TV Review

Send to a Friend



To: (email)


To: (name)


From: (name)


Message:



"Lost: Par Avion"

By: Stephen Lackey
Review Date: Friday, March 16, 2007

I’ll be honest with you, when I heard this was to be a Claire-centric episode I wasn’t so excited.  I like her well enough but she just isn’t figured that centrally into the series for me since the others took her baby, which was a story thread that just sort of came and went.  Finally this week, she gets some opportunity to be truly connected with the series again, and on top of that things progress nicely with the search for Jack leading to a pretty fantastic cliffhanger.  If you Tivo’d the episode, you may wanna check it out before you read this review. 

So, Claire has figured out a way, a long shot, of getting a message off the island.  For some reason she seems to know a lot about migratory birds and when she sees a flock of them fly above the island she knows they are tagged, and the tags will be checked.  With the help of Jin and Sun, she builds a trap to catch one of the birds.  Desmond scares the birds away just as she’s about to catch one and Charlie is reluctant to help.  Sensing that Charlie is lying to her again, she sends him away.  This bothered me right away because I though “Ok here we go with the on again off again Claire/Charlie thing.”  Speaking of that, hasn’t Claire let Charlie back in pretty quick after his nutty spell?  Anyway, this time Claire wasn’t about to let things slide.  She knows something is up with Charlie and Desmond and she is determined to get answers this time.  It could be a statement about how she has finally let herself care about Charlie or she could just be sick of the way these to whackos are acting.  She follows Desmond who knew right where to go to find a bird for Claire and she forces the truth out of him.  This leads to a commitment from Claire to help Charlie get through it.  Normally a story like the one Desmond tells her would be a hard pill to swallow but not considering their current situation and all the other strange things they’ve all seen. 

At the same time we are treated to a Claire back-story.  Seems like the writers of LOST have an affinity for the alt-kids as they’ve made at least three of the castaways this type of character.  Not that I’m complaining, I much prefer that to the metro-sexual men and model-ish women of series like the OC and most anything that airs on the WB.  So Claire has her hair jet black and she works in a tattoo and piercing establishment.  When we first see her she’s just been in a car accident that puts her mother in critical condition with only machines keeping her alive.  A stranger is footing the bills for all of the medical expenses.  Claire seems to be more surprised at this than her aunt, who’s a total b*tch by the way.  The stranger just so happens to be Jack’s daddy who decides to head down under for a visit.  It turns out, in one of the big twists in this episode, that Claire is the result of a fling he and her mother had.  So, that makes Claire and Jack half brother and sister.  Claire sends the good doctor away having never even gotten his name, so of course she has no reason to suspect her relationship with Jack.  Wouldn’t it have been amusing if Claire and Jack almost hooked up all Leia/Luke style in a previous episode?  This twist is a fun way to further connect two of the main cast and I hope it actually means something in the grand scheme of things.  Oh and it turns out that Claire spent a lot of time watching nature shows with her Mom while she visited her in the hospital.   


Claire writes a note to be attached to the bird and Charlie reads it over a montage of shots of various cast members doing what they do on the island.  I liked this little moment, it was a subtle emotional peak without being as heavy handed as Hurley’s musical montages used to be. 

The third part of the episode involves Freckles, Sayid, Locke, and Russo dragging the eye patch man along as they follow the map to the compound of “The Others”.  This segment is definitely the strongest and it features many tense moments, especially between Locke and Sayid.  We know that Locke may not want to leave the island and it’s clear from last episode and this one that he has his own agenda.  At one point when eye patch man is challenging the group he very nearly reveals Lock’s secret that he was paralyzed before crashing on the island.  The look on Locke’s face is both intense and hilarious.  I’ve been waiting for this secret to come out and this little tease was a ton of fun.  It’s obvious at this point that Locke knows that eye patch man has to die.  So when they reach an apparatus that they determine is an alarm system, Locke believes that he has the opportunity to take out eye patch man.  He pushes the eye patch man into the area of the alarm and some sort of invisible sonic signal kills the man right there on the spot.  Previous to that, Locke and Sayid argued over the destruction of the fire base and Locke tells him that it would have helped if Sayid had informed him that the base was in fact wired with explosives.  When the group decides to build a bridge across the alarm Sayid finds a block of C4 in Locke’s bag when he goes looking for the hatchet.  Sayid tells Locke that they’ll discuss his lies later.  I loved all the tenseness between Kate, Sayid, and Locke.  It’s also very intriguing to follow where Locke is going with his decisions.  It’s about time more came out about this character and it looks like that’s going to happen next week. 

In the final moments of the episode the group finally makes it to the subdivision of the Others.  When they see Jack running across a nicely manicured lawn, Kate instinctively wants to run to meet him but Sayid stops her.  It’s a good thing too because Jack was actually playing a little touch football!  This was a hell of a cliffhanger leading to many questions.  Has Jack given in to the Others for a trip home?  I don’t think so, but it’s there anyway. 

