DVD Review

Send to a Friend



To: (email)


To: (name)


From: (name)


Message:



DVD Review of Birds of Prey The Complete Series

By: Tim Janson
Review Date: Thursday, July 24, 2008

Over five years after its last episode, Birds of Prey: The Complete Series, is available on DVD. The show premiered on the WB Network just one year after Smallville, and certainly Warner Bros. was hoping for a similar success story. Alas, the show ran for only 13 episodes before it was canceled despite decent ratings in the key 18 – 34 demographic. So why did it fail? It’s not hard to come up with a few reasons.
 
First there is the recognition factor. Even people who have never picked up a comic book know who Superman is but outside of comic book fans, The Huntress and Oracle are not exactly household names. Secondly, with comic book fans being predominantly male, they perhaps didn’t fully embrace a superhero show with all female characters. And you have to assign a lot of the blame at Warner Bros. and DC Comics as well who have stubbornly protected how their characters appear on the small screen. Batman was only shown in the show’s prologue and few other characters from the comics appear. 
 
The premise of Birds of Prey is that Batman has defeated the Joker in one last battle. However, the Joker escapes long enough to kill Catwoman and shoot Barbara Gordon AKA Batgirl, paralyzing her. Seven years later, Helena Kyle, the daughter of Catwoman and Batman, fights crime as The Huntress, a half Meta-human with enhanced speed, agility, and strength. As in the comics, Barbara Gordon becomes Oracle, operating a Batcave-live operation at the top the New Gotham clock tower. Joining them is young Dinah Lance, also a meta-human with precognitive, telepathic, and telekinetic powers. Dinah is the daughter of Black Canary.
 
Birds of Prey was a stylish, and beautifully shot series. It gave viewers a Gotham that was modern yet gritty and noir-ish. The cast was the strongest part of the show. Dina Meyer is a dead ringer for Batgirl/Barbara Gordon and her calm, controlled personality was the balance to Ashley Scott’s ferocious and often bad-tempered Huntress. Ian Abercrombie plays a distinguished and thoughtful Alfred Pennyworth, Bruce Wayne’s longtime butler. Shemar Moore is the skeptical detective Jesse Reese.
 
The boxed set includes all 13 episodes of the series as well as the unaired pilot. In addition, the set also includes all 30 episodes of the Gotham Girls Flash-animated series that originally appeared on the Warner Bros. website in 2000 – 2002. The episodes run 3 – 5 minutes in length and feature the same voices of those actors who worked on the Batman: The Animated Series show including Adrienne Barbeau, Diane Pershing, and Tara Strong.
 
In the original pilot episode, Dinah comes to Gotham as a teen, searching for Huntress and Barbara Gordon after seeing them in her dreams. Huntress and Oracle are investigating a series of apparent suicides, which turn out to be the work of a Scarecrow-like villain who injects his victims with a drug that terrifies them into suicide. Dr. Harleen Quinzel (Mia Sara) is also introduced as Helena’s therapist and the mastermind criminal, Harley Quinn. In the unaired pilot, is Sherilyn Fenn who plays Quinzel.
 
Some of the notable episodes include:
 
“Slick” in which Quinn recruits a meta-human who can turn into water, to get revenge on New Gotham for her beloved Joker.
 
In “Sins of the Mother”, Dinah’s mother, The Black Canary is reunited with her daughter and tries to explain why she left Dinah with a foster family. Meanwhile a local mob boss is out to kill the Black Canary and Dinah. Lori Laughlin plays Black Canary and she is one of the few low points of the set. Her performance is dull and lifeless.
 
Someone is kidnapping female meta-humans in “Gladiatrix” and forcing them to fight to the death in an underground arena. When both Dinah and Helena are captured, they will be pitted against each other unless Barbara and Reese can save them.
 
The set closes out with a two-part finale “Feat of Clay/Devil’s Eye” Clayface’s son has stolen his father’s formula and is using it to turn people into clay statues. Helena questions Clayface who is imprisoned in Arkham Asylum. We learn a shocking revelation about who killed Catwoman, and the team has a final showdown with Harley Quinn.
 
