Dollhouse: Belonging Review - Mania.com



TV Review

Mania Grade: B

13 Comments | Add

 

Rate & Share:

 

Related Links:

 

Info:

  • TV Series: Dollhouse
  • Episode: Belonging
  • Starring: Eliza Dushku, Olivia Williams, Harry Lennix, Fran Kranz, Enver Gjokaj, Dichen Lachman
  • Written By: Maurissa Tancharoen, Jed Whedon
  • Directed By: Jonathan Frakes
  • Network: Fox
  • Series: Dollhouse

Dollhouse: Belonging Review

The Origin of Sierra Revealed

By Kurt Anthony Krug     October 25, 2009


Dollhouse Review(2009).
© Fox/Bob Trate

 

After being off the air last week, Dollhouse returns with a solid and disturbing episode. While the main character Echo (Eliza Dushku) is in the background again this episode, the spotlight is shined on fellow Doll Sierra (Dichen Lachman), whose origin is revealed.
 
Turns out she’s an Australian artist named Priya who’s working in the United States without a visa. She becomes the object of desire of a wealthy, handsome doctor named Nolan Kennard (Vincent Ventresca). However, Priya’s not interested in him and the doctor’s desire turns to violent obsession. He systematically strips away her identity, pumping her full of anti-psychotic drugs, turning her into a paranoid schizophrenic. Priya then is sent to the Dollhouse, where she’s cured of her mental illness upon being transformed into Sierra by Topher (Fran Kranz), which goes back to the first episode of the series when Echo walks in on him giving her a treatment.
 
While in their docile states, the Dolls are becoming self-aware and retaining aspects of their prior personalities. Further, their sexuality is awakening in their docile states as Sierra reveals her love for Victor (Enver Gjokaj). Their love is so powerful that mind-wipes can’t erase it. When Topher (who seems to be growing a conscience this season) learns that Kennard is employing Sierra for repeat engagements, which include rape, Kennard is confronted by Adelle DeWitt (Olivia Williams), the Dollhouse honcho.
 
Unfortunately, Kennard has Matthew Harding (Keith Carradine), a top Dollhouse official who is superior to Adelle, in his backpocket. Harding tells her that she has no choice but to comply with the client’s wishes and Sierra is handed over to Kennard, though none too willing. Without revealing too much more of the plot, a carefully-designed plan to rescue Sierra is orchestrated by Topher and Boyd (Harry Lennix), which results in a very gory ending.
 
There’s plenty of good character development this episode, besides just Topher. We learn that Adelle has skeletons in her closet, including having a few flings with Victor, something Harding stated was the least of her worries. Williams as Adelle has a very ladylike calmness about her. When she gets mad, she doesn’t explode; instead, she gets cool and her voice goes flat but firm. Turns out, she also likes her booze as she’s imbibing several times this episode.
 
Paul Ballard (Tahmoh Penikett) was absent from this episode, which is fine. It makes sense since he’s Echo’s handler and not Sierra’s. Otherwise, there’d be no room for character development.
 
Other notable items about this episode are the guest stars, the writers, and director. Veteran actor Carradine, the brother of the late David Carradine of Kung Fu fame, has recently been seen on Dexter and Deadwood. Part of the fun of bringing in other top Dollhouse officials is having them played by recognizable actors like Carradine and Battlestar Galatica alumnus Michael Hogan. Also, Carradine co-starred with Ventresca in the short-lived 2005 series, Complete Savages.
 
Speaking of Ventresca, he is no stranger to genre shows, having appeared in 1998’s short-lived yet promising science-fiction series Prey with a pre-Will & Grace Debra Messing. Additionally, he was the lead as Darien Fawkes on SCI-FI’s The Invisible Man from 2000-02. He also played a love interest of Courteney Cox on Friends named Fun Bobby.
 
As for the writers, Jed Whedon (Dollhouse creator Joss Whedon’s brother) and Maurissa Tancharoen were two of the writers on 2008’s critically acclaimed Internet short-film, Dr. Horrible’s Sing-Along Blog. And the director, Jonathan Frakes, really needs no introduction. Trekkies fondly remember him as Commander (now Captain) William T. Riker on Star Trek: The Next Generation from 1987-1994, as well as four Star Trek movies from 1994-2002. Further, Frakes has proved himself as a talented director in his own right, having directed numerous episodes of the Trek franchise, 1996’s Star Trek: First Contact, 1998’s Star Trek: Insurrection, 2004’s Thunderbirds, among others.
 
Now for the bad, which has nothing to do with Dollhouse per se: Why the hell is FOX not airing this show for over a month? It’s returning Dec. 4 with a 2-hour episode, which is all well and good, but this show barely got a second season, the ratings aren’t the greatest, and rather than try to build an audience, instead it gets yanked for well over a month. That makes no sense whatsoever.
 
When you do that, shows lose a lot of momentum. That happened with Lost, Heroes, Alias, even Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles, another FOX show that was pulled off the air for over 2 months last year, reappearing on Feb. 13, the night of the debut episode of Dollhouse. And look what happened to that show. That does not bode well for Dollhouse, which has only been picked up for 13 episodes this season. Fans, be prepared to express your displeasure to FOX.


