DVD Review

Send to a Friend



To: (email)


To: (name)


From: (name)


Message:



PLANET TERROR – 2 Disc Unrated and Extended Edition

By: Robert T. Trate
Review Date: Monday, October 15, 2007

‘Grindhouse Presents: Robert Rodriguez’s Planet Terror’ is a cinematic experience. Opening with a faux trailer that sets a mood, a great mood, I knew that ‘The Grindhouse’ was going to be something different. It is a great tribute to all the writers, directors, and actors who gave it their all when Hollywood only cared about making a quick buck. Oddly enough, the Weinsteins, to make a buck or make a few back, ripped this cinematic tribute apart to cash in by selling both ‘Planet Terror’ and ‘Death Proof’ as separate movies. I could bitch and complain about splitting up the two movies and the fact that this “Extended and Unrated” edition doesn’t have the words “Ultimate” or “Definitive’, another indication that there is another DVD on the way, but let’s talk about this DVD and the movie itself.
 
‘Planet Terror: Extended and Unrated’ doesn’t lose any of its punch, style, silliness, or gore that the theatrical cut had. Usually “Special Edition” and “Extended” versions are my first choice over the theatrical cut.   You might see a few more scenes that flesh out a few of the side characters, but this may be the first time I was bummed that I didn’t get the theatrical cut. There are longer takes and extended moments to nearly half the movie in this cut and I found them to be bothersome. I wanted my quick, balls to the wall version that I had watched in the theater, what Rodriquez and Tarantino called the ‘Grindhouse’. The ‘Planet Terror’ I watched on DVD was more like watching the movie at a second run theater which had a bad 35mm print. It wasn’t nearly as cut up as the one I saw back in April. This time I was watching more moments with the Block family, both at home and at work, watched a longer sex scene with Rose McGowan (okay, not something to complain about) and had a few more moments with Quentin Tarantino’s disgusting character, The Rapist. Just a few gripes here and there, however the theatrical, cut up, beat up, spliced up, patched up version was the true Grindhouse experience. This film is like someone found a few missing reels and then put them back into the film. Perhaps the “Restored Version” or the “Practically Restored Version” is how they should have packaged and sold the DVD.
 
Special Features
The commentary track is missing Quentin Tarantino’s input so Robert Rodriguez goes it alone pointing out how they did certain effects, stunts, and what was added to the DVD cut. Rodriguez’s commentary works nicely with his “10-Minute Film School” (on disc 2) which breaks down how they did many of the special effects and the aging of the film (it was actually shot on Digital Video). Like all directors who do commentary tracks Rodriguez points out various people in the film who play Sickos (‘Planet Terror’s’ term for Zombies), interesting enough Zoe Bell who was one of the stars in ‘Death Proof’ plays a Sicko in Planet Terror. Her scene is extended in this version.
 
Even though they changed the cinematic experience of ‘Planet Terror’, they included an audience reaction track. Reminding us all how much fun it is to sit in the dark and watch a movie like this with a group of people. The laughing and cheering were just as good as when I saw it both times in the theater, yet I have to ask, where is the theatrical cut and how long will we have to wait to get that on DVD?
 
Rodriguez included some nice features on his guy and girl cast (two separate features) and even on how and why he cast his son as the Block’s only child Tony (all three features on disc 2).   Rodriguez also reveals he had very little written for the side characters and let the actors who auditioned for the parts fill the roles out and rewrote many of the roles based on what he liked about them in their auditions. Josh Brolin, for one, had a complete rewrite for Doc Block.
 
Besides no theatrical cut or actually getting both movies together, as my $9.00 movie ticket got me, I was disappointed that there were no other faux trailers, outside of ‘Machete’.   I searched for an Easter Egg of them and found nothing.   I thought it would have only been appropriate to run them after the final credits of ‘Planet Terror’ and then gone to a reel missing sign that said, “Please put in your ‘Death Proof’ DVD”.
 
Robert Rodriguez mentions what he’ll “some day put” on later release of the movie, one of those things being his barbeque recipe.   I just hope he’ll put on the right version of ‘Grindhouse: Planet Terror” as it was originally intended to be seen. With that balls to the wall theatrical cut, multiple faux trailers, and ‘Death Proof’ right behind it.



More From Mania

DVD Shopping Bag: 300 Collector's Edition

Winner: 'Planet Terror' Cherry Action Figure
(Monday, October 22, 2007)
Box Sets
(Tuesday, October 16, 2007)
Superman 14-Disc Ultimate Collector's Edition Artwork
(Friday, September 22, 2006)
The 2 Johns
(Tuesday, June 6, 2006)
Disc Wars continue
(Tuesday, February 7, 2006)
French psycho vs. Aussie zombies
(Tuesday, October 11, 2005)

