Green Zone Movie Review - Mania.com



Movie Review

Mania Grade: B-

10 Comments | Add

 

Rate & Share:

 

Related Links:

 

Info:

  • Movie: Green Zone
  • Rating: R
  • Running Time: 1 hrs. 55 min.
  • Starring: Matt Damon, Greg Kinnear, Jason Isaacs, Amy Ryan, Brendan Gleeson and Khalid Abdalla
  • Written By: Brian Helgeland
  • Directed By: Paul Greengrass
  • Distributor: Universal Pictures
  • Series:

Green Zone Movie Review

A Rock and A Hard Place

By Rob Vaux     March 12, 2010


Matt Damon in Paul Greengrass' latest thriller GREEN ZONE(2010).
© Universal/Bob Trate

 

The Green Zone suffers in comparison to The Hurt Locker, which won the Best Picture Oscar just last week and thus casts a lengthy shadow over this production. Director Paul Greengrass endeavors to create the same "you are there" verisimilitude as Kathryn Bigelow's lauded effort, married to the trappings of a traditional Hollywood thriller to help put bums on seats. The combination proves a less-than-perfect fit. It functions extremely well as pure stimulus response, but its efforts to get at the deeper causes of the Iraq war hamstring the otherwise laudable technical elements.
 
Simply put, its central message is late to the party. The Bush Administration sold the world a bill of goods with its weapons of mass destruction claims in Iraq, a fact most of us acknowledged, digested and expressed our anger about years ago. Greengrass and star Matt Damon attempt to shed light on the way the lies unraveled, an admirable goal undone by their reliance on stock cliché. The Green Zone posits a lone do-gooder--Damon's Warrant Officer Miller--charged with uncovering WMDs and turning on his smug, arrogant superiors when he can't find the weapons everyone seems certain are there.
 
Greengrass has an unparalleled ability to plant us face-first in the action, and his canvas here carries the white-knuckle immediacy of a city still in the grips of war. We're scant weeks after the invasion and the whole world is holding its breath to see what happens next. Inside the Green Zone--Baghdad's central core where the U.S. has set up shop to rebuild the country--everyone's delivering high fives and planning important meetings from which democracy will surely bloom. But out on the streets, chaos still reigns, and Miller and his team come across empty warehouse after empty warehouse supposedly chock full of the chemical heinosity which set the whole imbroglio off in the first place. Frustrated at the lack of progress, he turns to increasingly unorthodox means to hunt down the truth, setting him against the very forces which handed him his mission in the first place.
 
On its most basic levels, the film is exceptional. Greengrass uses the same intensity he captured in the Bourne films to lace Miller's quest with all manner of unseen dangers. From a simple goal of securing dangerous weapons, he finds himself in a quagmire of shifting alliances and moral compromise. Backing the wrong side may get him killed, but amid all the Byzantine power plays it's hard to say whose is truly the right side. The Green Zone does first-rate work when it focuses solely on Miller's dilemma and on the threats which loom at him from seemingly every corner.
 
Unfortunately, the film seems hell-bent on saying Really Important Things in the midst of the sturm und drang. Greengrass has proven his ability to do so in the past--most notably with his indelible United 93--but here his efforts feel simplistic and contrived. The collapse of Iraq following the American invasion hinged on numerous complex factors, which The Green Zone glosses over in as expedient a manner as possible. In their place, it inserts easily-identifiable villains--Greg Kinnear's smug administrator, Jason Isaac's amoral Special Forces soldier, and Igal Naor's fugitive Iraqi general--to stand in for the actual issues. The clear demarcation of good guys from bad hamstrings the film's efforts to present an ethically ambiguous reality (though it does present the refreshing notion that the CIA may be on the side of the angels).
 
Within that framework, the monotonous drumbeat of right vs. wrong slowly drowns out all other concerns… at least if you look at it as political commentary. For popcorn entertainment, however, it can't be beat, forming a curious schism between a thinking man's action picture and a dreadfully outdated cry of outrage. The former is one of the best in recent memory; the latter as limp as week-old spaghetti. Your ability to enjoy the film depends solely on which side you choose to ignore. The Green Zone would have done well to emulate the example of The Hurt Locker, which presented its story unvarnished and let the audience make up its own mind about the politics. By presuming to lecture us, The Green Zone undermines its best qualities and saddles an otherwise terrific thriller with baggage it just doesn't need.