These three segment episodes are truly the way to go.  Last week and now this week both featured a main cast segment, a flashback, and a story arc segment.  I really appreciated that the main cast segment this week wasn’t just comedy relief.  I do like the humor but there are some opportunities for more character development in the main cast and we were given a taste of that this week.  The question remains: was the flashback an important twist or just cotton candy?  I don’t know the answer to that yet but I really enjoyed the ride.



More Content By Stephen Lackey
Fandango Logo
Comments/Responses
1
DarkJedi • Mar 16, 2007, 03:09am •
As I said in our Lost forum....Yes, that's right Stephen and fellow maniacs, we have a whole Forum dedicated to the show of Lost....Use it.

As I was saying.....I'm not much of a Claire fan...and not much of a Charlie fan...

Still, the last minute of this episode has one of the best endings ever for the Lost series.

I'm sorry but if I was Jack, I would be happy too when I was welcomed to the neighborhood. I would take all the appliances and all the luxuries and say "Screw you to 'living on the beach".


jedibanner • Mar 16, 2007, 07:46am •
This one was one of the best season's episode ever. That cliffhanger at the end, really well made. I can't wait for next week.

I am part of those who believe Jack is all doing this for his friends on the island, he's not joining the others I'm sure....he has to!!

From the previews of next week's episode, we do learn what is Lock's secret agenda and I got to admit, it makes perfect sense...next week, NOBODY will want to miss that episode.

snallygaster • Mar 16, 2007, 08:00am •
Terrific episode. I'm also not a huge Claire fan, but she seems to be much to under-utilized, so it's nice to see her brought to the forefront.

Unfortunately, I stumbled across the big secret of the episode somewhere, so it wasn't a huge revelation for me - I hate spoilers, even when I come across them accidentally.

It's also refreshing to see an episode where somebody is actually thinking of ways to get off the island again.

The ending was a classic Lost twist!

I'm looking forward to next week, I'm really interested in seeing what's been making Locke do the things he's been doing lately...

Freddyfred27 • Mar 16, 2007, 08:13am •
Ok , hear me out real quick,,,
Jacks old man has 3 kids...tell me if im wrong.
1st we have jack..duh..
2nd we have Charlie's brothers's wife's kid..
You following me?
There was an episode in the second season where where jacks pops goes to charlies brothers house and demands to see his baby..
Now.. this led me to belive that Charlie's Brother's Wife's kid was fathered by jacks pops.
Now is this crazy?? or does any 1 else remember that?
Then now we have Claire as the 3rd child.

kisskissbangbang • Mar 16, 2007, 11:42am •
Pretty sure that was Claire's Aunt's house -- where Claire was staying after the car accident -- that Jack's father showed up at with Ana Lucia in season 2 -- and not anything to do with Charlie or his brother. I think it will be interesting if the other's reveal to Jack and Claire that they are related... I'm sure that the man with the list would know this. Also, we never did find out what happened with Jack's dad's body that disapeared from its coffin in season one... of course, the bears could have dragged it off. LOL.

On a side note, I love the way all the episodes of this show fit together like pieces to a puzzle so that every episode is important to the next one. I love the show's sense of foreshadowing, setup and payoff... like how stuff mentioned in season one gets answered in season three... it makes it feel connected and really shows that the showrunners know what they are doing and have planned the show out and aren't just making it up as they go along. And I love that in the end Lost will be one long, sprawling saga rather than a bunch of throw away episodes or even separate seasons strewn together -- which is the safe way to go these days for serialized shows without any balls.

scoundrel • Mar 16, 2007, 03:33pm •
I want to believe Jack is playing ball with the Others to help his friends on the beach because I like Jack. And maybe he is.

But the thing that scares me is that in the book Lord of the Flies, the antagonist's name is Jack. The writers are too smart to not do anything with that (they've already made several little meta-nods to the book) and it wouldn't surprise me if Jack went to the dark side.

Oh. And I'll have to check those lost forums.

Captmathman • Mar 16, 2007, 03:43pm •
Were these recent shows reedited to fit three stories together, when they had originally been storyboarded to be part of two story episodes? If so, this may be the greatest editing room job in history.
I love the pace and the story again. Keep it coming. I'm glad to be hooked!

Merin • Mar 16, 2007, 04:49pm •
This was a great episode, worthy of an A rating, and one of the better ones this season.

I don't care if Lost isn't the "water cooler" show anymore, I still enjoy it.

mbeckham1 • Mar 26, 2007, 11:15am •
Great episode. I couldn't beleive I saw Jack's dad in that room.

Anyone know if there's something significant about Sawyer reading Ayn Rand while Charlie read Claire's letter. The camera made point of showing the authors name, so I wondered if there was some kind of symbolism I was missing.

1
Login to post a comment!