingly dictatorial Federal government.

Dazzler 6/13/2013 3:53:55 AM

He was great on Stargate.  I do miss that show.  This was a great ep.  Finally something to remember this series for so far.  I still don't get how the video game is going to effect the show however. 



You must be logged in to leave a comment. Please click here to login.