Mania Review: The Avengers -

Mania Grade: A-

115 Comments | Add


Rate & Share:


Related Links:



  • Starring: Robert Downey, Jr., Chris Evans, Chris Hemsworth, Tom Hiddleston, Mark Ruffalo, Samuel L. Jackson, Jeremy Renner, Scarlett Johansson and Clark Gregg
  • Written by: Zak Penn and Joss Whedon
  • Directed by: Joss Whedon
  • Studio: Paramount Pictures
  • Rating: PG-13
  • Run Time: 142 mins.
  • Series:

Mania Review: The Avengers

It's here at last. Is it worth the hype?

By Rob Vaux     May 02, 2012

 And here it sits, after four years of official build-up and an equal number of franchises created largely with this outcome in mind. The Avengers feels unprecedented in its ambition, but the very fact that it exists at all is a minor miracle. What if Thor had tanked or Downey quibbled about his price or Disney’s purchase of Marvel ruined the whole deal? What if they handed the project to some studio hack instead of a director with both talent and respect for the characters? What if fate had simply rendered it a cacophonous bore? What if any of those things had happened and dashed all our fanboy hopes to pieces?

Everybody breathe. They didn’t.

The Avengers fulfills all of those promises handed down since Sam Jackson broke into Tony Stark’s pad: a superhero mash-up that merges seven different good guys and five movies’ worth of backstory into a throwdown for the ages. They do this kind of thing on the comics page all the time, and a few movies have tried it before (notably Universal’s later “classic” monster flicks like House of Frankenstein). But to see those possibilities rendered so well on this scale leaves one a little bit in awe. It expertly captures the magic that Stan Lee and Jack Kirby created with their original comics, pulled from numerous disparate sources to create a hugely satisfying whole.

Credit goes primarily to director Joss Whedon, a man who I have been less than kind to in the past but whose talents are uniquely suited to this project. He works exceptionally well with ensembles – giving every character their due and creating balance where cacophony may have reigned – and his abiding wit brings lightness to the film’s epic scope. He also knows how to temper his ambitions with realistic goals. The Avengers doesn’t attempt to make profound points or attain a deeper resonance the way, say, The Dark Knight did. Instead, it aims for popcorn fun at its finest: sprinkled with liberal character development but making blockbuster entertainment its top priority.

We also have to give props to Tom Hiddleston – one of many standouts in the cast – whose sinister Loki sets the straightforward plot in motion. In that sense, The Avengers most closely resembles a sequel to Thor, picking up where that film left off and following the trickster god’s plans for revenge. So grand are his schemes – involving a race of invading aliens and the all-powerful Tesseract Cube – that one hero alone cannot stop him. So SHIELD Director Nick Fury Jackson calls upon a whole six-pack to shut him down: wise-cracking Iron Man (Robert Downey, Jr.), stoic Thor (Chris Hemsworth), earnest Captain America (Chris Evans) and volatile Hulk (Mark Ruffalo), as well as SHIELD agents Black Widow (Scarlett Johansson) and Hawkeye (Jeremy Renner) to round out the team.

Naturally, they struggle to get along, even in the face of Armageddon. Whedon wisely frames their bickering within the context of Loki’s schemes, bringing substance to the mayhem and emphasizing the villain’s status as a fermenter of chaos. Even so, it takes Hiddleston’s force of personality to stand as a viable threat in the face of all those heroes, and the actor does a masterful job. Loki’s smarter than the lot of them, and even in those moments when he seems to be down – like a brief imprisonment on SHIELD’s nerdgasm-inducing helicarrier – we get the sense that he has them all right where he wants them.

The good guys, of course, need to put their fussin’ and feudin’ behind them if they want to stop him. It forms an agreeable arc upon which Whedon can trick out all of his mayhem, but it also allows for the sorts of little moments that endear us to the characters. Here, Marvel honcho Kevin Feige’s evil genius really bears fruit. All those earlier Marvel movies gave every principle the time and respect to develop their own personality. Whedon simply finds interesting ways to let them clash, interact and grow.  The Captain’s straight-laced honesty, for instance, initially bugs Stark to no end, but as time goes on, he comes to understand it and even emulate it after a fashion.