 

COMMENTS AND RESPONSES

Showing items 1 - 10 of 13
1 2 >  >>  
ponyboy76 10/25/2009 6:55:23 AM

Honestly, this episode deserves an A or at the very least a B .  This was a really good episode. I like that Echo's story took a backseat to Sierra but was still pivotal in the episode. Dichen Lachman is a pretty damn good actress, too. Dollhouse is getting better with every episode. Its too bad that the ratings aren't reflecting that.

ponyboy76 10/25/2009 6:57:52 AM

Fox did the same damn thing to Firefly, so I'm not surprised they are scewing over Dolhouse with this month lay-off. I bet they figure since they picked it up for a second season, they don't owe Joss anything anymore.

obsidian 10/25/2009 8:48:47 AM

Best. Dollhouse Episode. Ever.

Granted, that would usually not mean much over the life of this show.  I've warily watched this show waiting for the various flashes of promise to turn into something concrete.  This week's episode was completely solid.  Definitely an A.  For the first time, the reality of the Dollhouse, the whole sordidness of the concept, the very sordidness of the premise that may end up dooming this series, was fully embraced by the writers.

The Dollhouse is a flesh market.  Pure and simple.  Absolute power over the dolls is corrupting the Dollhouse personnel in various significant ways, and probably corrupting the Rossum Corporation as well. 

The direction made this episode look and feel like a movie.  The nonlinear plot (always a risk) was used perfectly.  The origin of Sierra and her character arc was amazing.  The actress who plays her basically stole the show.  The Topher character has NEVER been better and his moral awakening (and its consequences) made this episode head and shoulders over anything this show has produced so far.  Adele's moral dilemma and Keith Carradine's sublime sliminess just made a great episode even better.   

I feel like I'm writing an epitaph for this show .  I think Whedon and company thought they were writing another 'superior plucky girl against the world' story, but it looks like something much darker and interesting is beginning to emerge.  However, the Dollhouse concept is too dark (too sleazy?) and too morally ambiguous to stay on network TV IMO.  One episode does not a series make, but this particular episode is one of the best things of seen out of a Whedon production in a long time. 

This show should be on HBO or Showtime.  FOX will probably kill it though.

ultrazilla2000 10/25/2009 10:28:37 AM

Actually this episode is NOT where we first learned of Adelle's "indiscretions" with Victor, there was an episode last season which covered her little secret.  Excellent episode though.  I often find Topher to be a little grating, but he always ends up enduring by the end of the episodes.  The innocent love between Victor and Sierra is adorable, and it was touching how Sierra was able to remember the feelings through the personalities.  I really hope this show continues for many seasons.   What happened to Amy Acker though?  Is she off the show forever now???  They got rid of her right when her character became interesting!

animefanjared 10/25/2009 11:03:15 AM

This show is on it's way out, unfortunately.  And Whedon knows it.  He acknowledged the show's terrible ratings and has stated that the 13th episode of this season is being written so that it can function as a series finale if need be.  It being pulled off the air for a month shows that Fox is pretty much done with it.

I agree, this doesn't need to be on network TV.  It would do much better (and survive longer) on cable.  I think the best thing we can hope for at this point is that some cable network picks it up after Fox cancels it at the end of this season.

LittleNell1824 10/25/2009 3:05:12 PM

That was a great episode, possibly saved by Frakes. I agree with Obsidian that acknowledging the sordidness is the best way to go. At this point I can't wait to see what happens next, which should have been the case from the start. As far as the life of the series, it's up to Joss to shop it around if he doesn't want it cancelled. I don't think he should put any of his future shows on FOX.

Off-topic, but is anyone else excited by AMC/IFC's mini-series remake of The Prisoner?

IGPNicki 10/25/2009 9:10:28 PM

It's definitely not a good sign that they're canning the series for the next month. Conversely, they're planning on showing all 13 episodes, so that's at least something. If it does get canned, hopefully the viewers can get some closure! And I thought it was an excelent episode. One of the best so far. I loved all the hints of things to come, like Toher trying to work on doing a remote wipe. We learned a lot more about the people in the Dollhouse including Boyd... who saw that coming? I;m thinking he didn't learn how to get rid of a body simply from being a cop!

http://www.igp-scifi.com/dollhouse-episode-guide-2.html

ManiaHasIssues 10/25/2009 11:05:53 PM

 "hey, look at me! i convert imdb info into one third of an article, shallowly spoil the plot for another third, comment on the network's history, and still call it a review!"

how about you actually review the show next month? that way you might ACTUALLY draw in new viewers for the show your so WORRIED about getting canceled.  

mbeckham1 10/26/2009 11:29:46 AM

Defintely more Amy Acker, her performance in the season premier was the highlight of the whole series, I'd love to see her and her tormented issues with Topher get played out more. topher was brilliant here, continuing the journey Whiskey/Saunders put him on. Echoe's pushing people into moral and emotional; conflicts is fascinating. Wanbt to know more about this Storm. I wonder if waking people up will be a sort of better intentioned version of what Alpha tried to do to her. Sierra was brilliant both as herself and as her Doll, Victor was brilkliant botyh as the art guy and as his Doll self. Keith Carradine as unbelievably creepy and slimy as the bad guy, the complete opposite of Agent Lundy from Dexter. Brilliant show. Loved Ventressca and Adell to, her barely contained fury was palpable and he was one of the sleeziest characters I've ever seen, quite diferent from his Darian Fawkes. You might also add to Frakes credits David Xanatos of Gargoyles opne of the coolest characters in American animation. And I think he directed some of those episodes. He also directed some recrent episodes of Leverage which is a cool Fun show . I also liked his turn as Will Riker's transporter clone in Deep Space Nine.

Vyse 10/26/2009 8:45:05 PM

I agree: Best. Dollhouse Episode. Ever!

1 2 >  >>  

ADD A COMMENT

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Please click here to login.

POPULAR TOPICS