DVD Shopping Bag


DVD Shopping Bag: Seventy Minutes

By: Robert T. Trate
Date: Tuesday, June 17, 2008

The new version of the Incredible Hulk is, in my opinion, well done. It is not awesome nor is it awful. It is a tribute to the TV show if nothing else. Finally the heart, soul and loneliness of Bruce Banner are back and that part of the movie is better than Ang Lee’s version. Now I hear there is more Incredible Hulk out there, somewhere.

The rumor about the new Incredible Hulk movie is that seventy minutes has apparently been cut from the film. Edward Norton has stepped aside from doing any publicity about the film. He is apparently upset because Marvel wanted to trim down the film and make it sleeker and more action oriented. Marvel Studios shortened the film, as rumors have it, to separate it from Ang Lee’s vision of the Hulk from back in 2003. Will this keep you from seeing it in the theater with the hope of a longer cut on DVD? Will this keep you from seeing it again in the theater knowing full well that another version sits out there in some editing bay? 

I cannot help but wonder about those additional seventy minutes. Would a longer version of movie been better? Peter Jackson’s last two films come to mind has great arguments for the pro and con: The Lord of the Rings Return of the King and King Kong


The theatrical cut of Return of the King was long. Many thought even too long. However, many fans love the extended cut and all knew that when the DVD arrived there would be “…room for a little more”. We all knew there would be more because it had happened two times before. We knew it, loved it and couldn’t wait to buy it. The problem was when Peter Jackson delivered his next film we saw this huge bloated tribute to King Kong. A long version with nothing left on the editing room floor. Taking a lead from his extended cuts of LOTR, Jackson gave us what he thought we all wanted, everything. The film was an awesome spectacle but after a while it became a snore fest just waiting for them to get to the island and then for Kong to get to the Empire State Building. A shorter version of the film could have made that longer cut a treat instead it just turned a lot of people off. 

Will Norton’s cut of the Incredible Hulk surface? Will those seventy minutes really matter or will they release both versions like they did for Mark Steven Johnson’s Daredevil? Will you wait for the longer cut? All this is in Marvel’s hands but will your dollars go into Marvel’s pocket?

ACTION / ADVENTURE / KUNG FU/ THRILLERS / WESTERNS

Brenner

Cut Off

 
ANIME

Blood+: Volume Two

Gundam Seed Destiny TV Movie Limited Edition

Gundam Seed Destiny, TV Movie 1

Legend of Crystania Complete Collection

Noir Complete Collection

The Restless

School Rumble: Extra Class OVA

Shuffle, Vol. 4

xxxHOLiC: Third Collection

CARTOONS
Galaxy High School Collection

The Jungle Book 2 (Special Edition)

Popeye and Friends, Vol. 1

Popeye the Sailor: 1938-1940, Vol. 2

-Popeye Commentaries - Including historians, animators and filmmakers
-Popeye Popumentaries - A closer look the voices of the show
-"Out of the Inkwell: The Fleischer Story" - a featurette chronicling the lives of the Fleischers
-"Men of Spinach and Steel" featurette

-Classic Paramount Short
-Early Max Fleischer Short & Art Gallery
-Females is Fickle Pencil Test
-Stealin Ain't Honest Storyboard Reel
-Vintage Audio Recording from I'm Popeye the Sailor Man
-Interview with Jack Mercer (audio only)

Sonic Underground, Vol. 2

The Sword in the Stone (45th Anniversary Special Edition)

Transformers Animated: Transform and Roll Out Check out my review

COMEDY AND LOVE Mania Style

Be Kind Rewind

The Nude Bomb
-The original Get Smart movie

Criterion Collection

Classe Tous Risques - Criterion Collection

- New, restored high-definition digital transfer

- Excerpts from Claude Sautet ou la magie invisible, a 2003 documentary on the director

- Interview with Classe tous risques novelist and screenwriter José Giovanni

- Archival interview footage featuring actor Lino Ventura

- Original French and U.S. release trailers

 
HORROR

Alive or Dead

The Dead Pit

The Sitter

Tokyo Shock Horror Pack Triple Feature (Japanese Hell, Cursed and Samurai Chicks)

SCIENCE FICTION / FANTASY

Men in Black [Blu-ray]

Men in Black

-re-released to coincide with the Blu-ray Edition
 
TV LAND

Burn Notice - Season One

Californication - Season One

ER - The Complete Ninth Season

Jericho - The Second Season

-Commentary: Dan Shotz, Jon Steinberg
-Series Finale As Broadcast
-Series Finale With Alternate Unaired Ending
-Rebuilding Jericho
-Nut Job

