Game of Thrones: The Old Gods And The New Review Comments - Mania.com



COMMENTS AND RESPONSES

Showing items 1 - 10 of 14
1 2 >  >>  
isgrimner 5/7/2012 7:42:18 AM

A pretty good episode, and I expect the rest of the season to all be well reviewed as I am pretty sure we will have a lot going on each episode.  This was probably one of my favorites so far. 

The book series got a shout out on 30 Rock when they showed Grizz reading a boook and all of a sudden exclaim "Ned Stark's dead", though I'm paraphrasing there.    It just cemented that the show is popular enough to become a part of pop culture used in other shows.

 

Now its time for some book SPOILERS which will include spoilers for the entire series.

So there was a lot of divergence going on in this episode.  Starting at Winterfell, we still have no Reeds or Walders.  The Walders are probably not important but I would have thought the Reeds to be very important for the role they play in getting Bran to Bloodraven.   I also think they missed a major moment in showing us that Bran & Rickon escaping with Osha.  I remember reading the book and not being sure if Theon and Reek actually killed them or not.  I had to cheat and look for more Bran chapters at that point.

Ygritte is much better looking than described in the books, that was another point that seems like they are going away from the books if I recall correctly.   I think they should have played this one closer to the books and involved Rattleshirt and Jon having to kill Quorin.  They also didn't have Jon kill Ygritte's husband, in fact he didn't kill anybody in the melee. 

Dany's dragon's getting taken kind of makes me expect they won't have Dany doing her "spirit walk"  which kind of sucks cause I wanted to see the visions she saw in the rooms, especially of Reagar. 

Having Littlefinger go to Harrenhal was totally unexpected too.  I was pretty sure they wouldn't have him notice Arya, but  who knows what they'll change.  I'm thinking they may not have Harenhal changing hands as much as it did in the books. 

ddiaz28 5/7/2012 11:51:34 AM

Great episode and definitely lots of changes from the books but I think they all worked to make things more intense.  I was a little bummed right off the bat that we didn't actuallly get to see Theon and Co. climbing the walls of Winterfell and seizing control of it.  I was looking forward to that.  We only got the aftermath.  But that was done perfectly and really showed Theon still struggling with his mixed emotions and loyalty.  It was great to hear that Reek will eventually make an appearance since his father told Rob he would send his son to take back Winterfell.  And Theon killing Rodrick definitely gives us a reason to want bad things to happen to him in the future. 

It was great to see The Hound finally get some screen time with Sansa.  Arya's scenes with Tywin were great and it was fun seeing her have to "waste" a name with Jaqen.  I also loved Ygritte.  The actress really played her perfectly.  I can't wait to see more or her and Jon.

Book spoilers ahead although I am extremely vague about them

isgrimmer, I think the stuff with Quorin will still happen, just not in the same order as the books.  I think Jon will eventually find his men again.  The events with him help cement his place with you know who so I think that is too important for the writers to leave out.

I also konw for sure we'll see the "spirit walk" since the dragons were obivously taken to The House of the Undying.  This actually works better because now Danarys has more reason to do what she will eventually do there.

I'm not sure why the Reeds weren't introduced but the most definitely will have to come into play.  They'll probably meet them in the forest at some point.  And you are right about them missing a chance to make us think the boys were dead.  They should have had Bolton tell Rob and Catelyn they were dead and show the heads Theon had.  Then reveal their escape at the end.  Would have added a bit of tension.

jdiggitty 5/7/2012 3:55:49 PM

 Spoiler, spoilers, entire series. 

 

I have a suspicion the Reeds are getting replaced with Osha and Rickon. 

zalder 5/7/2012 7:15:57 PM

I hope not jdiggitty that is almost as bad as what they are doing with Arya...I mean really in this situation she would be recognized and taken back to the capital and she would use a name on pop lanister.  Stll the first major mistake they have made to my mind so I'll let it slide I suppose.

jdiggitty 5/7/2012 7:41:08 PM

 Now that I think about it more, the need the Reeds. 

 

BIG SPOILER!!!

 

So that Howland Reed can confirm R L=J in the next book.

(That's Rhaegar plus Lyanna equals Jon Snow for those who haven't read the books)

MrJawbreakingEquilibrium 5/7/2012 9:58:59 PM

It'd be awesome if when people printer SPOILERS they'd say up to when.

ripum853 5/8/2012 7:09:56 AM

Kinda spoiler, kinda spoiler.

 

 

I'm loving the changes to Arya's storyling myself; as it's creating a lot of great scenes with Her and Tywin.  Her arc is my favorite of the second book too, so I'm a little surprised that I'm taking her changes so well.  I would say that the changes in Jon Snow's storyline has me worried the most, and yes, the lack of Reeds or "Reek" for Bran/Theon's arcs; but I understand a lot of the changes, and even like most of them.  Dany's arc needed more excitement as well, so this kidnapping of the dragons doesn't bother me neither.

 

 

ddiaz28 5/8/2012 9:17:07 AM

ripum, it's true that Reek should have shown up already but we know Bolton told Rob that he's sending his son to take back Winterfell.  So we'll definitely be seeing him.

jdiggity, I definitely don't think those characters will be replaced by Osha and Rickon.  They are too important to Bran's story for more reasons than just the possibility you mentioned.

MrJawbreaking ... I think you can just assume that everything after the spoiler warning in a post may contain spoilers.  Personally, if I write anything unspoilerish after the spoiler section, I write end of spoilers before it.

isgrimner 5/8/2012 11:17:34 AM

kind of spoilerish, but nothing really specific

I think the missing siblings we're talking about could show up next season.  Maybe they just don't want to cast actors yet for small roles.   They can cast them for later and then just move some of their early dialogue to when they are more central to the story.  I think that could be one reason we aren't seeing a lot of characters we're expcting to see right now.  

You could even look how they handled Quarth so far and the one lady/priestess whose name I am blanking on right now, Pyatt Pree, maybe?  They put her in that wierd mask so that they don't have to cast a specific actess yet. 

ddiaz28 5/9/2012 7:49:27 AM

The lady you are thinking of is named is Quaithe isgrimmer.  Pyatt Pree is the bald warlock from Quarth.  And you are probably right about why they haven't cast certain roles.  Same goes for Ramsay Snow (Reek).  But who knows, there are still a few episodes left.  It's crazy that there are only 4 more.  This season seems to by flying by. 

1 2 >  >>  

ADD A COMMENT

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Please click here to login.