Frankencastle: Rebuilding THE PUNISHER -


22 Comments | Add


Rate & Share:


Related Links:



  • Series:

Frankencastle: Rebuilding THE PUNISHER

Frank Castle done right by Remender and Moore!

By Chad Derdowski     January 13, 2010

Comicscape: Frankencastle: Rebuilding THE PUNISHER
© Mania

Ever since he was appointed head of H.A.M.M.E.R., there aren’t many places in the Marvel Universe where the long arm of Norman Osborn’s law doesn’t reach. That grasp finally extended all the way to Frank Castle a few months ago when Daken caught up with The Punisher and cut him to pieces. What we’ve seen since then has been, in the opinion of Comicscape, one of the most brilliant reinterpretations of a comic book character that we’ve ever seen. Resurrected as a shambling monstrosity, the Punisher was reborn as Frankencastle.

Why It’s So Hot

It’s hot because of Rick Remender and Tony Moore, two creators with solid track records of awesomeness whether working together or apart. If XXXombies, The End League, Doctor Voodoo and The Last Days of American Crime don’t ring any bells, it’s time to get yourself to a comic shop. As for Tony Moore, perhaps you’re familiar with his recent work on Ghost Rider with Jason Aaron, The Exterminators, Brit and an incredibly unpopular book that nobody reads called The Walking Dead (the first six issues, anyway). Put these guys together and you get… well, you get Fear Agent. Mixing sci-fi with westerns, horror and war comics, Fear Agent reads like a love letter to EC Comics. It’s that same genre blending flavor that is making the current Punisher arc such a blast to read.

No, It’s Not Like The Last Time The Punisher Came Back From The Dead

He was huge in the 1980’s, but by the end of the ‘90s, The Punisher had pretty much run his course. He’d become oversaturated and boring. So Marvel killed him off and brought him back in a 4-issue mini-series which depicted Frank as a supernatural avenger. It was declared sacrilege by longtime Punisher fans and has been largely forgotten since Garth Ennis and Steve Dillon breathed new life into the character with their 2000 series. It’s also been forgotten because it was stupid.

But… isn’t this the same thing? The avenger of the downtrodden, waging a one-man war on crime, killed in battle only to come back as a monster… on paper it sounds pretty similar but the big difference here is intention. While The Punisher: Purgatory was done as a serious reinterpretation of the character, Frankencastle has its tongue planted firmly in its cheek. That’s not to say that the series hasn’t had some pretty heavy emotional moments, but it has also got a healthy sense of humor, as evidenced by the relationship between Jack Russell and Morbius as well as the sheer absurdity of the whole situation. Moore’s artwork is perfect for the story as it balances whimsy and wackiness with expressive faces and incredibly informative body language.

The Inspiration

Speaking of Tony Moore’s artwork, let’s talk about the influences, as they play a pretty big part in this story. Moore has said that his work with Rick Remender on Fear Agent wears its influences on its sleeve and if you’re familiar with guys like Jack Davis, Wally Wood, John Severin and Harvey Kurtzman or comic books like Two-Fisted Tales and Weird Science, you know what we mean. If you’re not familiar with these names, do yourself a favor and educate yourself. If you’ve never trusted Comicscape before, you can trust us on this one. You won’t be sorry – we promise. These are foundation-laying comic creators whose influence is still being felt throughout the industry, especially in the current run on The Punisher.

Inspired by these legends of sequential art and classic storytelling styles, Remender and Moore have taken a character that many readers have regarded as one-dimensional and bland and … man, they’ve really F*@%-ed him up, haven’t they? It’s almost like putting Charles Bronson’s character from Death Wish in the middle of Evil Dead II or using Monster Mash as the soundtrack for Dirty Harry. Add in a team of high-tech Japanese monster hunters who have forced the 1970’s Marvel monsters into a terror-stricken existence in the sewers under New York and you’ve got a comic unlike any other on the market.

