TV Review


"Heroes: Six Month’s Ago”

By: STEPHEN LACKEY
Review Date: Thursday, November 30, 2006

What we have here is an origin episode.  I was afraid that we may be getting our first “filler” episode.  You know, that episode that really doesn’t have a lot to do with the main storyline.  In a way it was a filler episode, but it wasn’t any less interesting.  In fact, the episode is very necessary in that it deepens the motivations for many of the main characters, most importantly the super powered killer Sylar.  In this episode, we get to meet Sylar and see his back-story and his is the most interesting, and most comic book in tone.  We first meet him as Gabriel, a fittingly biblical name, the watchmaker.  He’s mild mannered, timid, and quiet, but he’s particularly talented at repairing watches. One day Chandra Suresh, Mohinder’s father, shows up in the watch shop to tell Gabriel that he may be the man he had always hoped to be.  Chandra has a list of people he has determined may have the genetic evolution that would give them special abilities.  When Chandra performs the necessary tests and tells Gabriel that he actually may not be special, Gabriel explodes in a rage and begins killing those that are on the list.  He first kills a man with telekinesis and some how, off screen, takes his power.  He returns to Chandra and demonstrates his new ability, putting himself back on the professors’ radar. It’s during that first murder that Gabriel takes the name Sylar from a watch in his store.  This story just feels so classic; the man dedicated to make mankind better creates a villain who only wants to be special.  I’ve seen it more times than I can count in comics and in classic literature but it still feels so fresh here.  Getting so much about Sylar this week really makes up for the lack of information from last week’s episode, even though we still don’t know why saving the cheerleader saved the world. 


The basis for this trip down memory lane is Hiro’s attempt to save Charlie, a waitress apparently killed by Sylar.  After witnessing the murder in the previous episode Hiro jumps back in time, intending to go back one day to save her life.  He actually travels six months back in time.  Rather than trying to go forward in time, he just chooses to live out the six months, or a good amount of it anyway.  He tries over and over again to convince Charlie of his abilities and of her impending doom.  She takes it all as flirting and it often comes off quite romantic because Hiro is obviously infatuated with the girl.  Hiro unfortunately learns a hard lesson that may have an overreaching effect on the series.  He can’t change the past no matter how hard he tries.  He may have prevented her from being murdered, but in the future he ahs created Charlie has a blood clot in her brain.  So, was Charlie always going to die of the blood clot or did time do this to her because Hiro stopped the murder?  It’s apparent that Hiro can change the future, but not the past, so how does that affect his little trip from the future in ninja garb to tell Peter to save the cheerleader?  You have to be very careful with this time travel debacle, hopefully we’ve learned much from STAR TREK in this regard.  In the end I was sorry to have seen the last of the instantly likable Charlie and the chemistry she shared with Hiro.  Her death is a necessary part of Hiro’s evolution as a “hero”.  All the greatest heroes have made the most tragic sacrifices, and now Hiro is well on his way.  His back-story just goes further in defining him as the most fun and interesting character on the show. 

The other back-stories weren’t as interesting as Hiro and Sylar’s but that did offer some solid groundwork for the development of the characters.  Nathan has always been an unlikable character, possibly even a future villain, but now we see where he’s coming from, and the weight he carries with him.  From this episode we now know that his experience with Peter wasn’t the first time he had used his ability to fly.  Seeing him leap from the car as it crashed was a jaw dropper, and as awe inspiring as the moment was it was also one of the darker in the series.  He simply hovered away as his wife crashed in the car leaving her wheelchair bound.  He’s so callus and self serving though it’s a little tough to see where they plan to go with him.  Does he feel guilt over what happened or does he not really care as long as his political career isn’t affected?  He sure likes sleeping with any cute blonde that might happen along.  Speaking of Nikki, her back-story has given her some required complexity and depth.  Having her split personality being named the same as her dead sister adds some potential for new ideas with her character.  Is her split personality a result of child trauma or is it somehow connected to Jessica and the biological evolution sweeping the world in a more literal way?  For the first time so far, I’m a bit interested to see where her character goes. 

Eden’s back-story also crosses with Mr.’ Bennett’s and his daughter Claire.  Bennett finds Eden and he uses the Haitian to help catch her and explain to her what her options for a future are.  She agrees to work for him, which leads us to her moving in next door to the professor.  The interesting part of this for me was learning that Bennett’s initial involvement seems to be to get Claire’s name off the list.  It’s simple, too simple, and it made me wish for more of a back-story on this shady character.  The biggest misstep of the episode is that of all the time given to Matt Parkman, the cop.  He gets a good amount of screen time but other than the fact that he has dyslexia, we learn absolutely nothing new about him.  I like this character a lot but he had no purpose in this episode at all.  Minor complaints aside we now have a great platform from which to see these characters evolve throughout the rest of the season.  I also think it was a brilliant more to do this now rather than during the opening weeks.  It’s interesting to know what the characters have done so far and what they’ve been through and then go back and learn what might have motivated them.  I’m sure we’ll get another episode like this because there’s much more to learn.




