Television Review


Heroes: How to Stop an Exploding Man

By: Stephen Lackey
Review Date: Wednesday, May 23, 2007

Some of you will remember way back when Heroes started, that I took issue with the pacing of it. I still believe the first 3 or 4 episodes moved very slowly, especially now after being able to look back at the season as a whole. With that said, when the series did pick up speed it became one of the best series on television. Up to this point it has been a near perfectly rendered comic book story for television. The characters are developed just enough, and presented realistically enough, that non comic book fans could get into the series while comic book fans could actually enjoy it for those same reasons along with an additional layer of comic book influence. My favorite part of the “comic book” story in this series is how the super groups were formed, and how Hiro actually has a sidekick. In comics these aspects are handled literally, a group is specifically formed for crime fighting and sidekicks are taken for various reasons. In the series, the groups are formed based on the situation; it’s never planned the pieces just fall together that force these people to work as teams. Hiro’s sidekick Ando was absolutely necessary to Hiro’s development as a hero, and when the time came for the final battle Ando directly or indirectly helped Hiro make the right decisions. So, Heroes has the drama and character of a good television series while also maintaining a solid comic book fantasy storyline. There’s only one problem; in comic books, even the best ones, plot holes are common and unfortunately there are some plot holes in this series finale. Now, fan boys can explain many of them away as “comic book” storytelling, or make assumptions on why this happened or what that was about, but the finality is there were plot holes. Did it make me hate the final episode of Heroes, no chance, but did it leave me with questions and frustrations? Absolutely.
 
The episode starts off with a recap of the entire series via a montage of shots going all the way back to episode one with a narration from Mohinder that discusses the need for humanity to solve problems and answer questions no matter what quest the answer might send them on. I know some people aren’t fans of his narrations at the beginning of each episode but I really like them. I think they add a magical quality to the series, as if he knows everything that will happen and he understands just how special and unique these people are. I may have said this before, but the narrations in a way remind me of The Watcher from Marvel Comics. The sequence is calm and quiet, a stark contrast to much of this episode.
 
The episode picks right where we left last week with a different angle on the death of Linderman and Matt waking up just in time to stop Mohinder and Bennett from killing each other and Molly, the tracking system. At the same time, Nikki faces off against Candice who is impersonating Jessica. They fight it out for a few minutes with Nikki getting smashed until she tags out with Jessica who knocks Candice out and then switches back to Nikki to get Micah out of the building. OK, plot hole number one, once Candice got knocked out the illusion of Micah disappeared and she reverted back to her familiar Candice form. Now, if getting knocked out turned off her abilities shouldn’t she have reverted to this bigger supposedly fatter form we were told about so many episodes ago? This one is sort of a small one compared to the ones I’ll mention later, but it bears mentioning anyway. So, she and Micah recover DL who is now with Mohinder, Matt, Bennett, and Molly. They head down stairs where Peter and Sylar are about to face off.
 
Before the big face off , Peter and Claire meet Nathan because Peter is hoping to get Nathan to help. He reads Nathan’s mind and discovers that Nathan has given up any thoughts that the explosion can be stopped. Peter and Claire are briefly separated until Claire makes a kick ass escape. Hiro leaves to find Ando who has gone to Isaac’s to try and kill Sylar. Why he thinks he can stop him is beyond me other than maybe he believes that by going he will force Hiro to follow, which Hiro does. This encounter between Hiro and Sylar is different. Sylar challenges Hiro asking him if he thinks he can use his power before Sylar kills Ando. Sylar is surprised to find the answer to be yes he can. This was a riveting sequence and foreshadows to the final battle. 
 