COMMENTS AND RESPONSES

Showing items 1 - 10 of 10
1 
MrJawbreakingEquilibrium 3/12/2010 1:09:40 AM

Knew it was nothing like The Bourne series that everybody keeps trying to compare it to.

spiderhero 3/12/2010 4:09:28 AM

I'll rent it when it comes out, but I'm getting kinda tired of war movies about Iraq. No political stance here, just saying.

wolfmanX 3/12/2010 4:54:37 AM

I love war movies, but it has to be done right. I saw The Hurt Locker and thought it was a great movie. When I saw the preview to this movie it came to look more like a action movie then a war movie IMO. So thats why I wasnt really rushing for it. I think I wil Netflix it unless I hear that is a movie that cant be missed.

Hobbs 3/12/2010 7:38:16 AM

One thing for certain, a Greengrass movie is going to have a major shaky camera thing going on.

JDK008 3/13/2010 12:05:50 PM

I was excited to see this movie till I read this review. Knowing now that it has a far left political agenda turns me off completely. Haven't we heard enough about there not being WMD's in Iraq?  Hasn't that ship sailed far, far away? Someone needs to make a movie about how bad this 800 million stimulus will frak up this country in years to come. Leave Bush alone already..Jesus!

fenngibbon 3/13/2010 11:54:37 PM

 Every review I've seen makes it sound as if this movie was based on a bumper sticker:  Bush Lied, Thousands Died.

 

Rather than observe that at the time major intelligence services around the world thought Saddam had WMD's, I'll just ask when they plan a movie based on "If You Can Read This, You're Too Close." 

DaForce1 3/14/2010 1:21:59 AM

 JDK, since Dubya got us into a two front war by not tightening national security when he got into office, and then lying to Congress to start another war in another country costing us billions and putting us into a deficit (when we had been in a surplus under Clinton) which we may never get out of (much like we may never get out of Iraq or Afghanistan), I think it does bear repeating lest some morons don't learn from those rather large mistakes and attempt to repeat them. 

Kind of like loosening banking regulations on loans in 2001 that led to the housing loan collapse. But that's for another movie.

jdiggitty 3/14/2010 11:28:44 AM

Hobbs, I saw it Saturday and you'er right. Shaky-cam overdone. Even felt a bit motion sick a couple times.

Other than that, the movie wasn't all that good, IMO. Its more of a political intrigue than actioner. I think the action scenes in the previews may have been the only ones in it.

Hobbs 3/15/2010 7:33:50 AM

Wow...stop reading the propaganda DaForce.  Clinton left office with 5.3 trillon dollar debt, Bush doubled it to over 10 in 8 years.  Obama has almost spent that much in one year and is going to bankrupt the nation with his massive Socialist health care plan.  That surplus thing Clinton had has been spun to the nth degree.  Bush was a moron, an idiot to the highest standards but the moron in office now is making him look like George Washington. 

Iraq was a mistake, no doubt about it and I'll be happy when we are out of there.  One of the only things I support Obama on...but Afghan?  Didn't terrorist fly planes into a few buildings about 9 years ago or something like that?  And didn't the Terrorist come from training in Afghanistan?  Or was that a conspiracy by the Evil Bush people too?

CaptAmerica04 3/15/2010 5:30:06 PM

LMAO!!  Hobbs, you are SO right.

And might I add my favorite highlight of the Clinton years that everyone seems to forget:  While he was getting his knob polished in the Oval Office, he was simultaneously deconstructing our military, down to 35% of its fighting strength under Reagan.  Maybe Aghanistan would be going better if we had 20 Army infantry divisions still in existence rather than the paltry 7 we have now.  When I was there, we sure could've used more boots on the ground.

That said, Bush didn't learn that little lesson that was taught to the world by Napoleon and then reiterated by Hitler:  you don't fight a war on 2 fronts!  Moron.

But this is all old news, right?  ;) 

I just wanted to write on here that I hate Greengrass and his shaky-cam nonsense that is supposed to make things "frenetic" and end up just being annoying and headache-inducing.  He is supposed to be the ideal of action directors now, since the Bourne series, and he SUCKS. 

I miss John McTiernan.

1 

ADD A COMMENT

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Please click here to login.

POPULAR TOPICS