More From Mania

You Nitwit! Heroes Are Extinct!! Vol.#01

"Heroes: .07%"
(Wednesday, April 25, 2007)
Throwing Gas on the Flames: Your Letters
(Wednesday, April 4, 2007)
Science Center Unleashes Super Heroes
(Tuesday, March 21, 2006)
City of Heroes
(Thursday, June 3, 2004)
SCOOP: Your feedback on CITY OF HEROES!
(Saturday, April 24, 2004)
Comicscape - December 17, 2003
(Wednesday, December 17, 2003)
Marvel Heroes Losing Costumes?
(Monday, October 29, 2001)

See more related content
More Content By STEPHEN LACKEY
TV Wasteland: CBS Knows Best, or Do They?
(Monday, August 25, 2008)
BURN NOTICE: Rough Seas
(Friday, August 22, 2008)
EUREKA: I Do Over
(Thursday, August 21, 2008)
PRIMEVAL
(Tuesday, August 19, 2008)
TV Wasteland: Ron Moore Goes Virtual
(Monday, August 18, 2008)
EUREKA: Best in Faux
(Thursday, August 14, 2008)
TV Wasteland: Torchwood Audio Episode?
(Monday, August 11, 2008)
EUREKA: What About Bob?
(Thursday, August 7, 2008)
TV Wasteland: Heroes Cast Getting Larger
(Monday, August 4, 2008)
EUREKA: Bad to the Drone
(Thursday, July 31, 2008)
Comments/Responses
1 2 > >>
Redshirt1 • Nov 30, 2006, 06:37am •
I don't think that Nathan flew out of the car on puropse. He seemed to be surprised that he was hovering over the car. He was shouting to his wife and seemed to be trying to reach her, but couldn't. And then he fell to the ground after his wife crashed. I would have to say that Nathan wasn't in control of his powers. Litterly his subconscious mind activated the fight or flight trigger and he shot up into the air. That's my take on it anyway.

evilkerek • Nov 30, 2006, 06:59am •
I agree - it was definitely not intentional. I'm assuming that this is the first time he had manifested his power and it was running on automatic - and I think this also is where the whole 'what do you want me to do fly around and do what?' attitude towards his brother. His power didn't help him save his wife - how can he save anyone else?

slackey • Nov 30, 2006, 08:34am •
I agree with both of you. The question I'm left with is how did that event change him emotionally? Does he feel any guilt over what happened? I know he couldn't have predicted that he would literally fly from the car the way he did but I'd think he'd at least feel bad that his wife was put into a wheelchair when he wasn't hurt at all. His actions don't speak to that at all, making him even more of a potential villain.

mbeckham1 • Nov 30, 2006, 09:00am •
I agree too. Nathan's power kick probably for the first time without his control. And I also agree that it is the reason he has such a negative attitute toward his powers. You'd think flight would be one of the better powers to have, alot of fun and little down side.

Its more clear now that Peters true power is as an empath. Nathan's wife even uses that word to describe him, and that his dreams of flight came either from his brohers dreams or his actuall experiments with his own.

As for how super-empathy leads to power duplication, Chandra lays out the powers come from changes the DNA akes in the brain, so Peter's empathic powers alters his brain to function as others around him with powers. But he can enter the dreams or experience the memories of anyone.

It also exlains the relationship between the Haitains ability to erase memories and his ability to negate the powers of others. Maybe he can inhibit certain vital neural connections.

As for Syalar. He talked about making the parts fit right and seemed to start examining his first victims brain with his watchmaker's glasses. I beleive his intuitve sense of how things work together allowed his, after examining the brain of a super, to know how to adjust his own brain to gain that power.

Whether this involves him actually perfoming brain surgery on himself or whether he just needs to see the brain wiring is unclear.

The beleif I'm leaning toward with Nikki and Jessica is that Jessica's real full consciousness in Nikki's mind. I'm thinking either Jessica had the power to leave her body which kicked in when her father killed her and she had to take refuge in her sisters body to survive. Or Nikki had the power to take her sisters consciousness and save her, which kicked in when she saw or felt that her sister was dying. And maybe having two mind doubles the strength of her body which only her sister knows to take advantage of since the trauma or the experience blocked Nikki's memory of it.

I had thought Sylar was the one wo killed Chandra, but now leaning to Mr. Bennet having him killed.

Syalar would have wanted Chandra alive as an audience to his exploits while Chandra who, if Eden was successful in her mission, would be the only one alive who knew Claire belonged on that list.

So why not have the Haitain "clean him out" maybe they tried and something went wrong. Or maybe the Haitain doesn't actually work for Bennet, but instead they both work for the same orginization, which Bennet may not as far as Claire is concerned.

