DVD Review


DIARY OF THE DEAD

By: Tim Janson
Review Date: Monday, May 26, 2008

George Romero’s four previous zombie films have all followed a natural progression. The Zombie outbreak started in Night of the Living Dead and by the time we reached Land of the Dead the zombies had become the dominant species. However, Romero takes the series back to its roots with Diary of the Dead in more ways than one. Consider this a reboot or a re-take on the start of the zombie outbreak. We are back in Pennsylvania just as the first few reports of the dead returning to life are being broadcast on local news stations. A group of University of Pittsburgh students, working on their own horror film for a class project, pile into a motor home to try and get home. Jason (Joshua Close), the director of their film, decides to start recording the entire event on his camera. 

The group has their first encounter with a zombie along the highway as a burned up state trooper tries to stop their RV. The full realization of what is happening finally hits them as they take an injured friend to a hospital only to find it empty…except for a few undead doctors and nurses. Even as the carnage unfolds, Jason continues to film, uploading his footage onto the Internet even as his girlfriend Debra chastises him for his insensitivity. Immediately you’re thinking Night of the Living Dead meets Cloverfield because of the handheld camera. The camera work in Diary is certainly less jerky than in Cloverfield and much of the time you’ll barely notice it. 

Diary is the closest zombie film yet in terms of scope to Night of the Living Dead. It’s a small cast working within the confines of a handful of sets and locations. There are fewer zombies than in any previous Romero zombie film since “Night”. This is all by design. Romero wanted to return to a smaller, independent feature. His intent was to make the film for under a million dollars. This was a very personal film for George, one that he could do entirely his way without having to please studio bosses. Romero talks quite candidly about this during the making of documentary. While he certainly enjoyed working with the bigger budget he had with Land of the Dead, you get the feeling that he’s more comfortable with a smaller film.

The cast is largely unknown but not inexperienced. Most of the actors have at least a couple of dozen credits in both film and TV. No one stands out but no one hams it up either. What the film lacks, however, is any real tension. The difference with Diary and the rest of the series is that our survivors are mobile, and are not trapped within a farmhouse, shopping mall, underground bunker, or a walled city. The one time they are pinned down within an old barn they are able to make a quick getaway.

Diary is also less bloody than Romero’s previous films, in part because of the camera work.  Since the whole thing is supposed to take place through the lens of Jason’s camera, some of the zombie feeding activity must be imagined. There are some notable special effects, such as the zombie who gets a jar of acid busted over his head and his skull slowly is dissolved down to the brain. Still, you have to admire Romero. He could have made another big-budget zombie film but he told the story that he wanted to tell.
 
Extras

Pulling up the grade on the DVD is a nice set of extras. Romero, Director of Photography Adam Swica, and Editor Michael Doherty provide a lively audio commentary. The best extra is the feature lengths (80+ minutes) making of documentary covering the cast, crew, special effects, make-up, and more.

Other extras include featurettes on the first week of filming, character confessionals, and the inspiration for the film. Romero recruited some well-known horror personalities to do some of the voices you hear over the radio and TV in the film and these are covered in a featurette called “Familiar Voices”.

Finally there are five short zombie films, winners of a Myspace contest that are quite entertaining and well-made.


More Content By Tim Janson
DVD Review of Dexter Season 2
(Wednesday, September 3, 2008)
Book Review of The Art of Marc Silvestri
(Tuesday, September 2, 2008)
Book Review of Creepy Archives Vol. 1
(Monday, September 1, 2008)
Weekly Book Buzz: Romita Finds Himself Stranded
(Monday, September 1, 2008)
DVD Review of Phantasm 4: Oblivion
(Saturday, August 30, 2008)
DVD Review of Scorpion King 2: Rise of a Warrior
(Saturday, August 30, 2008)
DVD Review of Starship Troopers 3: Marauder
(Monday, August 25, 2008)
DVD Review of Witchblade the Complete Series
(Sunday, August 24, 2008)
Trade paperback Review: Indiana Jones Omnibus Vol. 2
(Wednesday, August 20, 2008)
Book Review of Comic Art Now
(Monday, August 18, 2008)
Comments/Responses
1
spiderhero • May 26, 2008, 05:39am •
Eh...I didn't like Romero's last Zombie flick & this review doesn't make me want to see this one. I think I'll pass.

jedibanner • May 26, 2008, 05:43am •
I though it was ok but, the only part I didn't like the movie was EVERYTIME that dumass ''Jason'' character was speaking, I felt I wanted to shoot him instead of listen to him (he's the guy who was holding the camera all the time). I mean, he bugged the hell out of me everytime he was asking stupid, stupid questions about how do you feel after running over people, how do you feel about what you're seeing, bla bla bla...

That's the part that took out the element of real life being filmed in the movie because that character was justs stupid in my view and if I was one of his friend in the movie, I would've punched him myself. In any case, it's still worth to watch it but, I'll wait until it gets into the bins of 2 DVD's for 30$ or something.


rudewordsmith • May 26, 2008, 09:23am •
I am still hurting over the disappointment of this film. It was acted, written and directed more like a crummy Sci-Fi Original Movie rather than a true George A. Romero film. It felt like someone impersonating Romero. Since it wasn't, that just makes the whole ordeal that much more sad and pathetic.

Plus, the whole "mocumentary" schtick only works if the characters feel real. They didn't. They still spoke like teens in a horror film. And the Professor? Always with the solemn, slurred philosophic quotations and traditional "thriller" tough guy dialogue. "It's time we leave this place." Who actually says that? "Let's go", "Let's get the Hell out of here". When you're panicking, the last thing on your mind is "How do I say this in the most old fashioned way -- because, you know, I'm a professor?"

And the action scenes fell so flat. There was not a scary scene in the whole mess of film. Not one scene. Romero is better than this. And please don't let him do the CGI gore effects any more. Squibs work just as well, and they're just as cheap.

I never thought I'd live to see the day when Romero would hand in something so pedestrian and boring. F-.

drewan86 • Jul 28, 2008, 06:09am •
hi! it could be cool!

1
Login to post a comment!