"Monokuro Kinderbook" - Mania.com

Manga Review

Mania Grade: B

0 Comments | Add


Rate & Share:


Related Links:



  • Story and Art: Kan Takahama
  • Publisher: Ponent Mon
  • Rated: Unrated

"Monokuro Kinderbook"

By Janet Houck     January 06, 2007

Monokuro Kinderbook
© Ponent Mon

I make it a point to buy indie comics every once in a while. Call it my donation for the betterment of the arts or whatever, but I think it’s important to look beyond mainstream comics for something that challenges your visual sensibilities. Same thing when it comes to manga, although independent titles are still hard to find on bookshelves. 

Kan Takahama is well-known for her involvement in the Nouvelle Manga movement, and Monokuro Kinderbook is an excellent example. The Nouvelle Manga movement crosses the Franco-Belgian tradition of fantastical comics with Japanese “slice of life” manga, one of the genres less likely to be translated into English. Thus Nouvelle Manga is essentially alternative, slice of life manga from creators around the world (but usually specifically Japan and France), written in English and marketed around the world in Japan, Europe and the US. 

I’ll say this right now. Monokuro Kinderbook is a really depressing book, as I find many alternative books to be. Each chapter is a story unto its own, each one a slice of a rather depressing life full of regrets or of future tragedy in the making. The titular story, “Kinderbook: A Picture Story for Melancholic Girls,” is about child pornography, while “Over There, Beautiful Binary Suns” involves the real/mock suicide of a pair of illicit lovers. It’s ugly, but it’s life unblemished. None of the stories have any conclusion, but then again, that’s how life is. The characters are rough and fully fleshed, with loves and hates and the problems that they create.  

Takahama drops the reader in the middle of these lives without much explanation, if any at all. It’s like watching a TV drama twenty minutes into the show. A very disconcerting feeling, but sometimes, being uncomfortable is good. 

The art style is something of a jump for regular readers of mainstream manga, as Takahama could easily fit under the banner of an independent American comic company, such as IDW. Her style is sketchy, with faded watercolors and backgrounds that blend in, clashed by strong, dark black inkwork, filled in with wavy pencils. It’s a very distinct style. Either you will love it or hate it. 

With such a polarity, Monokuro Kinderbook is not a book for casual fans of manga or of comics, especially at the $18.00 price tag (normal for a book of this quality and size, but a little higher for folks used to the low cost of manga). If you want to try something entirely different from the other books on the manga shelves at the bookstore, or if you’re a fan of independent comics, this isn’t a bad place to start. Just be aware that Nouvelle Manga is exactly as it says: New Manga.


Be the first to add a comment to this article!


You must be logged in to leave a comment. Please click here to login.