Mania Review: Transformers: Dark of the Moon -

Mania Grade: C

151 Comments | Add


Rate & Share:


Related Links:



  • Starring: Shia LaBeouf, Josh Duhamel, Tyrese Gibson, Jon Turturro, John Malkovich, Frances McDormand, Peter Cullen and Leonard Nimoy
  • Written by: Ehren Kruger
  • Directed by: Michael Bay
  • Studio: Paramount Pictures
  • Rating: PG-13
  • Run Time: 154 minutes
  • Series:

Mania Review: Transformers: Dark of the Moon

More than meets the eye?

By Rob Vaux     June 29, 2011

Transformers: Dark of the Moon
© Paramount Pictures/Robert Trate

 Before we begin, a word of clarity. The “C” on this review doesn’t actually reflect a grade. It stands for “critic proof.” The notion of actually evaluating this… this thing that has arrived in our midst is patently absurd. Do we look at a tidal wave and say “well, it gets a 6 out of 10, but full marks for upending that building?” Do we judge tornadoes based on the quality and quantity of wreckage on display? Those things aren’t criticized; they’re endured.  So it is with Transformers: Dark of the Moon, a pop culture force of nature that lives by its own set of rules. To pretend otherwise insults everyone involved.

While we’re at it, here’s something for my fellow critics to keep in mind: it’s easy to talk about how films lack heart, how they need more compelling characters, and how their narratives need to reflect some aspect of the human condition. This is not that movie. If you want that movie, put The King’s Speech in your Netflix queue. This one involves giant robots pounding each other into scrap metal, and if you honestly walk in expecting anything else, you deserve whatever happens to you.

The problem with Dark of the Moon, as with the other two Transformers pictures, is that the critics aren’t the only ones who think it should involve human beings. Director Michael Bay does too. And he has absolutely no idea how human beings really act, think or feel. They don’t interest him at all; not when there’s civic landmarks to destroy or national I.Q. levels to lower. And yet he insists on packing far too much of this film with people. Talking. About dull, pointless shit with no freaking robots anywhere. We can handle the crass sexism, the horrendous racial stereotypes, the toilet humor and the action scenes that make no logical sense. That’s part of the package. But whatever you do Michael, please don’t show us any more scenes about Sam Witwicky’s (Shia LaBeouf) job woes, or why his woman (Rosie Huntington-Whiteley) doesn’t understand him. It’s just cruel.

Yet for the first hour, that’s largely what we get. The fact that Witwicky hangs out with Optimus Prime (voiced by Peter Cullen) and has saved the world twice – as he keeps reminding us in increasingly shrill tones – hasn’t translated into a viable job. Instead, he lives with his girlfriend (a sexpot museum curator who differs from Megan Fox’s sexpot grease monkey in no discernable way) and struggles through humiliating interviews while his robot buddies are out hunting down Decepticons. He also gets another helping of awkward sex talk from his parents, with some jealous exchanges with his girl’s boss (Patrick Dempsey) thrown in for good measure.

Show of hands: who wants to watch any of that? Better yet, who wants to see that interrupt scenes with robots on the moon and new Decepticon killers and an ancient Autobot genius (voiced by Leonard Nimoy) who may herald the end of the world as we know it? Hey, let’s break away from Prime and his buddies kicking ass to get another “family meeting” from Sam and his parents! It’ll be cool! I mean, nothing says summer movie more than the trials and travails of a young man who struggles with feelings of inadequacy and just wants a place to call- zzzzzzzz….

Admittedly, the overstuffed human cast features a few diamonds in the rough: specifically, Ken Jeong, Alan Tudyk, John Malkovich and Frances McDormand. The film tosses them to us like life preservers at a drowning man, and they keep the interminable “plot” elements from driving us totally around the bend. And once we get down to the real purpose of the exercise, the visual effects retain their usual high level of quality. We can tell the combatants apart this time, and many of the money shots actually show a little flair for a change. Dark of the Moon also makes excellent use of 3D, with a depth of field that excites the eye (especially if you see it on IMAX) and a refreshing lack of the darkness that usually accompanies the format.

If that were all there was, it might be enough. Sadly, it adds up to a comparatively small percentage of the actual running time. For the remainder, we get more off-color jokes (Jeong’s character is named Wang; get it?), appallingly bad improvisation, and exploitative shots of Huntington-Whiteley’s ass. Even Bay’s signature jingoism gets screwed up, as various human soldiers (including Tyrese Gibson’s Sergeant Epps) overtly tuck tail without the Autobots to help them. Considering how heavily the screenplay emphasizes our need to believe in ourselves, and considering that military porn is par for the course in these movies, Bay’s inability to follow through on his own stated philosophy is truly sad.

