Movie Review


I AM LEGEND

By: Abbie Bernstein
Review Date: Friday, December 14, 2007

The newest screen adaptation of Richard Matheson’s influential novel I Am Legend suffers from near-schizophrenia. After director Francis Lawrence and screenplay adapters Mark Protosevich and Akiva Goldsman (Goldsman is also one of the producers) set a fine moody, bleak tone and create a few sequences that really make us sweat, they try to cram a film’s worth of plot into the last act, allowing unanswered “wait a minute” questions to breed like crazy and yanking us right out of their reality.
 
Will Smith plays Col. Robert Neville, a military scientist who is holed up on his own in Manhattan with only his German shepherd Sam for company. We know how things got this way – in the opening moments, Dr. Crippen (an uncredited Emma Thompson) modestly announces that she’s found a cure for cancer. Not long afterwards, the cure is either killing outright or turning its survivors into rabid mutants who cannot bear sunlight but, in darkness, will kill and eat anything that moves. Neville is immune to both contact and airborne strains of the virus and dogs can’t get the airborne version. By day, man and dog hunt for deer in the weed-choked streets of the city, full of abandoned cars and menacingly shadowed tunnels; by night, they hole up fearfully in a fortified brownstone. Neville persists in trying to contact other survivors via a daily radio broadcast and seeks a cure by experimenting on rats and, occasionally, a living mutant. Neville’s capture of a new mutant subject trigger a chain of events – and it’s here that the movie turns inside out.
 
Smith is soulful and empathy-inviting as Neville – we feel for the man in his loneliness, his love for Sam, his efforts to give himself hope in a hopeless situation. But in trying to show us that Neville has unknowingly underestimated the opposition, the filmmakers raise issues they then totally fail to address. They then add another plot element that makes us wonder all sorts of things – without giving anything away, it seems highly unlikely within the context of everything else that’s happening.
 
Although Matheson’s novel I Am Legend predates 28 Days Later and even George A. Romero’s Living Dead films, the new film feels like a lesser, not fully imagined riff on those movies rather than something with its own identity. When I Am Legend succeeds in being truly creepy, it’s great, but when it tries to tell a more elaborate story, it becomes lost in its own shortcuts.


More Content By Abbie Bernstein
THE STRANGERS
(Friday, May 30, 2008)
IRON MAN
(Friday, May 2, 2008)
PROM NIGHT
(Saturday, April 12, 2008)
THE RUINS
(Friday, April 4, 2008)
AMERICAN ZOMBIE
(Saturday, March 29, 2008)
FUNNY GAMES
(Friday, March 14, 2008)
CJ7
(Friday, March 7, 2008)
10,000 B.C
(Thursday, March 6, 2008)
PENELOPE
(Friday, February 29, 2008)
VANTAGE POINT
(Friday, February 22, 2008)
Comments/Responses
1 2 3 4 > >>
bjjdenver • Dec 14, 2007, 09:53am •
Going to see it Sunday, and I'm hoping for the best. I won't be expecting the mood of Last Man on Earth, or the 70's camp of Chuck's Omega Man, but I hope it will be entertaining.

this is such a great story that can be adapted to different eras and social climates, I can't believe they had such a hard time getting it made.

Will is a fine actor and a pretty sharp guy, who has done extremely well for himself. i usually enjoy his work, I just hope this one of his more dialed-down performances.

A few pretty dark flicks coming out for the holiday season...I love it, lol.

kaybar • Dec 14, 2007, 10:07am •
Man Abbie, I don't know how you could have given this flick a B- and Golden Compass a B+. I thought GC was terrible, in the D range, while I Am Legend eeked out a high B.

When the film enters into the third act the movie as a whole does slip up a bit, but this is a very cool post-apocalyptic thriller, and any shortcomings Legend had was more than made up for by the friggin' incredible Dark Knight attached trailer. LEDGER IS THE MAN!

WISEGUY562 • Dec 14, 2007, 01:16pm •
kaybar I agree with you, except that I don't think the movie slips at all. For those that were worried about so called "Smith momments", there really aren't any. He plays it straight. There really isn't any of that over confidence, I can take on the world if I have to attitude he displays in some of his movies. He comes across as vulnerable and human and in no way immune or unaffected by the situation he's in. I loved it. Man the critics here are tough. B-?
And that Batman trailer was great. Nothing there to think this movie won't live up to the hype. Now I just need to get to the I-MAX to catch the prologue.

goatartist • Dec 14, 2007, 01:23pm •
Oh man. Sounds like a good review but I was planning on seeing this thing in Imax, now Im a little hesistant. Is it worth it. B- man.

galaga51 • Dec 14, 2007, 02:35pm •
I gave it an A on enjoyability; as a general movie, maybe I should have given a slightly lower grade (B+ as a minimum), but as a thriller, I thought pretty much anybody (who likes thrillers) would like it. There was only one line that later I thought could be construed as a small plot hole and should have been left out. The vampy guys seemed a tad toonish at times, but otherwise it was a fun ride that didn't miss it's stop.

Again, if you're trying to decide, I think it would look cool on IMAX, but I didn't see it there.

ChittyChityBang • Dec 14, 2007, 04:23pm •
Anybody here also read the book? If so, how does it compare to it?

Jeedian • Dec 14, 2007, 04:27pm •
I hate watching movies like this because you know the character you are going to feel for the most.. (Sam the dog) is going to suffer a horrific death and instead of watching the movie enjoying it, you will be wondering what scene is going to be the dog's last.

The conept of the movie is overdone but I am always open to new interpertations because lets face it, its an intriguing one that always asks, "What would I do if I was in this situation?"


mephisto • Dec 14, 2007, 04:42pm •
Well I just watched the movie here in St. Louis at an IMAX theater so I could see the Batman/Joker prologue. Definately worth seeing at IMAX for that reason since only IMAX gets that Batman/Joker prologue. The movie was really interesting and solid for the first 2/3. Then it gets silly (a huge convenient/lucky moment) and it sets up the end which is even more silly in my opinion. Too bad some moron had to ruin what was a solid movie.

mephisto • Dec 14, 2007, 04:43pm •
Well I just watched the movie here in St. Louis at an IMAX theater so I could see the Batman/Joker prologue. Definately worth seeing at IMAX for that reason since only IMAX gets that Batman/Joker prologue. The movie was really interesting and solid for the first 2/3. Then it gets silly (a huge convenient/lucky moment) and it sets up the end which is even more silly in my opinion. Too bad some moron had to ruin what was a solid movie.

Jeedian • Dec 14, 2007, 04:48pm •
Mephisto, so you are saying its just like another one of those movies like Independence Day with the "give it a cold" relates to a computer virus and everything miraculously works out there after? That always makes the movie cheesy and never did like those kinds.

1 2 3 4 > >>
Login to post a comment!