Television Review

Send to a Friend



To: (email)


To: (name)


From: (name)


Message:



Heroes: Five Years Gone

By: Stephen Lackey
Review Date: Wednesday, May 02, 2007

OK, I have to admit I wasn’t really looking forward to this episode because the ads made in feel like filler. You could look at this episode as filler in some ways and if you do it’s some of the most brilliantly done filler I’ve seen on television in years. So, Hiro and Ando have traveled five years into the future and run into well, Hiro. In this episode we meet the bad ass English speaking Hiro that we first caught a glimpse of so many episodes ago. Before I go any further let me say that Masi Oka has done a great job as the super geeky Hiro but as the bad ass Hiro, not so good. His acting is really sketchy in this role. Let the complaining begin! Say what you will, I like the character too, but Oka was weak in those scenes. Anyway Hiro and Ando discover from the future Hiro that after the explosion, blamed on Sylar, people with special gifts are feared and hunted by the government that’s now led by Nathan as President and Matt as his flunky. I’ve made reference to The X-Men before but it has never been more appropriate than in regard to this episode. Also, remember when I compared this episode to a What If? comic from Marvel, well did you catch the promo to the episode before it started? At least they are wearing it proudly.

Future Hiro tells the story of the last five years to Ando and present Hiro. He tells them of how he has worked on the timeline and finally found what must be done to set things right. Present Hiro must go back to his own time and kill Sylar. Just as they hash out the plan present Hiro is taken by Matt, now leader of homeland security and responsible for bringing in the “specials”. The President has been funding Mohinder to research the potential of reversing the genetic flaw that gives the specials their power. In the end though that’s not what the president wants, he wants genocide. IN the coolest twist of the episode we learn that Sylar isn’t dead, he has taken Candice’s shape shifting power and has been impersonating Nathan since the explosion. It wouldn’t be a “What If?” episode if other characters weren’t put in unique situations so also in this episode we see Peter and Nikki as a couple, sort of, and Matt’s partner is the Haitian. Bennett is working in secret hiding “specials” getting them new identities and money to start over. Future Hiro and Ando convince Peter that everything that has happened can be fixed but he has to help them save present day Hiro. This leads to a showdown between Sylar and Peter that starts off cool and then just happens behind a door.

A lot more happens in this episode but most of it doesn’t matter because after all it is a “What If?” but we had to see it, and Hiro had to see it, so he will do the right thing back in his own time. What will also be interesting to see is how much of this future still holds true when and if the specials stop Sylar and the explosion. The one to watch is Nathan. At this point he hasn’t committed to Linderman’s plan but he seems ready too. Now we didn’t see her in this episode but I’m very curious to see what role Nathan’s mother will play and what her abilities are.

This was overall a very entertaining episode. It’s fun to see characters in a series we are familiar with changed or thrown in different situations that might force them to act out of character. 98% of this episode was filler, but as I said it was well done filler, and implemented in such a way that all of it matters to the finale of this story because of how it affects Hiro and Ando. Hiro, the sweet guy who just wants to be a “hero” knows in order to meet that goal that he has to kill someone and Ando, the man without powers knows that in the future where the explosion happens that he will die, and the he plays an important part in Hiro’s life and success. 





More From Mania

DVD Review of Next Avengers: Heroes of Tomorrow

Video: 'Legion of Super Heroes' Vol. 3 DVD clips
(Monday, August 25, 2008)
You Nitwit! Heroes Are Extinct!! Vol.#01
(Friday, August 31, 2007)
"Heroes: .07%"
(Wednesday, April 25, 2007)
Throwing Gas on the Flames: Your Letters
(Wednesday, April 4, 2007)
City of Heroes
(Thursday, June 3, 2004)
SCOOP: Your feedback on CITY OF HEROES!
(Saturday, April 24, 2004)
Comicscape - December 17, 2003
(Wednesday, December 17, 2003)

