Television Review


JOHN FROM CINCINNATI: His Visit: Day One

By: Stephen Lackey
Review Date: Tuesday, June 12, 2007

I was a big fan of Deadwood, and can’t wait to see the movies that will tie that series up. When I found out the John from Cincinnati was the creation of Milch, I was intrigued. From the ads, I was never able to really figure out what this story was to be about and now after watching the premiere, I still really don’t know. The entire episode is more about character setup than story arc or direction, and in fact there’s at least one character that we see but we don’t learn anything about her in this episode. She does apparently get to do something more than stand around in the next episode based on the previews. 
 
The thing is the cast is huge, and none of the characters appear to be cookie cutter, every actor on the series must be thrilled because all of the characters are complex and offbeat. They feel like characters ripped from classic literature and given a new life and slightly skewed motivations similar to the way the Coen brothers brought characters from classic literature to life in O’ Brother Where Art Thou. Mitch Yost is an ex pro surfer that had to leave the sport early after an injury to his knee. He still surfs, but only in the early morning when no one is around to see. One morning after surfing he passes a man who says “Mitch Yost should get back in the game”. He tells the guy to mind his own business and he keeps walking also passing a shady promoter who wants to sign his grandson as a pro surfer. Yost tells him to go f@#ck himself. He doesn’t think much of it as he rinses himself off standing behind his truck. He glances down and notices that he is levitating. He decides that he has a brain tumor until his drug addicted son also sees him levitating, so the hallucinations theory is quickly blown.
 
This story centers on the Yost family and what could have been a surfing empire were it not for a series of failures. Mitch blew out his leg, and then his son became addicted to drugs. Mitch’s wife still has hope for her grandson, which she and Mitch has custody of, a 13 year old prodigy. Mitch doesn’t want him involved fearing that he will end up like the rest of them bitter or on drugs. There is quite a bevy of characters backing up the Yosts including Bill (O’Neil), a friend of the family who is also a retired cop. He seems to have some real mental problems and now just stays at home and tends to birds. In one scene, one of his birds is dead and comes back to life when he and the youngest Yost touches it. Luis Guzman plays the caretaker of a run down motel that just got sold to a man who won at the lottery. The only connection to the main story seems to be that the drug addicted Yost has been squatting in one of the rooms. 
 
So, this strange guy John that says that Mitch should get back into the game finds his way among all of these quirky characters. “Some things he knows and some things he doesn’t” but he does always seem to have whatever is needed at any given time in one of his pockets. He’s obviously there to deliver a message to these characters and to help them find there way out of the downward spiral that the Yost family and all the other characters are in. That’s really the entire story that the writers give us in this episode. In the end all of the characters do find their way to being connected with even the guy who buys the motel nearly shooting everyone when he discovers that his squatter is in fact a guy that beat him with a broom when they were in school together.
 
I don’t have much of a clue where this series is going but the characters are fascinating and the episode was beautifully shot and assembled. I found myself questioning the ages of the family because Rebecca De Mornay and Bruce Greenwood don’t look old enough to be grandparents (and in fact barely are old enough) of a 13 year old. I don’t know how well this series will do with mainstream viewers based on the first episode because there’s not one normal character in the bunch, the dialogue and story can feel a bit self important at times and not much actually happens in the episode other than meeting all the characters. So everyone’s weird, that’s a plus in my book, I just hope they start going somewhere soon. As far as John, we’ve seen his type of character many times before, sometimes he’s an angel, sometimes he’s an alien. I hope Milch came up with something unique for him this go around. So, far it made me laugh and it got me intrigued, so I’m in for now.


More Content By Stephen Lackey
SONS OF ANARCHY: Pilot
(Friday, September 5, 2008)
PRISON BREAK: Scylla/Breaking and Entering
(Thursday, September 4, 2008)
TV Wasteland: What to Watch this Fall, or Not?
(Monday, September 1, 2008)
TV Wasteland: CBS Knows Best, or Do They?
(Monday, August 25, 2008)
BURN NOTICE: Rough Seas
(Friday, August 22, 2008)
EUREKA: I Do Over
(Thursday, August 21, 2008)
PRIMEVAL
(Tuesday, August 19, 2008)
TV Wasteland: Ron Moore Goes Virtual
(Monday, August 18, 2008)
EUREKA: Best in Faux
(Thursday, August 14, 2008)
TV Wasteland: Torchwood Audio Episode?
(Monday, August 11, 2008)
Comments/Responses
1
rileymartin • Jun 12, 2007, 10:12am •
I tired REALLY hard to stay awake while watching this. I was unable to however. I'm sure I'm not the only one. At least Al Bundy landed another gig. For 13 weeks at least.

nax37 • Jun 12, 2007, 11:29am •
It was ok, but maybe it should have been longer. I feel that after a pilot episode, I should be able to give a better description of what the show is about. For now, all I've got is "Well, there's a family of surfers and a weird guy."

MrJawbreakingEquilibrium • Jun 12, 2007, 06:17pm •
I don't know. I thought it was good and what it did show just gave you more answers to look forward to. That's not a bad quality in a show. As long as they don't drag the question for six seasons. Lost? Anyone.

nax37 • Jun 13, 2007, 06:34am •
Except, even Lost's worst episode is way more compelling than this episode was. I'm not saying John from Cincinnati is a bad show, just that the premiere episode could have used a little more...something. I'll watch the next few, give it a shot, but if this had premiered in the fall when there are more options, I probably wouldn't.

1
Login to post a comment!