And that, in the end, finally dooms the picture. Dark of the Moon doesn’t live by the terms its detractors set, and that’s one thing. But it doesn’t live by its own terms either, and that’s something else entirely. It lacks the courage of its convictions, and can’t follow through on the appallingly amoral spectacle that remains the only criteria worth applying to it. In the face of such failings, I submit a challenge to the director. Next movie, I just want two-and-a-half hours of explosions. No dialogue, no context, no plot. Just things blowing up in an amusing way over and over again. I dare you to do it. I double dog dare you. Only then will your ethos truly reach its zenith and whatever bizarre art form you’re practicing become fully manifest.  Until that day, you’re just applying half-measures… of which Dark of the Moon is the latest example. 


Showing items 1 - 10 of 151
1 2 3 4 >  >>  
raa2001 6/29/2011 1:00:06 AM

 and this movie is still gonna make a megaton of cash...

SarcasticCaveman 6/29/2011 1:07:14 AM

Better grade than what this Michael Bay hater expected, but then again, Thor got an A- and Green Lantern got a C-...don't really trust grades on here...that is, I doubt this movie is worthy of a C.  Me and a buddy take turns paying for movies...I'll see it if it's his turn to pay.

ActionMovieGod 6/29/2011 1:31:18 AM

Im sorry its gotta be said.Rob your a fucking idiot that movie was amazing!! Its gotta be the best ACTION movie ive ever seen far as a climax goes..The last time i saw a movie with a ending like that was the last matrix say it deserves a easy A.In my book stor line was pretty good also..Michael Bay has raised the bar Very high for all future movies this year and next...

kennynine 6/29/2011 1:40:44 AM

They should hire Michael Bay to direct "The Rock 2", and when he is filming on Alcatraz, lock him in a cell and throw away the key. This guy is a friggin moron.

I liked the first Transformers but expected much better. The second one looked good but the story was terrible, full of plot holes and dumn annoyin CHARACTERS.

I just watched TF3 in 3d Imax. Some of the action scenes looked breathtaking and were pretty sick, but again, there was no good story to tie it all together. Again, the story had tons of plot holes. Again, there were a half dozen annoying characters including 2 stupid robots (not the twins, but just as dumb). Again, I left disappointed and felt cheated. The idiocy in this movie has Bay's hand prints all over it. And I have liked some of his movies. Now, I wish he would stop making movies for good. At Least leave the Transformers alone. You decimated them and left the next director with a pile if shit to fix. Reboot is the only way to salvage these mess of movies.

WTF is up with the Ferrari autobot? He has an Itallian accent. The green wrecker has an Irish accent. Are they really fighting for the US, or getting culturaly aquanted with Italy and Ireland. Robots with accents that have lived here for 4 years. Stupidity. And so much more ;(

raa2001 6/29/2011 2:23:54 AM

 Well, either way I'm still going to see it. I want to see giant robots tear shit up.  Although, I will hate that Bay had to include more stupid robots.  The twins were a disaster in the last one.

Darkknight2280 6/29/2011 4:12:40 AM

ITS A MOVIE ABOUT GIANT FUCKING ROBOTS FIGHTING EACH OTHER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! WTF Do you people want? lol I could give 2 shits about Shia ladouches character or any other human being in the movies! They could have replaced them all with cardboard cut outs for all i care!! Whaaa Whaaa Character development...whaaaa whaaa i want a deeper story!..How bout STFU and go watch Dark Knight or Braveheart or some random Coen Brothers movie and leave us alone with your whining about all that as far as a movie about ginat robots killing each other!!

Cant wait to see this friday in Imax 3D!

Darkknight2280 6/29/2011 4:14:24 AM

Sarcastic Caveman..i hope your not trying to say that Green Lantern was better than Thor?!

ObiWannaJones 6/29/2011 5:01:11 AM

Shia deserves and Academy Award for his dramatic, Shakespearean take on such a complicated character . . .


SgtTechCom 6/29/2011 5:01:54 AM

Anyone who didn't like this movie is a dam fool haha, Seriously it was incrediable Bay is the Action Master.

Totally fun and a great pop corn hang out with your friends enjoy a lil death and destruction time.

I don't know why too many people try to read into these movies and expect something alot more.

Get a grip

Green Lantern sucked - Thor was ok but not great.

Captain America will knock both of them back to the stone age tho \m/

ultrazilla2000 6/29/2011 5:16:54 AM

Kennynine...Ferrari is an Italian made car, understanding why they jokingly made the Autobot speak with an Italian accent shouldn't be that difficult to grasp!  And as shown in Revenge of the Fallen, the Autobots battle Decepticons across the globe (remember the Hong Kong opening?), so who's to say some Autobots wouldn't adopt various accents while arriving on Earth?  All it takes is a little imagination, people...

1 2 3 4 >  >>  


You must be logged in to leave a comment. Please click here to login.