With the confidence of their pervious performances, the cast emerges with flying colors. Only Hawkeye and the Widow feel a little short-changed, not through any fault of the actors but because we haven’t had nearly enough time to get to know them. Ruffalo’s Hulk, on the other hand, almost steals the show. His Bruce Banner has attained a quiet Zen state: wary of what he calls “the other guy” but accepting that reality as a part of his life. He easily makes The Avengers the best Hulk movie we’ve yet seen, with a trio of brilliant moments that stand out amid the highlights.

And as for said highlights… they’re enough to send the most hardened fan into arias of joy.  Whedon invests the various throwdowns – Thor vs. Hulk! Hulk v s. Widow! Cap vs. Thor vs. Iron Man! – with the enthusiastic glee of a true aficionado. Individual frames look like they were pulled straight out of Kirby’s sketchbook,  from Loki standing atop a skyscraper while his army decimates New York to the Hulk’s spectacular mid-air catch of his plummeting teammate. Whedon’s gift for dialogue and the increasingly iconic visages of the actors keep the characters in the forefront. Even smaller figures like Clark Gregg’s Agent Coleson get their due, a testament to the director’s outstanding juggling act on display.

It was long road to this spot, but the results speak for themselves. The Avengers mines the collective goodwill of the Marvel nation to impressive effect, starting the summer off with a proper flourish and rewarding our patience in the most satisfying manner possible. Nolan will have his chance to bring some gravitas to comic-dom in July. For now, it’s a chance kick up our heels and celebrate, thanks to this first-rate example of what a Hollywood blockbuster can do. 


Showing items 1 - 10 of 115
1 2 3 4 >  >>  
redslayer 5/2/2012 12:19:03 AM

I'm so there !!!  I just hope it doesn't disappoint as hinted by some overseas moviegoers


goatartist 5/2/2012 12:24:46 AM

 Great Review Rob. After that overgenerous grade for Cabin in the Woods however, I should be a little skeptical, but I have a feeling the A- is well earned. Bring it on!

CrazyCEO 5/2/2012 12:33:20 AM

"Instead, it aims for popcorn fun at its finest"

Couldn't have said it better myself, oh wait I did :)

SmokingFrog77 5/2/2012 1:47:38 AM

Only complaint is that Powers Boothe wasn't rockin' a FEARSOME moustache :P  

Best lines: "Oh, that's what it does..." " He's adopted" and "Puny god".

Fantastic movie, speaking as an overseas-er!  Great review too, Rob :)

Dazzler 5/2/2012 4:44:56 AM

142 minutes.  Surprising they did not cut for more asses in seats in short amounts of time. 

Dodgyb2001 5/2/2012 5:06:17 AM

They don't have to. People I never would have thought would be caught dead in a comic book movie are gushing for this movie. I really hopes this makes a billion dollars because Marvel deserve it for making it happen. It's funny, smart, and awesome.

"He's got all your cigarette cards you know"

wish 5/2/2012 5:12:19 AM

I love it when a favorite director gets his due.  I loved Sam Raimi from the 80's and lined up for all his films until he finally got the big break with Spiderman.  Now everyone will know Joss Whedon!!!!  I know he's been around for a long time and obviously Buffy and Angel were huge but he still hadn't hit that houshould name level. 

Well I think this'll do it........

That's a pretty consistent review, it couldn't be happening better!! 

lazarus 5/2/2012 5:31:13 AM

 Saw it last night, and it was AWESOME. That is all. 


Going again at Midnight on Thurs.

ElBaz13 5/2/2012 5:33:41 AM


It's seems the general consensus. 93% on Rotten Tomatoes. Not many negative reviews.

This should be a wild ride. Only 2 days to go....

dalgoda 5/2/2012 5:50:31 AM

I'm still pinching myself that this is actually happening.  I never thought I would see an Avengers or JLA movie be made, but in 2 days I will be sitting in a theater watching one.  

1 2 3 4 >  >>  


You must be logged in to leave a comment. Please click here to login.