There are no extras in the set but it’s just nice to see this series on DVD. The series was stylish, perhaps too stylish at times, but the actors all seemed committed to their roles. It deserved better treatment than it got and had it come out today, after so many recent comic book film hits, it may have had better success.


More Content By Tim Janson
Fandango Logo
Comments/Responses
1 2 > >>
jyansr • Jul 24, 2008, 04:53am •
Does anyone know if this is worth buying? I found some scenes on Youtube, but wasn't really impressed.

hanso • Jul 24, 2008, 05:05am •
I'm thinkin about buyin it although I never really got into the show.

filmnotmovie • Jul 24, 2008, 05:52am •
I have a really hard time recommending this show. Even though I'm a bit fuzzy on specifics,
I seem to recall the series being something of a disappointment. Yes, Dina Meyer did an
excellent job as Barbara\Batgirl\Oracle. Her performance actually anchored the show and
balanced some of the histrionics of the other performers. Ashley Scott made for a charismatic and sexy Huntress, but Rachel Skarsten often came off as whiney and annoying.
The concept was a bold and imaginative step, but the execution fell well short of the the
innovative premise. Most of the stories were bland, with unimaginative special effects that
resembled some of the lesser fare of the Sci-Fi Channel. I think the folks at the WB were
hoping to duplicate the success of "Charmed," with the female trio dynamic. However, the "Birds" cast lacked the chemistry of the "Charmed" cast, and the writing was not up to
the standard of "Charmed." This is a real shame, because, as stated in the review, the look
of show was dark and engrossing, much like the "Underworld" films. Having said all that, the show is definitely worth a look, although you may want to sample the Youtube clips before investing in the box.

jyansr • Jul 24, 2008, 09:05am •
I was pleased to see Harley Quinn in it, but IMO she was just played to straight. Once again, maybe I just sampled the wrong clips. Unfortuantely I don't think, ok I know, that the show wasn't well known enough that I will be able to sample the DVD from my local video store.

hanso • Jul 24, 2008, 01:30pm •
Netflix it yo.

ashamel • Jul 25, 2008, 02:41am •
I'm about 8 episodes into it. The cast is really good, but the stories are a bit dodgy. It's worth a look.

Todd89 • Jul 25, 2008, 08:29am •
I remember this show when it was on the air. All of you are right though, but the title seemed off. Birds of Prey before it came on, I thought that it was the superhero group that was based on the comic. But to my delight it wasn't, what threw me off was the fact that Catwoman and Batman had a daughter. I don't ever recall that ever happened.
The stories are uninteresting, but through the small success that it had I thought we'll get to see an older Batman who faked his death.
It had a strong cast, but it needed better story lines to keep you griped. To bad though, but it is worth to buy the dvd set from what I read above.

marinej22 • Jul 25, 2008, 01:12pm •
just stick to A-team episodes, B.A Barakus kicks ass!!!

Hobbs • Jul 25, 2008, 05:23pm •
I know a few people that loved this show and are seriously pissed at the DVD's. They had a license problem getting the same music that was in the orignal series so the music has been recorded over and I heard the DVD transfer isn't very good. A buddy of mine said it looks like WB half ass put it together. Having only briefly watched it when it was on I can't comment to that but I thought it was worth mentioning.

I am concerned, however, if warner half ass put this together are they going to do the same thing with Witchblade that comes out next week? That's the one I'm picking up and will be just as pissed if they did.

indybyteman • Jul 29, 2008, 06:58am •
Huntress was the daughter of Batman and Catwoman when the character was first introduced. That story line took place on Earth 2. (A sort of alternate reality of the DC Universe).

I enjoyed the show when it aired and definitely enjoy the DVD set, even though the music is definitely different. (Glad to read your post Hobbs. I thought I was going crazy on the music being different on the DVD).

1 2 > >>
Login to post a comment!