Supernatural: As Time Goes By Review -

Arrow Review

Mania Grade: B

0 Comments | Add


Rate & Share:


Related Links:



  • Episode: As Time Goes By (Episode 12, Season 8)
  • Starring: Jared Padalecki, Jensen Ackles, Gil McKinney
  • Written By: Eric Kripke (creator), Adam Glass
  • Directed By: Serge Ladouceur
  • Network: The CW
  • Series:

Supernatural: As Time Goes By Review

A kiss is just a kiss

By Tim Janson     February 04, 2013

I mentioned last weeks about the two different types of Supernatural—the standard episodes and the lighter, humorous ones.  Maybe I should have made it three different types or at least call it 2A because time travel has been an oft-used plot device throughout the show’s eight seasons.  However, instead of Sam and Dean travelling through time here someone comes from their past…their paternal grandfather Henry Winchester.  Henry is seen in 1958 at a gentleman’s club about to be initiated into a secret order.  However when a demon named Abaddon kills the other members, Henry casts a spell to escape into the future, carrying a mysterious small box.

Henry had attempted to move forward in time to find his son John, Sam and Dean’s father, but since he is dead, the spell brought Henry to his grandsons instead.  Henry reveals a secret to the boys that COULD change the whole tenor of the show.  The boys were never meant to be hunters, they were meant to be “Men of Letters”, an order that gathers and safeguards all the secrets of magic and the supernatural, a kind of scholarly hermetic order.  The box that Henry carries contains a key to a vast storehouse of magical items and knowledge.  He asks the boys to take the box and toss it into something that will lock it away forever.  But before they can accomplish the task, Abaddon kidnaps Henry and tells the boys she will trade him for the key.

This episodes helps the boys, especially Dean, come to grips with the father issues they have.  John Winchester had always thought his father ran out on him when he was a kid.  Consequently Dean has now carried on this grudge.  But now he knows that Henry jumped forward into time and died before he could return home to his son.  

The boys also learn that their lives could have been much difference.  Hunters were meant to carry out the dirty work with the knowledge provided by the Men of Letters.  The key is what will the show do with this new information?  Will it just be discarded or will this change things for the Winchesters?  One important note is that the boys had not cast the box into whatever it was that was supposed to keep it safe from the demons at the end of the episode and this could certainly present a lot of new storylines for the boys to come.

I like the idea of there being a kind of yin and yang with the hunters and Men of Letters.  The episode also introduced a new and more powerful type of demon.  Abaddon is a Knight of Hell and can’t be killed with the standard demon dagger.  Will we see more demons of this type?


Showing items 1 - 0 of 0
egoist 2/4/2013 7:54:23 AM

 Solid  episode. Kind of shakes up a lot of the lore. Why not just jump to a point in time where John was still alive and hunting? BTdubs you mean different not difference in paragraph 4. Fix it real quick before anybody else sees.

digmapper 2/4/2013 8:15:34 AM

Maybe I saw a different episode but Henry didn't tell Sam and Dean to put the box into the place where the it would be safe, it was the sole survior of  Abaddon's attack in 1958, other than Henry and he only told Sam.  That was when Abaddon attacked, killed the old man and kidnapped Sam, not Henry. Great episode but the fact that Abaddon kidnapped Sam was important on how the show ended.

acidsquall73 2/4/2013 9:33:04 AM

It's awesome to think that they came up with a demon even more powerful than the Leviathans. At least that's the impression I get from the Abaddon. A Knight of Hell sounds pretty badass to me. And I seriously hope they revisit the Men of Letters thing later. I wonder if that's part why Sam can do some of the stuff he does. And Dean would be the brawn to his brain in this situation. Would bring the series around full-circle nicely, even more so than what was presented in this episode, which was awesome in itself.

invisioner 2/4/2013 9:57:23 AM

 I like the idea of it all, but some flub ups. If an angel is more or less equal to Lucifer (Michael, the archangel), than a knight of Hell can't be more powerful than a Leviathan, so Abaddon was a little confusing and a little sloppy in creation. 

Dean's pouty granddkid routine was poor. For someone who's time travelled, lived and tortured (and been tortured) in Hell, lived a year trapped in Purgatory, you would think he'd cut Henry slack. not a good character development, especially for how wholesome Henry acted. It would have been another thing if he had been a bigger, coarser jerk than John was, but he wasn't. I love Supernatural except for the character progression of Sam and Dean, the writers seem to always hit a reset button with their maturity that is lazy. they have been through so much, they should be beyond the petty whine-fests they seem to focus on to relate to younger audiences. How bout we grab onto other issues like an increasingly growing PTSD for all the crap they are going through, that would be interesting...

SarcasticCaveman 2/5/2013 1:22:58 AM

 I didn't think Abbadon was more powerful than leviathans...leviathans are ancient and primal...a demon, even a Knight of Hell, is still just a human soul that has been tortured and perverted. 



You must be logged in to leave a comment. Please click here to login.