Eternally Yours -


7 Comments | Add


Rate & Share:


Related Links:



  • Series:

Eternally Yours

Making a Case for an Eternals Revival!

By Chad Derdowski     February 16, 2011

Chad makes a case for an Eternals Revival!
© N/A


Go ahead and file this one under “pipe dreams”, but it’s our soapbox and we’re gonna rant. And as usual, we’re gonna take the long way around, so bear with us.
Movies get remade all the time. Franchises get overhauled and rebooted only three films deep. Sometimes it’s infuriating and has us shaking an angry fist at an imaginary Hollywood sign in our minds over the lack of creativity found in the so-called arts. Other times, we’re totally on board, hoping that the re-imagined version of whatever it was that we loved before lives up to the standard we’ve set or better yet, surpasses the original, whatever the original may be.
It’s probably a lot easier for comic book fans to accept remakes, reboots and re-imaginings because we’re used to it. History gets rewritten all the time, whether it’s a forgotten identity or marriage, a new addition to a twice-told tale or a complete overhaul of an entire shared universe. We’re accustomed to big shake ups and small ones too. Sometimes a new artist comes on board and creates a new dynamic and other times… well, multiple universes get smooshed into one, rewriting five decades of history and rendering the continuity of our entire comic book collection a moot point.
But you already know all this, right? So what’s the point? What’re we getting at? We’re talking about the comic book version of the big screen remake and as we so often do, we’re talking about Jack Kirby. Specifically, The Eternals. We think it’s high time somebody laid a new set of eyes on this concept and revamped the characters for modern day. We’re not talking about another attempt at reintroducing the characters to the Marvel Universe; that never works. This time, we’re talking about starting over from scratch and (hopefully) adhering to Kirby’s original vision just a tad bit closer. We’re talking about setting the characters as far outside the traditional Marvel U as possible – an idea that may actually come to fruition, should the heirs to the Kirby throne win their case against Marvel and gain ownership of the characters. Think we’re crazy? Hear us out…
The Eternals debuted in 1976 and were part of Kirby’s return to Marvel after spending a few years over at DC working on New Gods, Kamandi, OMAC and others. Thematically, it bore more than a few similarities to the stuff he was doing in New Gods, but it had a lot more in common with Erich von Däniken’s Chariots of the Gods?. If you’re unfamiliar with this book (or its sequels), turn on the History Channel at any given time during the week and check out a show called Ancient Aliens. Seriously, the program seems to air 24-7 on the channel. It used to be that the History Channel showed non-stop WWII footage, but these days, they seem to be less focused on Nazis and more dedicated to the possibility of alien contact with primitive civilizations. 
Anyway, Chariots of the Gods? puts forth the idea that humans were visited by aliens in ancient times and were worshipped as gods, which led to some of history’s more unexplainable aspects, such as pyramids, the Nazca lines in Peru, Stonehenge and the Moai of Easter Island. It was a popular theory back in the 1970’s, when shows like In Search Of ruled the airwaves and drugs were a lot more socially acceptable, but the boring scientists of the real world tend to shun these sorts of ideas. We at Comicscape grew up on these types of progams, as well as the work of the comic book masters and late night radio programs like Art Bell’s AM Coast to Coast, so it should come as no surprise that we’re hip to what von Däniken and Kirby were layin’ down. Obviously, a lot of other people are too, because as we previously stated, the History Channel plays that damn Ancient Aliens show all the time! We can’t be the only ones watching it… although, that would be one hell of a conspiracy theory right there.
Anyway, back to comic books and the Eternals. Now, the book wasn’t exactly a smash hit and lasted only a couple of years. This probably has something to do with the fact that while Jack was probably the best idea man who ever worked in the field and one hell of an amazing and influential artist, his skills as a writer weren’t exactly on par with the rest of his genius. The characters, as previously stated, were the super powered (and in some cases, super disfigured) result of alien tampering with ancient earthlings who had returned to cast judgement on the world. After the series was cancelled, the characters were written into Marvel continuity and have seen several attempts at revival, none of which have lasted very long. 
We feel that the main problem with this is that whole Marvel continuity thing. The Eternals were not intended to be a part of the mainstream Marvel U and when bound to the laws of that universe, they just don’t work – not even with Neil Gaiman and John Romita jr. working on the book! Our vision for a new Eternals series? Scrap everything that came before, re-read the original series, figure out what works and what doesn’t and retell the story the way it was (presumably) meant to be told. Only… well, better. Sorry Jack, we love ya but dialogue and narrative weren’t really your strong suit.
How many of you reading this also read superhero comic books? Oh yeah, that would be all of you. How many of you watch Ancient Aliens, or are at least cool to the notions of science fiction and alien visitors? We’re not asking if you actually believe any of that stuff, we’re just asking if it interests you? Don’t lie – we know you like spaceships. Okay, now what if somebody like Jonathan Hickman was writing a comic book, or maybe just a one-shot graphic novel based on that type of stuff? See? You’d read it, wouldn’t you? 
We think a lot of other people would too. But the key is to not be bound by the latest Civil Fear War crossover event or utilizing the characters in an Iron Man team up. It’s gotta be a story for the sake of the story. The ideas come from Kirby, the most fertile mind in comic books: a mind that is still being tapped and looked to for guidance and influence years after his death! The concepts are older than that and speak to humankind’s primal desire to find meaning and discover its origins. And they wear costumes! What part of that doesn’t deserve a re-imagining?
And if you’re not game, we bet the folks at the History Channel will be. It’s about time they started featuring an animated series on their network.


