Fringe: A New Day in Old Town Review - Mania.com



TV Review

Mania Grade: A

12 Comments | Add

 

Rate & Share:

 

Related Links:

 

Info:

  • TV Series: Fringe
  • Episode: A New Day in Old Town
  • Starring: Colin Ana Torv, Lance Reddick, John Noble, Joshua Jackson, Kirk Acevedo
  • Written By: Akiva Goldsman, J.J. Abrams
  • Directed By: Akiva Goldsman
  • Network: Fox
  • Series: Fringe

Fringe: A New Day in Old Town Review

Crisis on Infinite Earths

By Stephen Lackey     September 18, 2009


Fringe Review(2009).
© Fox/Bob Trate

 

So last season ended with Olivia, or “Olive” as many fans now like to affectionately refer to to her as, standing in front of the mysterious William Bell (Leonard Nimoy) in one of the two towers of the World Trade Center. Using the World Trade Center evokes a certain emotional response but it also quickly defines that Olivia is definitely not in Kansas anymore. She did make a trip to an alternate version of Earth where Bell has apparently decided to stay. The tease was that Olivia would finally get some answers and of course we’d see at least some of those answers in this episode. Well, some of the folks behind LOST are responsible for this show so we should know better. It appears that this conversation between Bell and Olivia is going to be trickled out to us slowly for quite some time.
 
When the episode started with the mysterious man in the car with a bloody head, the episode appeared to be a monster of the week situation. That would have been incredibly disappointing after last season’s finale. As the show progressed, it quickly became more clear that he in fact is involved with a shady group and has been tasked with keeping any information Olivia learned from Bell from getting out there. He is a shape shifter and he has quite the disturbing way of changing shapes throughout this episode. Walter and Peter arrive on the scene of the accident to meet a spunky FBI agent in charge of dealing with the now empty car that at one time belonged to Olivia. This leads to a shocker of a scene that brings Olivia back to our world. Walter is responsible but no one bothers to ask him how he knew what to do.
 
Olivia is hurt and in the hospital so she is out of commission for most of this episode. Anytime Olivia isn’t in the middle of the action, it’s a loss to this show. She brings a really unique and surprisingly melancholy kind of energy to the proceedings, even when she’s in a good mood or smiling. It says a lot about the acting abilities of Ana Torv because she doesn’t seem to be that sort of person at all outside of the role. Walter picks up the slack though by bringing boatloads of his weirdness to the episode. Peter’s birthday is coming up and Walter is insisting on making a pudding to celebrate. There's one scene in particular that’s a little gross and a lot funny where Walter is doing an autopsy while giving instructions to Astrid on how to make the pudding. She walks over to look at the body while mixing ingredients in a bowl and none of them think it’s the slightest bit odd. It’s not slapstick funny but it still brings a smile to the face of any fan of the show.
 
It’s barely a complaint that Olivia isn’t in the field because the payoff is so fantastic. Upon her return from the other side, many new plot threads are set up, some small and some major. Olivia’s first words when she returns appear creepy and monumental but in the end they have a much more subtle connection to the investigation and to the investigators. The most powerful shows lead you to believe that no one on those shows is safe no matter how major the character’s role may be. To make you believe that they have to knock off someone important on occasion. The stinger ending of this episode brings it all home in a really unexpected way. This is Fringe though so anyone who’s dead may still find a way back. The season premiere set up more mysteries but it didn’t bring back the “pattern” which is something that needs to be done. Last season, the show strayed a bit from the pattern into Fringe terrorism and it never really made its way back. The pattern element was one of the most interesting elements of the show in the early episodes of season one so hopefully all of this will get tied together properly this season when more is revealed about William Bell and the mysterious conversation he had with Olivia.

COMMENTS AND RESPONSES

Showing items 1 - 10 of 12
1 2 >  >>  
Chopsaki 9/18/2009 12:42:25 PM

No need to bloviate, this episode was fuucking sweet. So sweet I had to spell fuucking with 2 U's, thats pretty sweet.

MrJawbreakingEquilibrium 9/18/2009 2:25:46 PM

We can't cuss anymore here?  That's bullcrap.  And it erased my whole message instead of letting me edit it.  Come on now, guys, this site is getting worse and worse.  I mean, still no edit button?  Now let's see if I can remember what I put.

SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS

SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS

This episode had one of the best, if not the best, openers I've ever seen.  I mean that was sweet and curious at the same time.  I read one guy post something elsewhere about Olivia getting into a car accident and nothing happened to her and he always thought that was curious and he thinks this part explains that.  I don't remember what he's talking about.  Does anybody else?  All I know is that the last time we saw Olivia she was with Bell in the Towers.

The one tiny gripe I have but I think I can sort of rationalize away is the fact the shapeshifter seemed to take out Charlie, shift, and bring the nurse back down and dress her awflly quickly.  But I chalk that up the nurse being brought down there from the very beginning - she seemed to be smoking near there anyway - and that the shifter being a soldier can dress and undress very quickly.  I mean when I was in the Army you should see how quickly we got into our MOPP suits (biological suits sort of).  Hell, I had to change back in forth from PTs to BDUs pretty quickly to, almost ninja like.

One more thing I thought was grosser than making custard during the autopsy.  Wasn't Walter eating a Twizzler during the whole thing and holding it in his bloody gloves as well.

thorin02 9/18/2009 2:29:39 PM

Of course none of the questions were answered.  This is Abrams, King of the McGuffins.  Enjoy the ride but don't actually expect anything remotely resembly answers. 

Chopsaki 9/18/2009 4:06:25 PM

thorin02 How many questions did the X-Files ever answer? I understand wanting to know whats going on but you can't exactly shoot your load on the first episode of season 2. Patience my young padawan...

ponyboy76 9/18/2009 4:11:43 PM

Why does everything have to be answered? I mean, it is only the second season. I don't mind waiting awhile get answers as long as the ride is good and so far the ride has been fuucking awesome. Did anyone else notice that the X-Files was playing on that guys TV in the beginning? Thought that was cool. And strangely that senator mentioned a division that was designated "X" at the hearing.
Its also great about what Peter said about how they are going to be more proactive instead of waiting for something to happen.

 

SPOLIER-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

I am pretty upset that they killed Charlie off but we all knew it was going to happen, if you keep up with Aussiellio. Luke Goss was cool as the soldier. And I was sure about Agent Jessop in the beginning of the episode but she quickly grew on me. I guess she's going to be Olivia's new partner.

Walter is totally bizzare and I love it. The twizzler thing was nasty.

Chopsaki 9/18/2009 4:28:19 PM

Don't count Charlie out just yet, there is an alternate universe afterall. :)

MrJawbreakingEquilibrium 9/18/2009 5:13:24 PM

Didn't he say they wrote him off.  I think the first few episodes are his last unless that whole internet thing or Facebook thing was a red herring where he said, "They fired me from Fringe, yo."

Chopsaki 9/18/2009 5:54:48 PM

Well technically he wasn't fired they just didn't renew his option. Though now that I think about it they did throw him in the furnace so I guess technically he was "FIRED" hah good one. It's clearly a money issue as they also moved the production to Vancouver because it's cheaper. We still have evil Charlie for as long as this storyline plays out and my comment still stand, they can always bring him back at some point with my alternate reality sugestion. I can hold out hope anyways. :)

ponyboy76 9/19/2009 4:19:27 AM

Well, from what I read, the whole facebook thing was in part a joke as far as the choice of words he used "fired". He is going to be on Fringe about as much or even more than he was last season. He just won't really be playing Charlie. They actually played that really well, because the shapeshifter can no longer shift because they device is broken, so he 's pretty much stuck looking like Charlie for who knows how long. Could be the whole season for all we know.

Hobbs 9/20/2009 7:43:25 PM

This was a great episode and you can see "Lost" elements in it.  That's a huge compliment.  My wife watched it for the first time with me and was instantly hooked by way it started out with Olive crashing through the car window.  Plus when the shape shifter was jumping out the window and doing the Bruce Lee thing...that was a damn good special effect for a TV show.  If they keep this up I see the popularity of this show sky rocketing.

1 2 >  >>  

ADD A COMMENT

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Please click here to login.

POPULAR TOPICS