Jericho - The Complete Series

Lonewolf & Cub TV (Volume 2, Eps. 6-9)

Wanted Dead or Alive - The Best Of


More Content By Robert T. Trate
Toy Maniac: Top 10 Horror Action Figures
(Thursday, October 9, 2008)
Watching the WATCHMEN
(Wednesday, October 8, 2008)
WATCHMEN: Snyder and Gibbons speak in NY
(Wednesday, October 8, 2008)
DVD Review of Psycho - Special Edition
(Tuesday, October 7, 2008)
DVD Shopping Bag: Facing the Faces of Death
(Tuesday, October 7, 2008)
Toy Maniac: Guns, Gadgets and Giganta for Halloween
(Thursday, October 2, 2008)
DVD Review of Beetlejuice: Deluxe Edition
(Wednesday, October 1, 2008)
DVD Shopping Bag: Munster Memories
(Tuesday, September 30, 2008)
DVD Review of Speed Racer
(Monday, September 29, 2008)
DVD Review of Torchwood: The Complete Second Season
(Friday, September 26, 2008)
Fandango Logo
Comments/Responses
1 2 > >>
TayDor • Jun 17, 2008, 02:35am •
What's with all the Hulk bashing articles? Between this article and the other one written by the idiot who hadn't even seen the new movie yet, it gives an overall impression that Mania.com is trying to tank the new Hulk movie.

spiderhero • Jun 17, 2008, 04:56am •
I want a longer Hulk. I want the hole sfilled in & depper character development. Dr. Sampsom for example. There was supposed to be tension between Banner & Sampson, instead they never even appeared together. I hope Leterrier does make a director's cut, contrary to what he said. I want the "real" movie.

eagle97 • Jun 17, 2008, 06:05am •
The director of The Incredible Hulk has stated in an interview on G4 that there will not be a longer cut on the DVD. He DID say that all the of the extra material would be there however. I see a second disc full of deleted scenes. It is nice to think that a director would stay with one cut of the film. We'll see if the producers override his desire.

WISEGUY562 • Jun 17, 2008, 08:43am •
I think Marvel as the owners of the film will have final say. Maybe Louis won't actually put the film together, meaning they can't call it the Director's Cut but they can just call it the extended edition. I'd buy the theatrical version and a couple of months later when the extended edition came out I'd buy that, just like I did with LOTR. I'm sure they'll do it, too much money at stake and I'm already looking forward to it.

almostunbiased • Jun 17, 2008, 09:15am •
But this is the movie the producers wanted and the director wanted, he says, so why would they have anotehr version? (other than money of course)

And I'm just going to complain here: What's with the new pick this pick that crap just to get to the site? I was just starting to really like this place again and then something else annoying.

fft5305 • Jun 17, 2008, 10:11am •
TayDor, check out my rant on a previous Hulk article: http://www.mania.com/box-office-hulk-flies-into-top-spot_article_58680.html?page=3 For whatever reason, I think the media *wants* to see the Hulk fail. eagle, I saw the G4 interview too. I hope he doesn't go back on his word and release a DC after everyone has bought the DVD. I have the feeling they'll do as Wiseguy says, but call it a "Gamma Powered Extended Edition" or some bullshit like that.

WISEGUY562 • Jun 17, 2008, 11:52am •
fft, nice. See now you gave them a good idea of what to call it.

jonniej1017 • Jun 17, 2008, 01:23pm •
I saw the HULK yesterday with my 7 year old nephew, we thought it was great. I loved the action scenes and so did he. I think if there was anymore character scenes or more talking he would have lost interest. The film was 2 hours, i mean how much longer can u realy make a superhero movie?? It was perfect, did not need to b any longer or need any character history. It's the HULK, everyone knows whats goin on... accident in the lab, little scientist turns into big green guy when he gets angry... just dont make this guy angry. THAT's IT. lol anyway, I loved it!

hanso • Jun 17, 2008, 01:24pm •
If we get the extra mins as deleted scenes it's gonna be bullshit. I read somewhere it was more like 50 mins though, whatever they need to include it when they release that shit on Blu Ray, both versions same disc.
Hulk Smash son!!!!!!!!!!

hanso • Jun 17, 2008, 01:25pm •
I'll tell you how much longer you can make a superhero movie, 152 mins long. 152 mins equal EPIC son!

1 2 > >>
Login to post a comment!