PDA

View Full Version : Word In Stone-Review of Babylon 5 The Lost Tales


tstone
08-15-2007, 10:27 AM
Like Harry Potter, this was a unique tale, introducing a unique world with a definite mission, storytelling-wise. J Michael Strakzinsky wanted to tell a tale of empires, power, passion, morality, spirituality, philosophy and events, expressed through the lives of individuals who would arrive, grow, change, move on and, sooner or later, die. It would be how these events affected them and how they affected these events. And it would revolve around a unique place, known by travellers and inhabitants as Babylon 5.

Babylon 5, or B5, is a space station, built by the Earth Alliance and jointly funded by the Minbari, a race previously fought a catastrophic war with, with the intention of avoiding another such conflict. It was a noble effort, and like most noble efforts, especially ones of similar ambitions, it was not without complications, stumbles and questions of purpose.

At any rate, the original tale of B5 was a complete one of a specific set of moments in time. But, as JMS tells in an interview, the universe didn't start there. And it didn't end there. The universe and characters came from time before, and things moved on. Lots of fans have been asking, ok, where did it come from and where did it move on to?

JMS wants to explore some of those threads, string them out to see where they go. He also wants to explore a new approach to high quality direct to DVD releases, which this was the first.

Two main stories are on this disc. The first, which other reviews I've read unfortunately didn't favor as much (most liked it, just not as much as the other tale on this disc), peered into Babylon 5, post establishment of the Interstellar Alliance. Elizabeth Lochley has been promoted to Colonel and is still in command of Babylon 5. A strange man has come into her purview, a man apparently posessed by...a demon. Now, the scenario has been done before, but JMS has a bit of an appreciation for horror. He showed that in some previous B5 stories, most notably Thirdspace, with it's salute to HP Lovecraft. This one was a nod to The Exorcist, but with a twist.

Personally, I was a big fan of this story, as it did yet again one of the things JMS does well, that is, exploring the metaphysical underpinnings of the B5 universe, and as an extent, our own. If your thoughts meander over in this territory, as mine do, you'll like it.

The second tale featured Bruce Boxleitner returning as John Sheridan, now President of the ISA. He's on a tour to Babylon 5 and is visited by the mysterious Technomage, Galen. He is warned of an unfortunate event that may take place in Earth's future and he may be able to prevent it. But the course of action Galen suggests runs counter to Sheridan's sense of morality.

What will he do?

Great return to the B5 universe, and a great intro to what may come. And excellent salutes in both the stories and the extras to G'Kar (Andreas Katsulas) and Dr. Steven Franklin (Richard Biggs).

B5 fans? Must have. The uninitiated? Really, best you watch the series first. You'll be able to appreciate it much better.

barqs
08-21-2007, 06:33 PM
Like Harry Potter, this was a unique tale, introducing a unique world with a definite mission, storytelling-wise. J Michael Strakzinsky wanted to tell a tale of empires, power, passion, morality, spirituality, philosophy and events, expressed through the lives of individuals who would arrive, grow, change, move on and, sooner or later, die. It would be how these events affected them and how they affected these events. And it would revolve around a unique place, known by travellers and inhabitants as Babylon 5.

Babylon 5, or B5, is a space station, built by the Earth Alliance and jointly funded by the Minbari, a race previously fought a catastrophic war with, with the intention of avoiding another such conflict. It was a noble effort, and like most noble efforts, especially ones of similar ambitions, it was not without complications, stumbles and questions of purpose.

At any rate, the original tale of B5 was a complete one of a specific set of moments in time. But, as JMS tells in an interview, the universe didn't start there. And it didn't end there. The universe and characters came from time before, and things moved on. Lots of fans have been asking, ok, where did it come from and where did it move on to?

JMS wants to explore some of those threads, string them out to see where they go. He also wants to explore a new approach to high quality direct to DVD releases, which this was the first.

Two main stories are on this disc. The first, which other reviews I've read unfortunately didn't favor as much (most liked it, just not as much as the other tale on this disc), peered into Babylon 5, post establishment of the Interstellar Alliance. Elizabeth Lochley has been promoted to Colonel and is still in command of Babylon 5. A strange man has come into her purview, a man apparently posessed by...a demon. Now, the scenario has been done before, but JMS has a bit of an appreciation for horror. He showed that in some previous B5 stories, most notably Thirdspace, with it's salute to HP Lovecraft. This one was a nod to The Exorcist, but with a twist.

Personally, I was a big fan of this story, as it did yet again one of the things JMS does well, that is, exploring the metaphysical underpinnings of the B5 universe, and as an extent, our own. If your thoughts meander over in this territory, as mine do, you'll like it.

The second tale featured Bruce Boxleitner returning as John Sheridan, now President of the ISA. He's on a tour to Babylon 5 and is visited by the mysterious Technomage, Galen. He is warned of an unfortunate event that may take place in Earth's future and he may be able to prevent it. But the course of action Galen suggests runs counter to Sheridan's sense of morality.

What will he do?

Great return to the B5 universe, and a great intro to what may come. And excellent salutes in both the stories and the extras to G'Kar (Andreas Katsulas) and Dr. Steven Franklin (Richard Biggs).

B5 fans? Must have. The uninitiated? Really, best you watch the series first. You'll be able to appreciate it much better.

Actually I really enjoyed both...but they looked....understated.....I guess because they had such a small budget. I love the fact that everything looked the same only in better detail. I'm hoping that this does well enough that they can do more and with bigger grandiose stories and cast.

tstone
08-22-2007, 04:41 AM
Agreed on all counts.

Johnzilla
09-17-2007, 07:16 AM
I continue to wonder what JMS could do with a "Trek" budget. Although it was great to see the B5 Universe again, the DVD was lacking in several areas.
Call me greedy, but I couldn't help but wonder how much better the DVD would of been if Garibaldi, Ivanova, Londo & Vir were in it. Heck, I would love to see a Sinclair & Garibaldi story.

It just amazes me that JMS can't get the right amount of financial backing for B5. I've always felt that the story, writing & art direction of B5 was much better then Trek's.

Strider
09-17-2007, 08:24 AM
I totally forgot to post in here after I watched this. I liked both stories, although I liked the Sheridan one a bit more. That's probably because I like his character better than Lochley. To me, this felt like a really good intro to a larger story, kind of like a pilot. The stories were good, but I was almost more interested in what would happen next, like with Sheridan and the Centauri prince.

The extras on the disc were a bit on the light side, but they were done very well. I was amused during the section on special effects when I saw they were using Lightwave. That's the program I stare at day in and day out, so it was amusing to be able to recognize it just by seeing the UI. :D

Johnzilla
09-17-2007, 09:59 AM
Do you use that program at work or school? A few years ago I bought NewTek Aura2 Video Paint System. I hope to upgrade in the near future.

Strider
09-17-2007, 12:59 PM
I use it at work.

Johnzilla
10-26-2007, 09:10 AM
Any news or rumors about the next B5 DVD?
I would love to see a Garibaldi story. Better yet, a Garibaldi/Sinclair/Ivanova story.

I can dream can't I?

tstone
02-03-2008, 11:01 PM
The Hubbub is that the next Lost Tales will include Garibaldi and Londo stories. We shall see...

Johnzilla
02-04-2008, 06:55 AM
The Hubbub is that the next Lost Tales will include Garibaldi and Londo stories. We shall see...

Is that just a wishful rumor or did JMS or JD say something about it?

tstone
02-04-2008, 08:59 PM
Jms.