This movie was so bad, why are they even giving this a DvD realease.... let alone a blu-ray

I am going to rent it just to see if it is possibly so bad it might be good :D

I actually enjoyed it. Then I wasn't expecting much. I do agree with Janson that Routh was "more believable as Superman".

Then again, I wanted the other two Superman movies Routh was supposed to do because I liked "Superman Returns". I think that is Routh's problem here; we see Clark Kent rather than Dylan Dog.

 I wasn't even aware this came out in theaters.  I thought the previews looked ok.  Netflix, here it comes.

They should do a three-pack of Routh's movies titled "Suckass Routh Films"...Dylan Dog, Scott Pilgrim and Superman Returns

 I liked Scott Pilgrim.

I'll order it from Blockbuster and keep it on hand until there is nothing worth watching on either of the History Channels....

I saw Dylan Dog on opening day, and was not impressed.  I didn't have any problems with Routh being in it, though.  He gave a fine performance.  I just didn't care for the story, and the female lead was in desperate need of a few good meals.  Nobody that skinny is fighting off anyone.  I definitely agree with Tim that the 'romance' was shoehorned into the story.  There's a pretty girl in the story, therefore the hero HAS to sleep with her. 

Scott Pilgrim was awesome, and Routh was awesome in it. 

Yeah his features were too soft to buy him as superman let alone a grizzled noire detective. glad they finally have a more chisiled Superman this time around