Showing items 1 - 7 of 7
Wiseguy 2/16/2011 5:37:43 AM

Never been a fan of the Eternals, like you said they just don't work well within the Marvel U. They can easily be set-up in an alternate universe but for me I'm just not a fan to be honest. Not that I can't be converted but it would have to be a hell of a story

triggerleo 2/16/2011 9:26:25 AM

Awesome article!

"It’s probably a lot easier for comic book fans to accept remakes, reboots and re-imaginings because we’re used to it."

If I was religious I would say, Amen!

lusiphur 2/16/2011 1:48:11 PM

 "It’s probably a lot easier for comic book fans to accept remakes, reboots and re-imaginings because we’re used to it."

If that were completely true, why all the bitching about comic movies lately?

Good article Chad.  I only have a passing knowledge of the Eternals, having encountered the characters through other books.  But now I'm slightly more interested in them and may track down some older series.

Tashiro 2/16/2011 1:51:14 PM

 Actually, my general complaint is more about the reboots and such for comic books.  I'd really prefer it if comics didn't continually reboot, alter their history, and keep everyone unchanging.  I don't like everything floating around status-quo or backtracking.  It just drives me nuts.

everdreaded 2/17/2011 3:40:54 AM

The Eternals and New Gods have ever been two of my favorite concepts from Kirby. Back in the WAYY BAck day I used to wonder if Kirby was takin drugs and if he did where could i get what he was taking. The man was definitely playing with new ideas in suoerheroes and myth and lord knows where he would have taken these concepts if he was allowed to give the myriad of characters thier due, before Wolverine I was a big ORION fan. And the Eternaals were like one of those mysteries in the Marvel universe you couldnt exactly grasp, hell I even liked STARFOX for a time. The Whole idea of the Omnipotent Celestials and thier manipulation of aspects of mankinds evolution were very intriguing to me.

But honestly thats exactly what the remain...a CONCEPT. In my opinion to this day, nary a writer has produced any kind of stand out story for the Eternals let alone both that matches the interest that I feel alot of fans have for Kirbys characters. I grant its alot to cover, last I checked ther were actually two groups of Eternals, those on Earth and those on Saturns moon Titan I think and the majority of the ones on earth did the Uni Mind and went off SOMEWHERE. I checked out that mini series a while back and though interesting, it basically yanked the great awe and wonder out of the characters.

In this day with Marvel trying to blow up characters, I would love to think that there is a mind out there who could be able to flesh the Eternals out and make them a solid stand out. They were the ASGARDIANS on earth before the ASGARDIANS came to earth in the Thor series and Im more accepting of that than of the golden realm being in NEBRASKA( I still laugh at that)

But bottom line Its a concept that would involve alot of rebooting and remaking that probably would further confuse old and new readers alike as to thier status. all the more is the pity.

karas1 2/18/2011 8:22:33 AM

Actually, whenever I turn to the History Channel an episode of Pawn Stars (or another series about people who find and restore antiques) is on.  Or Ax Men (or Ice Road Truckers).  What I DON'T see is anything about history.


I've never really been a big fan of Kirby's work.  I think his characters look silly.

zipahead 6/27/2011 1:13:23 PM

It'll happen...with the success of Thor , Captain America and The Avengers...somebody will do the math and figure out the common denominator... The King... I think they should do it in that Bruce Timm style with some faux Kirby.... get Steve Rude.



You must be logged in to leave a comment. Please click here to login.