See more related content
More Content By Stephen Lackey
Fandango Logo
Comments/Responses
1 2 3 4 > >>
HudsonTaco • May 02, 2007, 12:26am •
Well I felt Future Hiro's acting was fine, I wouldn't call this a filler episode either. The future haden't changed because Hiro left the present and wasen't able to stop Sylar. This episode is about getting him back so he can fulfill his destiny. In my opinion a filler episode may give backround to characters without advancing the story. Also I think we may still see Sylar kill Candice and or Nathan and take thier powers, they weren't really specific as to when he took thier powers. His comment about how Nathan had already turned on his own kind when he killed him might still happen b4 the explosion. Kring said not all the heroes will survive for season 2.

Merin • May 02, 2007, 02:13am •
I found all the acting really good myself. No complaints there.

I also question this being called "filler." I even question the need that some seem to have to classify an episode as filler. Is it the show you were watching? Is it some of the characters you were watching at least? Does it reference previous episodes and lead into future episodes? Does it have a point?
It wasn't at all what I'd call filler. A filler episode of Heroes, to me at least, would involve telling some back story about some character just introduced in said episode, a back story that concludes in that episode without connecting to nor furthering the story but instead acting as a vignette of another heroes' life; or a filler episode could be a flashback to a main character's past which shows stuff that just further explains said character's personality but doesn't move any part of any storyline forward.

This episode had most of the main characters. It wasn't a flashback nor back story nor focusing on some "one-shot" character. It showed the future as if things go as they were going, it tied into previous episodes at many points, and the story of stopping the nuclear explosion of Peter is taken another step forward as well as the strengthening of Hiro's epic quest.

If this is filler, the whole season is filler.

EvilMonkey • May 02, 2007, 06:18am •
I also echo the previous comments. I found nothing wrong with the acting and this to not be filler but quite the opposite in that it advanced Hiro's story.

Plus how cool a tease was that for a Peter vs. Sylar smackdown ? Also a cool shot of Nathan/Sylar flying off.

TheSleeper • May 02, 2007, 07:36am •
Please, let's stop this sloppy use of the term "filler" before it gets out of hand the way people use "jumped the shark" when they really mean they just didn't like the episode.

Used to be "filler" was used to describe episodes like Star Trek: The Next Generation's infamous "Shades of Grey" in Season 2. Such an episode was literally there to "fill up space" because the production had run out of money to do anything better. Now I guess with all the serialized storytelling going on, any episode that doesn't reveal major plot ploints in the larger story arc is supposed to count as filler? By that criterion, just about every episode of the X-Files without Cancer Man was filler.

This week's episode of Heroes was great, entertaining, and one of the best of the season. Far from being irrelevant to the larger story, it shows us what the stakes are regarding the upcoming nuclear blast, and what failure would do to these characters. From that standpoint, it's a great setup for the episodes coming down the line.

My only complaint is that when Hiro and Peter launch their attack it's clear that some Matrix Government Lobby Shooting Spree type action is what was intended, but we only end up with one overhead shot of Hiro taking a guy out with his sword, and one or two examples of Peter throwing people around the room. Shame we couldn't get more of the good stuff...but I guess TV budgets and network censors prevented that from happening.

Great episode, regardless.


AlpineWoods • May 02, 2007, 07:39am •
Monday's episode was a good one. They'll save New York from exploding and stop whichever character it is who explodes, whether it's Syler, Peter, or the Nuclear Guy. And even if New York does go kaboom, Hiro can just go back and stop it from happening, and go back over and over if he has to. Just like The Terminator.