Maybe he reall wants her off their radar. Imn any case it seems clear he and others were on the trail of the superbeings before even Chandra had started his search. I suspect Chandra and Mohinder's former colleage at the Unversity and the girlfriend with the biotech are also involved with that search.

I had also hoped Charlie would become a regular on the series. It does adfd tragic depth to Hiro's character that things happened the way they did but I think she would have made a great permanent character.

Matt's part was indeed wasted considering his dislewxia had been mentioned in a preivious episode, when he learned Clea Duvall's character pulled strings so he could take an oral test for his promotion.

It does show a sample of his bitterness and feelings of inadequacy that may have initially caused the problems in his marriage. But that's about it.

I'm hoping we get a meeting between Matt and Peter now that Peter's been arrested. They would interesting notes to compare.

gutsmgee • Nov 30, 2006, 09:37am •
"even though we still don’t know why saving the cheerleader saved the world. " Well seems to me a good guess would be that if he takes a heroe's powers....and her power is to be very hard to kill....and if he stole her power...well then.....probably not making him impossible to kill would save the world.....I mean do they get these writers at wal-mart? geesh?

bherstig • Nov 30, 2006, 09:41am •
I agree on the Nathan piece - he was surprised, and probably now has immense guilt - at flying. I am not sure I agree with the reviewer about Charlie though. Perhaps she had a tumor all along, which is what precipitated or enabled her "power" to appear. As she said, it just started happening. There are certainly other medical examples (and we've seen it in shows like ER and Grey's) where a brain tumor ends up giving people abilities and they must choose between fixing the annurism and losing the ability, or leaving it as is and risk dying.

Redshirt1 • Nov 30, 2006, 11:59am •
I'm also wondering about Hiro's time travel abillities. He said that he couldn't save Charlie. I took this to mean that he couldn't save her from Sylar and not the brain tumor. I presume that Hiro would still want Charlie to live as long as possible and not die at the hands of a lunatic. There was no indication that Charlie went on to Japan without Hiro and I believe that she went back to the resturant and was still killed by Sylar. In this universe we know that the past can be changed because Charlie did not recognize Hiro when he first showed up. She didn't say "Oh my God Hiro your back. we were just about to kiss and you disappeared!" So events changed after Hiro initially met her. In addition Charlie's birthday picture changed to now include Hiro. Then there is Future Hiro's warning to Pete to "Save the Cheerleader, save the world." Which also seems to indicate that the past can be changed. Maybe Hiro himself can't change events in his own timeline. If an event happens in his past he is part of that timeline and has to live with the results. However maybe future Hiro found out that he can have someone in the past who is part of that current timeline change a future event. Future Hiro warns present Pete to save Claire from her impending death. Claire's death for Hiro had happened and became a fixed part of his timeline, but because the event hadn't happened yet for Pete Claire's death is only one of several possible future outcomes. Therefore Pete could change the future. If this hasn't given you all a headache then let me know what you think.

mishrak • Nov 30, 2006, 12:00pm •
Here is a thought...By taking Charlie's powers/brain, Sylar has sealed his own doom. Perhaps as a component of her powers, the brain annurism aided in her ability to learn, but as she used her powers, the annurism continued to weaken her blood vessels and would have eventually killed her. So now Sylar is liiving on borrowed time.

gazelle024 • Nov 30, 2006, 12:15pm •
I have to say that Nathan's flying from the car just then was like a reflex reaction and that he was completely surprised and even seemed to be trying to return to the car, but as he had not learned to control his flying he was unable. I have to think he feels guilt over this, but at the same time tries to hide it as if it is something wrong with him. He may even in the future act against other super powered people like himself. That his brother is superpowered also should have an effect on this, but he has already acted against his brother most obviously when he tried to destroy the painting so Peter couldn't see it. It is interesting that Nikki's power may not be just some Jekyll/Hyde thing, but rather a connection with her dead sister. I'm not so sure that Hiro cannot change the past just because he couldn't save Charlie. This blood clot in the brain or brain tumor is a problem that any or all of them could have. It seems clear that Sylar can see how things work whether it is a watch or someone's brain and then can fix things so they work better. It then is reasonable to assume he is rewiring his own brain to take on more and more of these powers. I had thought that when Peter confronted Sylar he would take on Sylar's powers, but if that is only to see how things work and rewire things it doesn't help Peter in a fight with Sylar much unlike Claire's ability to heal. Theoretically Sylar could also save someone like Charlie by fixing her brain too. At this point I am interested in seeing just how saving Claire changes everything. Perhaps if she were to die her father would take some sort of vengeance or perhaps it has to do with the guy who puts out radiation or both or maybe it does make Sylar unstoppable. Even now he's pretty formidable.

noblenonsense • Nov 30, 2006, 12:39pm •
Simple thought for all of you...time travel=confusing. Sure its a good tv show but lets not try to explain every detail, k? Just enjoy. :-)

1 2 > >>
Login to post a comment!