It’s Not Like the Precedent Hadn’t Already Been Set

Boy howdy, we hate to give press to other websites, but the super-awesome Chris Sims over at Comics Alliance wrote a glowing review of Punisher #11, which kicked off the Frankencastle arc, and got some feedback from a reader who didn’t see the appeal of this concept being used in the “core Marvel Universe”. Chris’ response was to point out that the “core Marvel universe” features men with purses in goblin costumes riding on flying pieces of sheet metal as well as a 120-year-old Canadian berserker samurai who has been to the moon and fallen in love with a psychic. We won’t bother to rehash some of his other statements, but we encourage you to check them out because they’re damn funny.

The point is that in a world populated by monsters, radioactive split-personalities, thunder gods turned into frogs and people with names like Victor Von Doom, the idea of Frank Castle being killed and turned into a Frankenstein monster isn’t really all that absurd. It’s fun – get over it. And if you don’t like it, you’ve always got Punisher Max.

You Can Have Your Cake And Eat It Too

Yeah, we just said that at the end of the previous paragraph. If you want nasty, prison-rapey stories featuring eyeballs getting carved out of skulls and hanging by thin, bloody tendons, you’ve got Punisher Max. It’s a really awesome book and we highly recommend you check it out in addition to the regular Punisher series. In the world of comic books, both concepts are equally viable and equally awesome.

You Either Get it or you Don’t

That’s pretty much what it boils down to. You either recognize the influences and the style and you’re on board and having fun with it or you’re reading this as fast as you can so you can get to the part where you get to leave a comment about how you’ll “just have to wait until this arc has wrapped up.” You might even be one of those folks who feel that Remender and Moore have irrevocably ruined The Punisher in such a way that Frank Castle can never recover. And in that case, we’re going to assume you’ve only been reading comics for like, a year or two and we’re not paying attention anyway.

As we bring this week’s edition of Comicscape to a close, we sit astride a magnificently stoned thoroughbred perched atop a box of Ivory soap and remind you that while taste is subjective and there are no right or wrong opinions. That said, we’d like you to know that if you are in the camp of “don’t get it” … well, you’re wrong and we’re right. Frankencastle kicks ass!


Showing items 1 - 10 of 22
1 2 3 >  >>  
jedibanner 1/13/2010 6:11:41 AM

I have to admit, reading the Darg Reign The List: Punisher, I did not expect Frank Castle to be cut into pieces and die like that. It was an awsome book and fun to read...then came the next issue.

It felt weird for one reason and one reason only: Garth Ennis. In my mind, he wrote what is the perfect definition of what the Punisher should be (in a MAX series was also a stroke of genious). Therefore, I always considered the 616 Punisher a ''lesser'' version of the character so once I read the List: Punisher, I felt's a cool read but, he'll be back or , it's a decoy or something...and then looking at the Frankencastle thingy...not fully my thing.

It's original, doesn't feel like a Punisher book but, it is true fantasy in comic book is a given and we should never take anything for granted.

I know I will stick with Punisher Max but, this thing might peek some interest in the future.

lister 1/13/2010 9:25:57 AM

I am repeating myself here, but I always hated the Punisher until this last series. I never connected with him, but I tried (like collecting War Journal back in the 80's from the start and stuff... well, for a few issues anyway).

But this series was different. It made me really like the Punisher and, most amazing of all, the Red Hood (still not real hot on that villain, but whatever).

However, this Frankencastle story line is one of the absolute worst things I have ever read. And I hate the art (actually, I like this artist's style but I think it's woefully inappropraite for this book and this plot). Hate how they are using Morbius and Werewolf.

It might be an original idea, but I think it sucks so hard that it has made me dislike the Punisher again. Now I could take him or leave him. They really wasted their goodwill with me! Nice that others are enjoying it tho...

HunterRose 1/13/2010 10:07:19 AM

The first time my friend told me about the whole Frankencastle story I burst out laughing. Really Marvel? It comes down to this? Let me guess....3.99? Maybe I should read it before passing judgement, but I just can't get past the Frankenstien concept. Sounds like Marvel is throwing poop on the wall to see what sticks.

agentkooper 1/13/2010 11:24:29 AM

Because I've alwas been man enough to tell others when they are wrong, I think I should also be willing to admit when I am. 

