Television Review


JOHN FROM CINCINNATI: His Visit: Day Nine

By: Stephen Lackey
Review Date: Tuesday, August 14, 2007

Here we are the season finale, more ex-Deadwood actors and more weirdness. Do we know anymore about the story? Well, no not so much. Do we really know anything about what we’ve spent the last ten weeks watching? Again, no, not so much. Oddly there is closure for many of the characters and John even gives us some ideas about their future, but there’s nothing for the viewer. It’s like the creators of the series wrote the show and the season finale in particular for themselves and the characters not for the audience. 
 
In the opening of the episode John and Shaun hurdle through the waves in matching uniforms and doing synchronized surf tricks. This scene exhilarated me and was excited for what would follow. During the scene we also visited most of the other main characters all in, if not happy, but more positive positions. So it just seemed like a lot of nothing happened with only a few notable events. One such event is that Bill finally made it up those stairs in his house and he sat near a hospital bed set up there for his wife. As he tells her of his current adventures Zippy makes a triumphant return. Also, Stinkweed organizes a parade and rally to announce the signing of the entire Yost family and John. The idea is to not only start promoting them as being “back in the game” but Stark also manages to cover all of the odd events surrounding the Yosts as part of his promotion machine. He even shows off the stick figure image posted on the internet by John to represent Shaun’s disappearance as the new logo for Stinkweed. The preparation for the parade provided an interesting scene where a car salesman took over to John for a few minutes when John was “taken offline”. Oh and there was another sequence where Cass did her best imitation of Cissy. This is really inherent of this episode; it’s made up of short interesting sequences that don’t add up to much.
 
Speaking of Stark, the Yost family did a pretty clever thing when Shaun and John returned, Butchie pulled Shaun to the side to talk to him and left Stark to talk to John and try to find out where he and Shaun have been. Freddie couldn’t get any information from John before and neither could Bill so why not try the slickest guy on the beach? The scene was hilarious because Stark approached the situation in every way he could think of but he never broke any ground with John. I think he in fact came away from the conversation even more confused, I know I did.
 
I appreciate how David Milch has used classic literary characters and concepts to build this series and I also appreciate the surreal mature of the proceedings. In fact the surreal situations are what have kept me coming back even after certain actors give me a headache with their utter badness and some scenes no matter how well acted are just boring. The trick is that there has to be some answers built into the haze of oddity and there really haven’t been up to now. In the end the only thing I took away from the season is a theme and not any true answers. Thematically the show is saying that in some way we are all connected and to make things better in the world we all have to work together no matter how different we from each other. I really appreciate how the series delivered this message but I’m coming away basically disappointed.


More Content By Stephen Lackey
PRISON BREAK: Five the Hard Way
(Friday, October 10, 2008)
TERMINATOR: THE SARAH CONNOR CHRONICLES: Goodbye to All That
(Wednesday, October 8, 2008)
TV Wasteland: Red Mars is Coming to AMC
(Monday, October 6, 2008)
TV Feature Interview: Ghost Hunters
(Saturday, October 4, 2008)
TV Feature Interview: Scare Tactics
(Saturday, October 4, 2008)
HEROES: One of Us, One of Them
(Thursday, October 2, 2008)
SANCTUARY: Sanctuary for All
(Thursday, October 2, 2008)
TERMINATOR: THE SARAH CONNOR CHRONICLES: Allison from Palmdale
(Wednesday, October 1, 2008)
TV Feature Interview: Josh Gates Talks Destination Truth
(Wednesday, October 1, 2008)
Feature Interview: Sanctuary's Amanda Tapping
(Tuesday, September 30, 2008)
Fandango Logo
Comments/Responses
1
DarkJedi • Aug 14, 2007, 12:25am •
Stephen....I loved this episode...Even more then I loved any episode of DEADWOOD..

Can you explain to me why you gave it a D?

Is "Cissy" (Rebecca DeMornay) that much an annoyance?

Jarrod

nax37 • Aug 14, 2007, 07:46am •
Not that surprising, but tvguide.com is reporting that the show has been canceled.

slackey • Aug 14, 2007, 07:51am •
I thought I made it clear why I gave it a D. The show didn't live up to any of its promises. Nothing really happened in the episode. There were some nice moments but nothing happened to explain anything. I like the offbeat nature but come on we have to get at least a crumb here and there. Expanding the wierdness doesn't count for explaining what's happening. I don't need all the answers in season one but some answers to make me want to keep coming back are required. There's a lot to like about this series but when you only get 10 episodes in a season you have to get to the point, or at least one of them, a little quicker.

rileymartin • Aug 14, 2007, 09:36am •
I've been commenting all along that it would be cancelled. I want the nine hours of my life back that I wasted watching this!

I kept coming back waiting for answers and got zip. Were the writers on acid or what?

cso1982 • Aug 14, 2007, 10:25am •
I feel like I got duped by this show. Kind of like the creators/writers tried to see if they could get an audience to watch something that was not going anywhere as their own personal inside joke. Something similar to the concept of The Producers. I enjoyed the show this summer. It was different. The acting was top notch. But I needed more than just a parade and the return of John and Shawnie as a reward for watching. Honestly though, what the hell?!?

cso1982 • Aug 14, 2007, 10:27am •
whoops double post

Jakester • Aug 14, 2007, 10:27am •
But we did get some answers. And you missed it -- Linc *did* understand (at least more than anyone else) what John was saying, hence his speech.

Additionally, the sequence with the car dealer -- I'm pretty sure that the words were that of John's father. Listen to what he says.

The show as a whole, left a lot of things unanswered and yet more open to interpretation, but on the JFC page of HBO's site, there's an essay that will probably help you understand the show, or at least the finale, a bit more.

jedibanner • Aug 14, 2007, 12:16pm •
CNN reported today the show has been cancelled so, regardless of how we felt about the show, it's done, it's over.

Clownpuncher • Aug 14, 2007, 05:28pm •
Man am i glad this is over... i for some reason wanted to keep giving it a chance and watched the hole year but it just never happened.

Talk about a dumb boring show.

We lost deadwood and got this????? im guessing HBO probably won't give him another chance but then again who knows

I watched flight of the comadores for a couple seconds but it looked worse than this so i hope HBO does come up with some good programing




jon41380 • Aug 18, 2007, 05:04pm •
It's called Flight of the Conchords, and I think it's genious. I'm having a hard time getting into JFC. I've watched the first two episodes and have the rest on my DVR. The news that it got cancelled makes me even more reluctant to finish it. HBO has great programming. They've given us shows like The Sopranos, Carnivale, Six Feet Under, Extras, Flight of the Conchords, Entourage, Rome, Big Love and Deadwood. Although they screwed us over with Carnivale, it can't really be said that they don't provide good programming. Back to JFC, I did like the second half of the second episode, I like the cast but it feels like nothing is really happening, it just wanders.

1
Login to post a comment!