Monster Manual V -

Toy Review

Mania Grade: A

5 Comments | Add


Rate & Share:


Related Links:



  • Written By: David Noonan
  • Art By: Various
  • Publisher: Wizards of the Coast
  • Pages: 224
  • Price: $34.95

Monster Manual V

By Tim Janson     September 04, 2007

"Monster Manual V" by David Noonan.
© Wizards of the Coast
I have always been of the opinion that when it comes to Dungeons & Dragons, there are two things you can never have enough of: Magic and Monsters! Part of this stems from my innate laziness. I’m simply not as motivated as I used to be to sit down and create my own monsters and magic items. It also stems from the fact that in the early days of Advanced Dungeons & Dragons, there simply were not a lot of supplements out there as I have mentioned before. The original Monster Manual was published in 1977. We didn’t get a new hardcover supplement until the Fiend Folio in 1981, which largely sucked. There were a few good monsters in the book I’d say no more than a dozen, twenty at best, were worthwhile. Contrast that with Wizards of the Coast publishing a new Monster Manual Supplement on the average of one every 12 – 18 months.
Monster Manual V has a good mix of monsters in terms of their CR. While Wizards of the Coast sometimes gets criticism for books being too high level, the new Manual has only eight monsters which rate a CR of 18 or higher, while there are 35 monsters which have a CR of 5 or lower. I think that’s a pretty good mix. As you would expect, many of the new monsters are subsets of a known monster type. For example there are five new demons, three new devils, two new golems, a number of new undead, and a new race of Mind Flayers which I will discuss momentarily.
In addition to new monsters, the book also gives us unique examples of existing monsters. One rather interesting inclusion is the information on Dragons of the Great Game. There is a game that Dragons play called Xorvintaal. I guess it’s sort of equivalent to the old board game Risk, except the game board is the entire world. Dragons vie for control of each other’s territories and dragon hoards. As exemplified by the unique examples included, it is played by Dragons of all alignments. The book gives us Chorranathau, an ancient Fang Dragon, and Morlicantha, a young adult Silver Dragon. There are also rules provided for creating these Xorvintaal Dragons for use in your own campaign.
The book includes a new type of Mind Flayer called the Mind Flayers of Thoon. The lore goes that a vessel of Mind Flayers was traveling at the far edges of the Astral Plane and encountered something that changed them both physically and philosophically. Their sole purpose now is to serve Thoon and to gather a mystical energy called quintessence. Whether Thoon is a deity of some kind or merely a symbolic ideal isn’t stated…that’s being left up to your own DM to decide. My personal take what that the designers were trying to go for an esoteric being in the mold of Lovecraftian Cthulhu Mythos deities such as Azathoth. These Mind Flayers employ creatures called Madcrafters of Thoon who create bizarre and extremely powerful constructs.
So what’s the final word on Monster Manual V? On the good side, most of the new monsters are unique and not just merely new species of existing monster types (despite the fact that most of what I mentioned is just that!). The monsters do show a lot of creativity not only in their design and look but also in their lore and ecology. As mentioned the mix is very good and there’s creatures here to challenge most levels of player characters. The art was up to Wizard’s usual high standards. On the negative side a few things: There was an incredible dearth of good-aligned monsters in the book, like maybe one! Secondly, as much as I appreciate the efforts of the designers, they continue to saturate players with more information than we could ever use. Almost all of the monsters in the book have entries that are 2 – 3 pages long. This is a case where they are simply over-thinking their creations.   All in all, a welcome addition to the D&D library.


Showing items 1 - 5 of 5
TheConundrum 9/4/2007 9:20:26 AM
The article doesn't specify which edition of the game it's used for. I am taking an educated guess and am saying ed. 3.5. No matter how good this book is why would anybody invest in it when Wizards of the Coast announced a new 4th edition at Gen-con this year. Of all the thing I have heard about 4th is how much (or how little) of 3rd and 3.5 source material will be readily compatible with the new edition. The fact that doesn't seem to be an upfront selling point tells me that players wanting to play 4th will be required to start making investments in newer sourcebooks. This book sounds like a great addition, but that fact it may already be obsolete will (at least for now) keep me from buying.
tjanson 9/4/2007 1:03:20 PM
Well I think players will continue to stay with the 3.5 edition. It's just like people staying with DVD and not moving to blu-ray yet. There's so much material out there that players don't need to change and I really don't think Wizards would be so bold as to completely make the new edition incompatible with 4.0. Heck i know people that are still playing regular AD&D with the original hardcovers.
Boombatty 9/4/2007 3:29:36 PM
Those people were beat up savagely in high school weren't they ? ;)
galaga51 9/4/2007 4:52:41 PM
Agreed Tj - While it isn't perfect, ed3.5 is pretty good. And with so much source material out there for 3.5, invested Dungeon Masters will likely be unwilling to drop another $30 per book on a new system. A 4th edition would need to be an extreme improvement.
TayDor 9/4/2007 10:07:52 PM
The gamers I know aren't impressed with what they've heard about 4.0. They are also a bit annoyed at how soon this new edition has come out after the others. They won't be getting 4.0 .


You must be logged in to leave a comment. Please click here to login.