See more related content
More Content By Robert T. Trate
DVD SHOPPING BAG- Blu-Ray Bonanza
(Tuesday, December 2, 2008)
TOY MANIAC-Mortal Kombat vs. DC Universe
(Thursday, November 27, 2008)
DVD SHOPPING BAG- The Real Ghostbusters DVD Collection
(Tuesday, November 25, 2008)
TV REVIEW- SWTCW Episode: Bombad Jedi
(Sunday, November 23, 2008)
TOY MANIAC: Call of Duty: World at War
(Thursday, November 20, 2008)
DVD Shopping Bag: 300 Collector's Edition
(Tuesday, November 18, 2008)
PS3 Review of Bond 007: Quantum of Solace
(Thursday, November 13, 2008)
Toy Maniac: Secrets Revealed About SDCC Exclusives
(Thursday, November 13, 2008)
DVD Shopping Bag: Gimmicks for the Modern Era
(Tuesday, November 11, 2008)
Blu-Ray Review of Star Wars: The Clone Wars
(Friday, November 7, 2008)
Fandango Logo
Comments/Responses
1
GentlemenDeath • Oct 15, 2007, 12:20am •
It sucks that the Planet Terror discs does not have any of the other trailers, which untimaltey suggests that there will be ANOTHER DVD with them in the near future, ripping off the fan of the movies....

I hate this shit! I loved this Grindhouse experience so I will of course, by this DVD when it comes out. But to release another one later, just so I can get the trailers is not only fucked up, but like I just said, ripping off the fans of the movie...Great job Weinstein fucknuts!

mckracken • Oct 15, 2007, 01:17am •
I'm STILL waiting for my Ultimate Directors Edition of Kill Bill 1&2 together finally.

the reason they split them up is to recoup losses from its theatrical run. If I remember correctly, Japan and China's theatrical release of Grindhouse split up the two movies, why? Because China and Japan never had "the grindhouse" experience in the 70's...
I had hoped that those faux trailers would find their way on the Planet Terror 2nd disk but apparantly not... hopefully they'll turn up someplace. Rumor is that Danny Trejeo is making or wants to make Machete into a theatrical or direct-to-DVD Grindhouse movie so hopefully the faux trailers will surface someplace.

xyde • Oct 15, 2007, 07:57am •
me too, swansong...
it pisses me off as well...
no wonder piracy is kicking their ass here in southeast asia.

mckracken, thatz right. BUT EVEN if they split em up for losses in the theatrical run, what's a little disc space for the rest of the trailers that swansong was talking about... that's like, what, 200 mb of video file space?

they do that in all of the big movie dvds... well, most anyway...

after you all have bought the dvds.... just when you thought its the "special double-disc edition"... months later, they release an ultimate edition, a 1.5, a 2.5, a director's cut... some of them are NOT even really special enough to be put on ANOTHER dvd edition... they could have been with the first double disc edition dvd

sucks, doesn't it?

WISEGUY562 • Oct 15, 2007, 08:06am •
This is exactly why I'm waiting for them to release the films together the way I saw them in the theater. I, like many others have been taken by the studios many times when they keep putting a supposedly better version out there only because it may have an extra 2 minutes that were edited out. No more, I'm waiting.

myklspader • Oct 15, 2007, 11:33am •
I agree with Swan, I too will be buying Planet Terror since I am a fan, and yeah it is messed up that they are not releasing Grindhouse the way they should.
And think, this is probably all because of a bunch of lame asses that quite didn't get the whole Grindhouse take (2 for 1) and their short ass attention spans (get over it people, I pay $9 a ticket, give me a 2-3 hour movie), with this as the result. Also those same jackasses gave the Wienstiens, Rodriguez and Tarantino the excuse to make the future dvd versions possible and rip the fans of Lucas style.

snallygaster • Oct 15, 2007, 12:33pm •
Actually, the two Grindhouse movies were also released seperately in Europe as well as Asia. I don't have a lot of hard numbers, but I recall reading that the individual movies tanked as badly overseas as the double feature did in the US.


GentlemenDeath • Oct 15, 2007, 03:36pm •
Like Myklspader just said, I would rather pay $7-9 dollars for TWO movies in one, then the same price for ONE movie that lasts maybe 1hr and 30-45min.....

These movies were awesome, and I can only hope Rodriguez and Tarantino team back up for another Grindhouse or another movie in general...

mckracken • Oct 16, 2007, 01:48am •
possibly Sin City 2 will be next for Rodriguez and Tarantino. dont expect another Grindhouse experience from these guys... I was thinking last night after I posted that these faux trailers were all directed by some well known directors (Rob Zombie, Eli Roth and so on) and most have movies coming out on DVD (Rob's Halloween) so its entirely possible that each director might attach his trailer to his own movie... I dunno... just a thought

joeypsychotic • Oct 16, 2007, 07:24pm •
Funny. I saw Grindhouse in the theater with a crowd of people mostly (obviously) too young to have experienced the real thing back in the '70's as I had. They were having a great time, laughing at all the right parts, etc.
I have no clue why the film did not perform BO-wise, but I understand why the Weinsteins are splittting up the DVD release, they want to get some return. Certainly QT & RR retain some kind of control to put out a proper version at some later date. I can't wait. I wisely did not buy either Kill Bill and will soon be rewarded. Same with Sin City. I'm so glad I waited for the extended cut.
If it's pretty clear a better release is coming down the pike, RENT, don't buy, & wait for the good one to come out.

1
Login to post a comment!