Comic Review


FANTASTIC FOUR #554

By: Kurt Amacker, Columnist
Review Date: Sunday, February 17, 2008

Mark Millar begins his run on Fantastic Four with a pitch-perfect, if somewhat decompressed, introduction. It opens with the team on a time-travel vacation gone horribly awry, with Ben Grimm somehow left in – and then rescued from – the year 1682. And, as it should be, the team returns home to one of Johnny Storm’s quips and life as usual. The appeal of the Fantastic Four has always been their propensity for high-energy science-fiction adventure with hardly a second thought. You expect this family to talk about time travel over breakfast. Millar nails that tone right off the bat, and shows a thoroughly versed understanding of each character. Reed and Ben Grimm visit an elementary school classroom, where the former bores the class with a physics lecture. Grimm finally breaks down and asks the kids if they want to play in the Fantasticar instead. Sue’s busy trying to start an all-women team with She-Hulk and the Wasp – one that effectively serves as charitable organization rather than a vigilante or paramilitary group. And, Millar finally gives us the kicker when an old girlfriend of Reed’s, Alyssa Castle, arrives. Much to Sue’s chagrin, Castle takes Mr. Fantastic to the headquarters of the Earth-Trust, where she and her husband work on a project that could have staggering implications for the planet.

This 554th issue of Fantastic Four runs so contrary to the tone of Millar’s own Civil War that one can’t help but wonder how much input he had on that miniseries. While this issue takes its time getting to the Earth-Trust project, Millar clearly enjoys playing in the team’s world, even if it only serves to establish his run’s tone. If anything, this issue highlights a significant shortcoming of monthly comics – though the story arc may work well in its entirety, individual issues may feel incomplete. In a way, it’s almost unfair to grade individual issues. Hence, while this 554th installment of Fantastic Four wants for more plot, it portends good things for the rest of Millar’s run. 

Bryan Hitch brings a more subdued flavor than his work on The Ultimates, though not an unwelcome one. With less flash and sharp edges to his work, it further enhances the lighter, friendlier tone of this series than his other work with Millar.

This is a really fun issue. Not a lot happens initially, but it sets the stage for something really cool. Pick this one up.

Questions? Comments? Let us know what you think at comicscape@mania.com.



More Content By Kurt Amacker, Columnist
Good-Bye, American Virgin
(Wednesday, February 20, 2008)
FANTASTIC FOUR #554
(Sunday, February 17, 2008)
X-FORCE #1
(Sunday, February 17, 2008)
SCUD THE DISPOSABLE ASSASSIN #21
(Friday, February 15, 2008)
Uncanny X-Men #495
(Thursday, February 14, 2008)
Comics After Katrina II: Tedd Walley and Mathilda
(Wednesday, February 13, 2008)
Alas, Poor Yorick
(Wednesday, February 6, 2008)
Death Dealer #6
(Saturday, February 2, 2008)
The Punisher #54
(Friday, February 1, 2008)
Rise Up and Hear the Bells: The Return of Captain America
(Wednesday, January 30, 2008)
Comments/Responses
1
muchdrama • Feb 17, 2008, 02:20pm •
The only thing Mark Millar and Bryan Hitch do for me on Fantastic Four is make me long for Mike Wieringo, Karl Kesel, and Mark Waid.

lister • Feb 18, 2008, 09:08am •
A "B+"? Were we reading different books? I thought this was really bad. From the hokey time travel with Ben in costume to the ridiculous idea that Mr. F is "hot". And from Johnny's "cameo" appearance to the arrival of... whatever that was at the end.

Yes, the FF has done time travel before. But here it's kind of contrived. I'd rather see them actually in the time travel mission that this. I was enjoying the book more with Black Panther and Storm on the team! That had a sense of wonder to it. This? This was too much soap. Not enough opera.

bernini • Feb 19, 2008, 08:36am •
I'm with Kurt on this. I really enjoyed it. I left the mainstream Marvel U years ago, and I haven't picked up an issue of the FF since Byrne's run. I'll admit that my primary draw was curiosity regarding what kind of feel Millar and Hitch would bring to the book. I'll admit to being very pleasantly surprised. I read somewhere that before Millar started his run on UFF, he got the best advice on how to write the FF from Stan Lee himself: essentially, there's nothing too big or too out there for the FF. And bammo, if Millar doesn't take that to heart here in the mainstream Marvel U.

I was curious to see how Hitch's exacting naturalistic style would play here. It's a nice look. While I think the Hitch uniforms are a bit too "Ultimates," (that's an editorial observation - blurs the line too much between the two properties), I very much enjoy the full range of expression with which he renders his characters. And I agree with Millar, the Baxter Building just looks cool. I appreciate the set pieces that Hitch labors to communicate, giving us a sense of place and comfort. For a book about a family, it's nice to feel like there's a "living room" in which these people relax and live.

Well done all the way around. I look forward to what's next.

1
Login to post a comment!