Chad, despite your tastes (didn't you like G.I. Joe?) I took your advice and read this book.  I dig it.  What can I say?  Oh, sick day with my daughter and we just started G.I. Joe.  I'll let you know what I think.

lister 1/13/2010 11:49:30 AM

He liked G.I. Joe? Get! (Elaine push) Out!

Matador 1/13/2010 1:26:20 PM

Every where I read this seems to have an ad for November 2009. What gives?

lister 1/13/2010 1:35:31 PM


Well, the first issue of the Frankencastle arc came out in November 2009 (or thereabouts). They are three issues in now (I think). Is that what you meant?

SONYMANswallows 1/13/2010 2:52:29 PM

Why not call him RoboCastle ? That's what this is influenced by or Universal Soldier.

Punisher is a human being that kills. Punisher is not Deathlok or Cyborg. 

Is Frankencastle going to marry Mary Jane Watson?

ChadDerdowski 1/13/2010 4:02:16 PM

Okay... G.I. Joe.  Here's the thing - it was hands down one of the worst movies I have ever seen.

But did I enjoy it?  Oh hell yeah.  I had to view it with my "Lone Wolf McQuade eyes" ... it was so bad it actually reversed the polarity of good taste and common sense and became good again!  Mindless fun with zero plot and even less believability.  Terrible acting all around (with the exception of Joseph Gordon-Levitt, who clearly enjoyed himself in the role of Cobra Commander).  It never took itself seriously and didn't ask us to either.  It never pretended to be something it wasn't (Transformers, I'm looking at you) and it was simply a big, dumb cartoon with real people.  The 10-year-old in me had a blast and ... hey guys, G.I. Joe is for kids, not adults.

Now, would I recommend it to anyone?  Only if you like MST3K, my friends.

As for Tony Moore's art being woefully inappropriate, I couldn't disagree more.  It's a fun book with a good sense of humor mixed in with the pathos of the old James Whale Frankenstein movies.  Moore is working with a much more whimsical style on this title - and can you honestly tell me the scenes in the last issue with the little subterannean kid didn't at least mildly tug at your heartstrings?  

Obviously we can't all like the same things, but I honestly can't even comprehend where you're coming from, Lister.  Please elaborate - we're not on the same page here and I'm curious as to just how you're viewing this.  You mentioned your dislike of the art when I reviewed the first issue of the arc (which was in November, Matador) ...  you do understand that the book is supposed to be humorous, right?  Is it simply that you want it to be a more serious story?  

I do understand your dislike of the "Butch and Sundance" relationship between Morbius and Werewolf... personally, I've never had a strong attachment to either, so that's probably why I'm more willing to let it slide.

lister 1/13/2010 4:24:16 PM

Oh, I get the humor and the classic monster lineup and the funny, funny FrankenCastle haha name and the kiddie art and all that. And it's all incredibly unappealing to me. Everything seems gratuitous, including the art. This pathos you mentioned seems tacked on, unearned. And again, I really like this Moore guy's artistic style, but I think it's better suited to Runaways or something.

Hate the subterranean gang plot, seen it, done it, watched Marvel Massacre it back in the 80's. I just don't care about any of this because I know this is not going to be the status quo. It's like a dream episode of your favorite TV show. It doesn't count.

My main problems with Morbius and Werewolf were the sudden change of storyline for them after all that zombie nonsense. It seemed like they were going to go off and do something with that, but then the characters got Shanghaiied so we could have the Monster Club (which is a fun idea when done right). The only thing worse was the sudden shift from the previous arc to this one (which we know cannot last, so I'm kinda like why bother).

And no, the little dude did not make me cry. I'm not that gay!  :)

Does that give you more insight into what I am finding so off-putting here? In a nutshell, I hate going off on this entire plot tangent when there was a completely compelling plotline already in progress that we will finally get back to when this (IMNSHOSFO) indulgent, unfunny and ugly crap finally ends. Spinning my wheels until then...

1 2 3 >  >>  


You must be logged in to leave a comment. Please click here to login.