Music News

Send to a Friend



To: (email)


To: (name)


From: (name)


Message:



Giant Soundtrack Poll Selects Graduate As Best And Ignores Film Scoring with the Rest

By: Randall Larson
Date: Monday, January 16, 2006

Simon and Garfunkel's "notorious score" for hit 60s film THE GRADUATE is still considered the best soundtrack in film history, according to a new poll taken by Giant magazine. The magazine's study, 50 Greatest Soundtracks of All Time, found the duo's soundtrack for Mike Nichols' 1967 classic was by far and away the favorite film album.

Featuring such acclaimed pop hits as "Mrs Robinson" and "The Sound Of Silence," The Graduate's soundtrack weighed in above Albert Magnoli's 1984 film PURPLE RAIN, starring former pop star Prince. The soundtrack for Quentin Tarantino's PULP FICTION, featuring Al Green's "Lets Stay Together," Dusty Springfield's "Son Of A Preacher Man," and Neil Diamond's "Girl, You'll Be A Woman Soon," came in third.

Seventies reggae movie THE HARDER THEY COME was voted as having the fourth best soundtrack, written by reggae songsmith Jimmy Cliff, 1998 film RUSHMORE came in fifth and Beatles classic HELP! was named sixth.

Danny Boyle's fast-paced Brit flick TRAINSPOTTING scooped the seventh place, LOST IN TRANSLATION was eighth and Robin Gibbs' SATURDAY NIGHT FEVER score came in ninth.

And Bernard Hermann, arguably the greatest ever film score composer, according to Giant, took tenth place for his efforts with the soundtrack of Alfred Hitchcock's classic 1959 thriller NORTH BY NORTHWEST.

As is typically the case with mass-media magazines like Giant, true film scores have been pretty much ignored in favor of song-oriented soundtracks. For example, Simon & Garfunkel's GRADUATE music is not a film score, per se, since it compiles songs into background music for the film. Excellent as it was in serving the film's purpose (as were those other song soundtracks cited by Giant), songs do not equate to score. Giant's top ten list typically cited films in which the songs were the only soundtrack music (one exception including HELP!, which featured limited underscore by George Martin). Herrmann is given lip-service but, aside from him, Giant's Top Ten is hardly a fair or accurate assessment of film music, per se. But it does reflect the public's perception (and, consequently, that of the record-buying majority) that songs are soundtracks and soundtracks are songs. Pity.

- www.giantmag.com  


- original report via http://soundtracks.monstersandcritics.com  

Cinescape's Music News provides weekdaily news and views on film music, progressive rock, and other notable musical genres, culled from a variety of sources.


More Content By Randall Larson
Fandango Logo
Comments/Responses
1
• Jan 16, 2006, 04:07pm •
WHAT?!?!?!?! Oh please, where were these polls taken? The Graduate? I guess that means they ignored "classically based" style soundtracks(i.e. Star Wars, Close Encounters, Jaws, etc.), films that use an ORCHESTRA not a "rock band". Sorry, but that doesn't define the ONLY kind of soundtracks.

• Jan 16, 2006, 05:22pm •
Well technically speaking a "soundtrack" is a collection of songs (musically speaking, not sound effects and such), and a score is the instrumental or orchestral stuff. So they could have been speaking solely about song-oriented film music. Maybe. Of course they've left out one of the most important elements of cinema. Sorry, NO John Williams, Jerry Goldsmith, Ennio Morricone, and only brief mention of Bernard Herrman: way incomplete list. And it certainly ain't accurate either.

• Jan 16, 2006, 07:06pm •
Fishpoop(love your name, BTW!), you just named 3 of my favorite composers, along with Danny Elfman, and James Horner. I also like David Arnold, John Corigliano, Alan Silvestri, and Howard Shore.

• Jan 17, 2006, 07:10pm •
While I don't agree with the results, I do have to say that, first of all, Simon and Garfunkel wrote those songs to score the film. And I would challenge the notion that songs do not equate to score. In most cases, yes, that is the case, just as most film scores are subpar--but I will contend that there are some song soundtracks that are crafted with as much care and attention as a composed score. Martin Scorsese is the master of this (Goodfellas, Mean Streets), and changed the way pop songs were used in film. Tarantino's soundtracks for Jackie Brown and Kill Bill work in the same way.

1
Login to post a comment!