MIKWOZ • May 02, 2007, 08:27am •
i loved the episode. I like the change in Hiro's story (now having to kill Sylar). But, and i know this is petty, but why did Peter have a scar if he has Clair's healing ability?????

ponyboy76 • May 02, 2007, 08:49am •
Another great episode! And definitely not a "filler" episode. I was surprised that it was Sylar but the glimpse of the battle between those two was really cool. Peter was bad ass in this episode. My one question is if it wasn't Sylar who explodes and its Peter who we thought it was all along, then what does it matter if Hiro kills him or not? Peter might still explode, because of Nathan and Linderman. Its still unlcear what or who causes him to explode.

monkeyfoot • May 02, 2007, 09:10am •
A truly excellent episode! As I watched it all I could think of was the famous X-Men "Days of Future Past" storyline. Tim Kring , the creator of Heroes may not be familiar with comics, but obviously others on the staff are. A major character is given knowledge of horrible future circumstances centered around a pivotal event and only he can stop it. This is the stuff of great SF tales that has been used in the Terminator movies but never fleshed out so well for non-genre audiences. Everyone I've talked to who is a Heroes watcher but not really a genre fan thought it was some of the best TV they had ever seen.
As was said in earlier post, this was not a filler episode but carried information important to the series. There were also names and events mentioned that I'm sure are relevant to the normal timeline of the show. I don't think there's been a misstep in this series yet.

mbeckham1 • May 02, 2007, 09:13am •
This episode was brilliant. I loved every minute. Seeing how the characters were affected by the explosion and the five years. The action and plot twist were classic X comics at their best.

You say "What...if"

I say "Days of Future Past" would be a more apt allusion.

And your right. Seeing President Nathan become Sylar was one the coolest scenes in televison ever. And seeing the look on Claire's face as the blood ran down. Chilling

Peter was brilliant, playing his future with a bitterness that evokes Claude when Peter first met, added to an obvious sense of having been beaten.

Seeing him get his hope back and rejoin the fight was great. As was Ando learning he had died.

Bennet was best served in this version, keeping the specials in hiding. And his conversion to a man desperate to make up for past sins was believable and powerful. I love the scene where he's telling that family about how to hide and that they'll never be completely safe. The sincerity of that scene from a man who would know, and know for all the wrong reasons was beautifully done.

Matt was probably the most interesting change. And to be honest I'd like to have known more about his motivations. From his conversation with Bennet one can infere that he was doing this job because it somehow enabled him to protect his wife and son, who apparently left him. Whether to hide or because they didn't like what he was becoming was unclear.

It is clear that he and Bennet have completely reversed roles since they first met and that reversal was palpable throughout their talk.

Which brings me to the wishing I knew more. I could buy Matt as the (to borrow at term from Days of Future Past) Hound, mutant hunting his own kind for the government. Given what had happened I could even accept him being such a hard case with Hiro. Even shooting future Hiro I could accept because from his perspective he was killing a terrorist. And when we found that he was secretly helping Bennet with the less dangerous specials. I thought, he is the old Matt after all.

Then he turned on Bennet. Which in itself is beleivable. But shooting Bennet's assistant in the head, apparently killing Bennet who from their had at one point been a friend, and then taking Claire in just to cover his own ass, that seems a little too much change for that character in five years.
If we knew he was doing it to protect his family I'd buy it no problem. Bennet's done as much himself, in the same cause, but I would've liked to have known the stakes for him.

Mohinder got some great scenes and his redemptive moment while a little predictable was very nice to see. And his and "Nathan's" interactions played well.

And the lead up to Peter and Sylars showdown was awsome.

And I agree, this wasn't irrelevant, it showed the consequences of failer for the Heroes, and gave Hiro a definitive direction for saving the world.

And I gotta speculate. Since future Hiro wasn't shot in the head, could Sylar take his powers and come back to our time, escaping the destruction of his timeline. Assuming he gets by Peter.

macgawd • May 02, 2007, 09:19am •
MIKWOZ writes:

"Why did Peter have a scar if he has Claire's healing ability???"

Remember way back when Peter first meets future Hiro on the subway, and Hiro comments that Peter "looks different without the scar"? My guess is that even though he has Claire's healing ability, surviving a nuclear explosion probably pushes that ability to its absolute limits, thus leaving a terrible scar. Just a guess.

1 2 3 4 > >>
Login to post a comment!