DEXTER: DO YOU SEE WHAT I SEE Review Comments - Mania.com



COMMENTS AND RESPONSES

Showing items 1 - 10 of 24
1 2 3 >  >>  
fatpantz 12/11/2012 12:41:47 AM

Loved the episode and the season has been great so far...I think my issue with the end of the episode was the fact that Dexter and Deb arrest Hannah....both are too smart to just let someone that knows intricate details of who Dexter is and many of the killings he has done, just go into the prison system with a grudge.  It does not take Encyclopedia Brown to decypher that Hannah is going to sing like a fat lady at the opera.

kennynine 12/11/2012 12:57:02 AM

Just throwing this out there! Is it  possible that Deb is so crazy in love with Dexter that she would lace her own drink and go crash her car in able to frame Hannah? Maybe Dex got manipulated by two woman in this episode.

TheSilentKiller 12/11/2012 5:01:03 AM

 fatpantz - that's exactly what I thought. Hannah, alive and in the same building as LaGuerta? Not a happy combination.

batkruse 12/11/2012 6:14:12 AM

That is a really good point that I did not even fathom when writing the review. They have definitely made it a point to show Deb taking the pills quite a bit, drinking water, etc. I don't think it is out of the realm of possibility b/c when Hannah said "I wouldn't have made a mistake (if I poisoned Deb)," I kind of bought it b/c Deb has really been acting weird since disclosing her true feelings to Dexter. Then again I totally thought Hannah and Deb were gonna make out when Hannah went to visit her unannounced! There was a definite pause in yheir interaction and a beat where I was like, "Whoa, something is about to happen between these two." LaGuerta is just too damn smart and you would have thought that we would have seen her play a mile out but I totally bought in and it added a wow factor when I put the pieces together in my head that it was her that got Estrada out of prison just to lure Dexter in the open. Reminiscent of SILENCE OF THE LAMBS a little bit in the way they played that. Should be a great finale later this week and I am way more into this season as a fan and critic of he show...

Bmfstunner 12/11/2012 7:05:16 AM

My first impressions after watching this episode is that Deb is becoming a Walter white type of character, she's no longer the beacon of justice. Planting evidence leads me to believe she spiked the water, even when Deb was at the hospital, I felt like she was pleading with Dexter to believe. Deb has been saying all along that she'll protect Dexter, I have no doubts it was her with the water. And finally, the Laguerta storyline that should have been coming seasons ago.

ddiaz28 12/11/2012 7:24:48 AM

While I really want Hannah to have told the truth, I also don't want Deb to have manipulated Dex like that.  And you guys are right abuot the arrest thing.  Did Dexter not think that she could rat on him?  Hannah's line "You should have killed me" was a real stab in the heart too.  Yvonne delivered it so well. 

And I loved that LaGuerta set Dex up.  Really didn't see that coming. I just love this show.  Too bad we only have one more season.

redhairs99 12/11/2012 9:32:09 AM

Great episode.  I really hope that Deb didn't poison her own water, but you are right she hasn't really been completely sane this season with all the pills and just her frame of mind in general and trying to wrap her head around who Dex really is.

Totally didn't see LaGeurta's masterful move coming.  Next week will be interesting.

I'll be sad to see the show end after next season (if it in fact does), but I think it will be good to go out while they are still able to tell good stories each week and season.  Granted some on here debate how this show has had mis-steps in quality.  Still, it's been one of the best shows on TV IMO since it's debut.  Sure 1 season may be better than others, etc. but it's remained interesting for me at least.

wish 12/11/2012 1:58:30 PM

I think it's entirely possible that Deb spiked her own water in a last-ditch effort to get Hannah out of the picture.  Afterall, she volunteered to plant evidence for Dexter to get Laguerta off his trail and back on Doakes.  It doesn't make sense that Hannah would be so careless as to spike water that would definitely be found after the fact, cuz she's right, she doesn't make mistakes like that, but then again, Dexter doesn't make mistakes like being lured into a trap either......so maybe the point of the episode was to show how emotions can shake the usually rock-solid methods of these perfect killing machines?  I dunno, I'm failry certain next week's finale will leave a big fat twist or cliffhanger ending so that we can stew about it until next fall!!

Great show, back to it's peak level of performance!!

kennynine 12/12/2012 12:35:14 AM

I think it would be more realistic and make more sense if deb drugged herself, purposely crashed the car, and left the water bottle as evidence for dexter to find. The car just happened to crash in a ditch, and not hit or injure any other people. Deb was not seriously injured. Dexter chose Deb over Hannah. IT all just fits with this theory.

If Hannah did indeed drug deb, she would have had to know about deb taking the drug. She would have had to break into a smart police officers house, find the drug, put the drug in the correct water bottle, and hope that deb would drink that water bottle right before she got behind the wheel of a car. Hannah drugging Deb is too far fetched. What if Deb drank the water before she went to sleep the night before the accident? Nothing happens but Deb having a great nights sleep.

If Deb is the culprit, that could explain hannah keeping quiet about Dexter. If she knows Dexter was manipulated to turn her in, she might still feel for him and think there is hope she can prove Deb was the culprit. Time will tell.

 

wish 12/12/2012 9:31:22 AM

The more I think about it the more I believe Deb set up Hannah and Dexter, she already commited to being a criminal in the very first ep when she helped Dex cover up a murder!  I'm sure we'll see it etiher in the finale or next season, but the truth will come out.  Just another example of emotions blinding Dex's judgement, it's been the theme of the whole season so far.

1 2 3 >  >>  

ADD A COMMENT

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Please click here to login.