The writing up to this point has been pretty clever. I love the way the story’s natural evolution just brings everyone to the plaza where Peter and Sylar are ready for the final battle. This entire series has been building to this final battle and honestly overall it felt a little anticlimactic. Now, it started off cool as hell. Sylar is running the show choking and throwing everyone when Nikki runs up and pulverizes him getting close enough for Peter to replicate her powers. I was exhilarated when Peter tells her to go back to her family that he has it under control. Parkman leaps into the fray to be nothing more than Matrix style cannon fodder. Why wouldn’t he just read Sylar’s mind and predict what he was about to do and dodge it somehow? Now, I do agree that his job was actually to be a distraction for Hiro to come in jam the sword into Sylar’s gut, but still it would’ve been nice to see Parkman be worth more than that. So, I guess we are to assume that all of the power usage on Peter’s part gets the radioactive juices flowing then suddenly his hands begin to glow again and he feels the explosions coming. Time for the next complaint. Claire approaches him with the gun and he tells her to shoot him but he doesn’t turn around to give her the proper target. He and Claire both know the only way to kill him is to shoot him in the back of the head but neither of them seem to be concerned with that. This leads to the final complaint and predictable moment. I just knew that Nathan was going to show up to fly Peter into the sky so he could explode harmlessly because Superman and others have done similar tricks hundreds of times in comics. My question is why didn’t Peter just fly himself? He’s been around Nathan and should have easily replicated his powers. Some of you will say “well that was because Peter was so unstable that he couldn’t use that ability” and that might be true but it’s never mentioned in the episode. It would have been nice to see Peter attempt a flight and fail. My final issue is where is everybody? How is it that New York City looks like a ghost town? When Claire leaped from the window and Peter passed out, both in the street, where were all the cars? Extras come cheap or free, so budget can’t have been an issue.
 
Overall I liked the finale, I appreciated the clever assembly of characters, I even liked Sylar very comic book escape, even though no one seems to notice he’s gone. If there’s time for Molly to beg Matt not to die there’s time for someone to notice Sylar’s disappearance. That would have been a perfect scene for “Noah” or for Noah and Mohinder to share. The set ups for next season were also good. I liked Molly’s reference to someone even worse than Sylar and of course Hiro’s cliffhanger ending that sent him back to 1600’s era Japan that will surely have him meeting his hero. Also, in this clip the eclipse that’s part of the Heroes logo finally seems like it will mean something. Even with my complaints, I still can’t wait to see what happens next season!



More From Mania

You Nitwit! Heroes Are Extinct!! Vol.#01

"Heroes: .07%"
(Wednesday, April 25, 2007)
Throwing Gas on the Flames: Your Letters
(Wednesday, April 4, 2007)
Science Center Unleashes Super Heroes
(Tuesday, March 21, 2006)
City of Heroes
(Thursday, June 3, 2004)
SCOOP: Your feedback on CITY OF HEROES!
(Saturday, April 24, 2004)
Comicscape - December 17, 2003
(Wednesday, December 17, 2003)
Marvel Heroes Losing Costumes?
(Monday, October 29, 2001)

See more related content
More Content By Stephen Lackey
PRIMEVAL
(Tuesday, August 19, 2008)
TV Wasteland: Ron Moore Goes Virtual
(Monday, August 18, 2008)
EUREKA: Best in Faux
(Thursday, August 14, 2008)
TV Wasteland: Torchwood Audio Episode?
(Monday, August 11, 2008)
EUREKA: What About Bob?
(Thursday, August 7, 2008)
TV Wasteland: Heroes Cast Getting Larger
(Monday, August 4, 2008)
EUREKA: Bad to the Drone
(Thursday, July 31, 2008)
TV Wasteland: Dr. Horrible's Sing-a-Long Blog
(Monday, July 28, 2008)
FEAR ITSELF: New Year's Day
(Tuesday, July 22, 2008)
TV Wasteland: High Hopes on the Fringe
(Monday, July 21, 2008)
Comments/Responses
1 2 3 4 > >>
lung • May 23, 2007, 12:26am •
Pretty disappointing, I must say - for all the mentioned plot holes and some that weren't.

As for Hiro, I had always thought (based on the images of his hero and how he was able to bend away the arrows that flew at him in the depiction) that Hiro would eventually go back in time and become the very hero that he had admired (in a literal sense). I'm probably missing something, but from what I gather, Hiro is in actuality Takezo Kensai.

skoora • May 23, 2007, 12:36am •
I was actually flabbergasted at how weak and underwritten the climax was. No imagination and lazy as hell. They should have had us grasping to keep up with how the heroes worked together to beat Sylar. I really neede a WOW and I was left with a WTF instead.

I know the guys on the forum are really trying to come up with some depth and theories for this climax that give it some oomph but c'mon guys, it was lame and we can't imagine the crappiness away.

When you watch this on DVD you'll be like "Fuck! It didn't get better, no matter what I thought of for the last 6 months"!

...yeah, I'll still check out Season 2.

skoora • May 23, 2007, 12:37am •
I was actually flabbergasted at how weak and underwritten the climax was. No imagination and lazy as hell. They should have had as grasping to keep up with how the heroes worked together to beat Sylar. I really neede a WOW and I was left with a WTF instead.

