Movie Review

Mania Grade: A-

0 Comments | Add


Rate & Share:


Related Links:



  • Reviewed Format: Wide Theatrical Release
  • Rated: PG-13
  • Stars: Johnny Depp, Geoffrey Rush, Orlando Bloom, Keira Knightley, Jack Davenport, Jonathan Pryce
  • Writers: Ted Elliott, Terry Rossio, story by Elliott, Rossio, Stuart Beattie, Jay Wolpert
  • Director: Gore Verbinski
  • Distributor: Disney


Yo-ho-ho and buckets of pirate adventure fun

By MICHAEL TUNISON     July 09, 2003

The final one-sheet for PIRATES OF THE CARRIBEAN.
© Walt Disney Pictures

Hollywood long ago drew the commercial skull-and-crossbones sign over any movie involving pirates, and the public's stubborn lack of interest in such modern-day spins as the 1995 Renny Harlin/Geena Davis vehicle CUTTHROAT ISLAND and last year's Disney pirate ship/sci-fi hybrid TREASURE PLANET has done nothing to convince the suits otherwise (Spielberg himself directed one of his rare duds in 1991's HOOK). The genre's fortunes had reached such a low ebb, in fact, that folks began to wonder if recent generations of filmmakers had simply lost the art of making sea swashbucklers in the style of the Errol Flynn-starring milestones CAPTAIN BLOOD and THE SEA HAWK. Dead screenwriters tell no tales, you might say.

But just as all it took were GLADIATOR and CHICAGO to prove that it was possible to bring the sword-and-sandal epic and musical back to popular life, all we ever needed was one good pirate movie to revive one of the screen's mainstay genres of the '30s through '50s. As unlikely as it may seem considering its origin as a Disney theme park ride, PIRATES OF THE CARIBBEAN: THE CURSE OF THE BLACK PEARL is that movie. A strange brew of creative forces, including the director of THE RING (Gore Verbinski), the scripters of SHREK (Ted Elliott and Terry Rossio) and action producer Jerry Bruckheimer, have combined to slyly update the genre's conventions while supplying the only thing that really matters with this kind of film: a boatload of fun.

While the mere idea of a PIRATES OF THE CARIBBEAN movie smacks of synergistic corporate filmmaking at its most calculated (you can almost picture the Disney board meeting where somebody pitched the idea of exploiting the PIRATES "brand"), in the topsy-turvy world of Hollywood the result has somehow ended up being one of the more inspired not to mention funniest mainstream action-adventures to come along in a while. Of course, it doesn't hurt that the studio called in the witty Elliott and Rossio, who previously scripted just about the only other memorable Hollywood swashbuckler of recent years, the Antonio Banderas-starring THE MASK OF ZORRO. Topping it all off is the improbable involvement of the usually anti-commercial Johnny Depp, whose hilariously off-kilter spin on his pirate captain character is an instant classic of the genre.

The half-serious


plot involves a supernatural pirate craft, the Black Pearl, whose Captain Barbossa (Geoffrey Rush) endlessly plies the waves of the Caribbean on a mysterious quest. Tied into this phenomenon in a way he doesn't yet understand is young weaponsmith's assistant Will Turner (THE LORD OF THE RINGS' Orlando Bloom), whose dual passions are his swordmanship and his apparently unrequited feelings for a childhood friend, Elizabeth (Keira Knightley), daughter of the local British governor (Jonathan Pryce). Depp's shipless and crewless Captain Jack Sparrow a stoned-out Han Solo with a brain so addled by grog and the sun that it's all he can do to walk a straight plank arrives just in time to get caught up in things before Barbossa's men attack the city and carry off Elizabeth. Of course, the heroes must organize a desperate attempt to rescue her, an effort that eventually leads them to confront the nature of the strange curse alluded to in the film's title.

The supernatural/curse element is one of the things that separates PIRATES from the straight-ahead traditional swashbuckler movies of yore, which were supposed to take place in the "real" world, however wildly romanticized. The filmmakers' savvy decision to incorporate magical ingredients (not unlike HOOK) actually shifts the film into the pure fantasy realm that audiences, softened up by THE LORD OF THE RINGS and HARRY POTTER, seem to have an endless appetite for these days. It's also an excuse to indulge in some delightful CGI skeletons and other effects from the guys at Industrial Light & Magic, who, we're pleased to find, have been studying their Harryhausen closely. Just for the fun of it, the film nods to a few of the more memorable scenes from the venerable Disney ride about the only direct connection, aside from the name, between the two properties.

While the film's tone is so light and cheeky that at times it threatens to sail off into pure camp, Verbinski and company have a strong enough grip on the characters to keep pulling us back into the story. Depp's show-stealing, eccentric Captain Jack is bound to get most of the attention, but PIRATES' cast is chock full of charismatic actors who get the film's humor and lighthearted action set pieces. Seen outside his fan-favorite LORD OF THE RINGS Legolas persona for the first time (in the U.S., anyway), Bloom makes a fine Luke Skywalker-type straight-man hero, while Keira Knightley (only 17 when the picture was filmed) demonstrates the special ability of British actresses to be distractingly beautiful without ever seeming like a bimbo or token sex object. The wryly funny Jack Davenport (THE TALENTED MR. RIPLEY) also manages to make an impression in what might have been the throwaway role of the Royal Navy commodore who happens to be Will's chief rival for Elizabeth's affections.

It's hard to imagine such an enjoyable screen adventure won't continue on in some shape or another, and the way Disney has affixed the CURSE OF THE BLACK PEARL subtitle to the film can be taken as a hint that somebody is already envisioning sequels if PIRATES catches on with audiences. Indeed, despite how well things are resolved at the end of the story, one is left with the sense not so much of something ending, but of a larger adventure beginning. Speaking as one fan, the reviewer can hardly wait.

Questions? Comments? Let us know what you think at feedback@cinescape.com.


Be the first to add a comment to this article!


You must be logged in to leave a comment. Please click here to login.