Comments -

All karas1's Comments

Showing items 2,871 - 2,880 of 3,175
<<  <  285 286 287 288 289 290 291 >  >>  

10 Reasons to be Worried About STAR TREK (Article) - 5/7/2009 12:03:48 PM

"Another thing if most of you guys are so smart and talented why are none of you directing or writing Star Trek... None of you are creative enough to pull it off...Could any of you have done any better."

Probably because we are not hollywood writers or directors.  This does not mean we can't have an oppinion about movies.  If I go to a resturant and do not enjoy my meal I don't have to be a professional chef to know the food sucked.  Neither do you.  We just have to be customers who want good value for our money, wether in a meal or a movie.

10 Reasons to be Worried About STAR TREK (Article) - 5/7/2009 4:12:52 AM

>Everybody is a critic. Fanboys bashed the Star Wars prequels and then went to the toy store to compete with kids for the toys.<

Not all of us who hated the Star Wars prequels went to the toy store.  Some of us saw the films, hated them, and then tried to forget we ever saw them because they disgraced the memory of the first 3 films that we loved so much.

As for the new BSG, I liked it and I watched it.  It was a quality show.  But it was so different from the original it could have been a different show.  I wish it HAD been a different show.  If they had done the exact same show but used different names for the characters it would have been just as good.

I still haven't forgiven them for making Starbuck a woman.

And I really don't wat to see these things happening to Star Trek.

Kara S

NBC Announces Pick-ups for 2009-2010 (Article) - 5/5/2009 12:16:03 PM

snallygaster, you are not the only one at Mania who follows Medium.

Dollhouse Hangs up the Barbie Clothes (Article) - 5/5/2009 4:17:20 AM

None of you watch Reaper on Tuesdays?  Why not?

NBC Announces Pick-ups for 2009-2010 (Article) - 5/5/2009 4:07:59 AM


Executive producer Peter Berg (NBC's "Friday Night Lights") delivers "Trauma," the first high-octane medical drama series to live exclusively in the field where the real action is. Like an adrenaline shot to the heart, "Trauma" is an intense, action-packed look at one of the most dangerous medical professions in the world: first responder paramedics.


Does nobody remember the 70's show, Emergency, about paramedics?  As I remember, it was an entertaining show.  But the fact that it exists means that Trauma is not the first.

10 Reasons to be Worried About STAR TREK (Article) - 5/4/2009 12:45:44 PM

Maybe I should tell you a little bit about myself.  I'm a middle aged woman and I was inducted into the cult of Trek by my mother who held me on her lap to watch it when it originally broadcast.  I was 2.  I'm a card carying Trekkie.

I grew up with Kirk and Spock as part of my life.  We would watch Star Trek every evening during dinner for years and my brother and I could recite the dialogue verbatim and could tell you which episode it was from watching 30 seconds of the teaser.

When the movies came out my family saw them all in the theater.  When TNG came out I saw it at college.  Some like minded friends and I made a party out of it every week.

Star Trek is special to me.  The characters are part of my family.  Sneer if you like, you probably have something special to you too.

What is it?  Is it Star Wars?  Imagine that Star Wars is remade with new actors and instead of meeting for the first time at the bar in Mos Eisley, Luke and Han grew up together and dated the same girl in high school.

Is it Batman?  Imagine they make a Batman movie but decide the name Bruce isn't cool and rename the character Cosmo.

Imagine that the fictional universe that you love is being remade by someone who is unfamilliar with it or doesn't like it and has stated that he will "improve" it and make it different for a new generation who have different likes and values.  I don't care how great his other projects are, you are going to be very uneasy that he's going to screw it up.  That he's going to make changes that don't need to be made just for the sake of being different.  That this new movie will have the same name but be nothing like show that you remember.

Perhaps it will be good.  But I'm not holding my breath.  It may even be a good movie but if it's too different from what I loved about the original, it won't be Star Trek to me.  

Kara S

Box Office is OBSESSED (Article) - 4/27/2009 3:55:09 AM

Like wessmith, I grew up on ST reruns.  My family watched them every night over dinner and we could all repeat the dialogue by heart.

I'm sure that  people who aren't as familliar with the old series and think of William Shatner as "that guy from Boston Legal" will love it to death.  But Abrams seems, from what I've read, to have a kind of "continuity is for chumps" attitude.  From what I've read the story will contradict established continuity and no matter how great the movie is objectively, for me it will suck.

6 Superheroes Who Completely Lost Their Shit (Article) - 4/25/2009 11:42:27 AM

Arcade was always one of my favorite Marvel villians.  He knew enough not to take himself so damn seriously all the time.  Pluss, he was kind of cute.

17 AGAIN Topples Cranky Report (Article) - 4/23/2009 12:29:49 PM

a)Why does it need to be rebooted?  To be honest, rather than rebooting it I would prefer that there were no more stories about Kirk and company.  I don't want to see someone other than William Shatner playing Kirk.  He's not James Bond that the character can be recast ad infinitum.

b) Time travel and altering timelines is a cop out.  If you are going to go that route then nothing matters.  Kirk and Spock met for the first time when they served  on the Enterprise, no, they first met at the academy, no, they were in kindergarten together, no, they were born in the same hospital and switched at birth (but Spock is several decades older than Kirk, doesn't matter, it can be retconned away).

I suppose that if ST:TOS isn't such a big part of your childhood as it is mine and Kirk is just another character to you it doesn't matter.  But for me it's a cultural touchstone. 

And great movies don't get stale.  The Wizard of Oz doesn't need to be remade.  Just watch the original again, it's still great.  ST:TOS is the same.  The FX may not pack the punch they once did, but the stories are still great and still have meaning.


Heroes: I Am Sylar (Article) - 4/23/2009 12:14:49 PM

I think the reason they are giving Sylar so many emotional problems is because otherwise, he would be too powerful.  If he actually had his act together he would be unstopable.  That being said, I found his dialogues with himself as his mother very tiresome.  They should just have him lose all his powers and have to start collecting them from the beginning again like they apparently did to Peter.

What did Nathan think would happen when he confronted Syalar?  I don't think he did much thinking.  He was offended to have Sylar impersonate him and flew off the handle.  It's not too surprising.  Nathan isn't very bright.  For most of the series he's let his parents take turns leading him around by the nose.  Whenever he's tried to take independant action it's gone horribly wrong.  Luckily for Claire, she seems to have inherrited her mother's IQ instead of his.

What happened to Molly?  Weren't Mohinder and Matt coparenting her in season 2?  You'd think that Hunter guy could get a lot of milage out of someone who could locate anybody anywhere in the world.

As for our beloved columnust, I agree that a certain amount of objectivity is required.  That's why we bother to read an official review instead of unsolicited rants on a message board.  If he hates the show that much, someone else should review it. 



Date Joined: October 3, 2006