I know the guys on the forum are really trying to come up with some depth and theories for this climax that give it some oomph but c'mon guys, it was lame and we can't imagine the crappiness away.

When you watch this on DVD you'll be like "Fuck! It didn't get better, no matter what I thought of for the last 6 months"!

...yeah, I'll still check out Season 2.

Merin • May 23, 2007, 01:19am •
Some comments for Stephen's plot holes:
1. Candice never said she was "big and fat" and that her "given" appearance was fake - she just kept teasing Micah with "how do you know I look like this or that", possibly to help keep him off balance and probably because she likes playing with people. YOU assumed she was fat because she was eating some french fries and said tauntingly "how do you know I look like this for real?"
2. We don't know that they have to be injured "in the back of the head" - it could just be damaging the brain does it. Shooting Peter in the face would have the same result as shooting him in the back of the head - it isn't like Peter or Claire are invulnerable except the back of the head - its that they heal all injuries save head injuries where something remains lodged in the brain. We know they can heal from said injuries when the object is removed, but we don't know that the object has to protrude through the back of the skull. He didn't need to turn around as far as we know.
3. Peter was focusing on controlling the one power - that was obvious - it was taking all his concentration to keep from exploding. Had he focused his thoughts (remember, we HAVE been told that he accesses his powers by thinking of the people and/or emotions related to the people he's copied the powers from) then he would have lost control and exploded before he could get away. It is not explicitly spelled out for you, but I do think it is strongly implied. At the very least it is as easy to assume this as it is for you to assume that he COULD have flown away himself BUT they forgot that and hence the plot hole.

Couple other observations on my part -

Sylar kept just appearing behind people from apparently out of nowhere. I was wondering if he had super-speed or teleportation or some other power we hadn't seen yet. But at the end, on the manhole cover where Sylar's blood trail leads, there's a bug, a cockroach I believe. Did Sylar turn into a bug? Was that how he "hid in plain sight" and snuck up on people? I think, if so, it was so very subtle and understated that it was awesome.

I knew Nathan would be a hero at the end, but even knowing I thrilled to watch it happen. The not leaving his brother angle, how he sacrificed himself - maybe you saw it coming and found it cliche. I found it perfect.

I believe the guy on the horse with the banner is an ancestor of Hiro. I think he could even possibly be Hiro's "father" who has "waited so long" for one of his family to rise up.

I don't think the plot holes were really holes, or big even if I could be convinced otherwise. I thought the episode was an amazing end to an outstanding series. And I loved how the story arc ended, wrapping basically everything up, but then we're given the start of the next volume before the episode ends! Sweetness!

westend • May 23, 2007, 01:39am •
Merin has it exactly right. I was only disappointed in the sense that I wanted a big Matrix stlye throw down between Peter and Sylar

Puscifer • May 23, 2007, 02:09am •
Season Finale for the most part sucked. So the big fight against Sylar and Peter punches him a few times?

WTF, they have been giving us little tastes of a big fight making amazing use of their powers...and they give us a few punches from Peter, Nicki hitting Sylar over the head with a parking meter, and a quick stab through the chest by Hiro? YAWN.

This goes down as one of the biggest anticlimactic let downs ever, right next to the crap that was the Iceman vs Pyro lameness in X-Men 3.

Here's a quick synopsis of what the ending should have been like.

- the streets should have been a battleground with most of the characters fighting against Syler in one aspect or another
- with Peter being the main combatant against Sylar
- at least 1 or 2 heroes dying during the fight
- Sylar starts to go nuclear to fight against Peter who at this point is winning
- Peter goes nuclear in response
- Sylar begins to lose control and can't contain it any longer
- . . . .

At this point just about any ending would be better than what they did. I can think of about a dozen cool ways this could end and none of them include Sylar dying by a simple stab to the chest and Nathan flying Peter off into space.

And why didn't they kill Sylar off? They already planted the seed that there was someone much worse. Sylar as a character was already flawed because they gave him too much power, making that much more difficult to have Heroes fight him.

DarkJedi • May 23, 2007, 02:49am •
Yep, we are trying to create imaginative reasons for what happened over in our Heroes forum here.

After all, for me at least, the last 10 minutes of Heroes was horribly written. It seemed as if the writers Kring and Co were either smoking something very toxic when thinking of the final act/scenes or their brains were completely "out to lunch".

Not sure what kind of reasoning they had behind that last 10 minutes of Season 1 but they definitely dropped the ball.

That said, I loved this first season as a whole overall view and I can't wait for season 2.

I just wished we could have a "Do Over!" for the last 10-15 minutes of the season.

ponyboy76 • May 23, 2007, 04:32am •
While I disagree with pretty everything Stephen said and agree for the most part with Merin, I still think that the last 10-15 mins could have been better. It definitely didn't "suck" as so many of us here keep saying but I think it could have been written with a little more "oomph".

I think some people are disappointed because , those of us who read comics expected some huge Secret Wars, Matrix type battle between Peter and Sylar. But thinking about it, and Stephen mentions it, the way the hero teams came together, weren`t planned. It was a string of events and circumstance. This isn't the X-men vs Magneto. None of them are professional "heroes". To me its the equivalent of 2 guys getting into a fight at a bar. In the future the fight looked bad ass because Peter has had years to learn to control and hone his powers. Right now, he can bearly stop from blowing himself up.
I`m sure Kring and co could have made it some huge Avengers type battle in the streets but thats not what this show is about. If you think it is, you`ve been watching the wrong show.
I would have liked the fight to last a little longer and maybe had more of the heroes fight against Sylar, not just Hiro and Nikki.
And just a note. Parkman wasn`t a distraction for Hiro. He was down and out way before Hiro showed up. Also, his powers don`t work that fast for him to dodge bullets.
I did wonder why there weren`t more people around, especially in NYC. That was probably the most unrealistic part, because there are people outside, no matter what time it is, especially in Manhattan.
I thought that this episode was good, could have been better but I`m happy with the finale.
I can`t wait for next season. That would be really cool if his father was Kensai. My belief is that Hiro is most likely a direct descendant and his father`s family has been waiting a long time for someone in the family to take up the mantle as a hero, like Kensai

nax37 • May 23, 2007, 06:41am •
Nikki didn't "turn into" Jessica to hit Candice. She finally realized she has the power herself. The Jessica personality was just a split personality to formed because she had an abusive father who apparently killed her actual sister Jessica. But it was the Jessica personality that first discovered and was able to use the super strength. And when Micah asked if it was really Nikki now and she said yes, I took that to mean that the Jessica personality is gone.

I thought the finale was good, except for the "All you need is LOVE!" and "Home is where our family is" corniness. Also, I hated how Nathan responded to something Claire said BEFORE he even flew in. Does he have super hearing too?

Buzzcutter • May 23, 2007, 06:55am •
Dito to Ponyboy & Merin. I too thought that the ending was rushed at first, but after thinking it overit made sense not only for the reasons listed above, but also poeticly, like in al comics - the villain is convinced of his own superiority and then is taken out by surprise rather quickly.

I didnt notice that Sylar's body was missing at the end of the show, i just assumed that first aid responders had removed it. Seems to me that the characters had been lingering at the scene for a while after the battle, so i assumed that someone would have noticed. I did notice that Hiro didnt feature much in the aftermath (if at all) and was wondering about his quick exit.

Someone brought up the idea of Sylar seemingly dropping in on people out of nowhere and related it to the cockroach at the end of the episode. I didnt make that conclussion, but it hadnt occured to me...i related the cockroach to being a symbol of evolution which Mohinder talked about at length in the 1st episode.

Going back to Sylar's poping in and out on people, i had noticed him make a quick exit on lats week's show, after fingering Ted to FBI Agent Audrey, she is talking to him, then turns and he is gone. We didnt see him disappear, but for a moment it seemed like he turned invisible or something, which brought me to my questions....

Why leave so many Heroes out of the finale? Where was Claude, especially after he figured so promiently laughing in Peter's visions on the bomb. And what ever became of the Hatian? He figured so prominently in the early episodes! Surely his powers could have helped in the battle. And then there was the email girl, Hana something...i know she has a big role in the on-line episodes, but i dont follow those closely, and she seemed to just pop up for an episode and then drop from the face of the earth.

I loved the redemption of Nathan coming to Peter's aid, and had figured Nathan to die if only because what the heck is this country (and this tv show) gonna do with a flying congressman! But I was sad to see Peter go. I know in a way he was getting too powerful, but he was a nicely developed character and someone you liked to follow. On a side note, since we know that Claire can regenerate from the explosion, does that mean that Peter should be able to also? Surviving the drop shouldnt be a problem since he can fly too! Just a thought.

Anyhow in season 2 im looking forward to finding out the connection between Mrs. Petrelli, Linderman, Shaft and Sulu, and also in this "more dangerous other guy".

1 2 3 4 > >>
Login to post a comment!