The Scorpion King 3: The Battle For Redemption -

Mania Grade: C-

13 Comments | Add


Rate & Share:


Related Links:



  • DVD: The Scorpion King 3: The Battle for Redemption
  • Rating: PG-13
  • Starring: Victor Webster, Ron Perlman, Billy Zane, Bostin Christopher, Krystal Vee
  • Written By: Randal McKormick, Shane Kuhn, Brendan Cowles
  • Directed By: Roel Reine
  • Distributor: Universal Home Entertainment
  • Original Year of Release: 2011
  • Extras: See Below
  • Series:

The Scorpion King 3: The Battle For Redemption

Weak sequel has few positives

By Tim Janson     January 17, 2012


The Scorpion King 3: The Battle for Redemption is the third film in the Scorpion King franchise although it is the first sequel to the 2002 film as the second film was actually a prequel.  With the death of his queen Cassandra, Mathayus, the Scorpion King (Webster) forsakes his kingdom for the life of a mercenary.  Mathayus is hired by King Horus (Perlman) to aid him in his upcoming war against his evil brother Prince Talus (Zane) who wants Horus’ kingdom for himself.  Mathayus is joined by the Germanic warrior Olaf (Bostin Christopher) and sent first to aid Horus’ closest ally King Ramusan somewhere in an unnamed Far East Asian kingdom. 
While the pair manage to help Ramusan’s troops defeat Talus’s initial invasion (in the most underwhelming castle assault you’ve ever seen on film), Ramusan now needs the pair to rescue his daughter, Princess Silda (Krystal Vee) who has been captured by Talus who is holding her for ransom in return for the ancient Book of the Dead that will grant Talus great powers.
Wow, where do I begin with Scorpion King 3?  It’s clear that no one involved with the production from the writers, to the directors, to the wardrobe people have ever picked up a history book much less read one.  To start, the Scorpion King was supposed to be a pre-dynasty Egyptian King and yet he’s also described as an Akkadian, whose nation was in what today is modern Iraq .  Ok so maybe I’ll let them off on that one but the fact is that there is almost nothing in Scorpion King 3 that looks remotely Egyptian or Middle Eastern in style or substance.  In fact the film is all over the map.  Horus, who has an Egyptian sounding name, rules a kingdom that strangely looks populated mainly by white, western Europeans.  His soldiers are dressed as Mongol warriors but his personal guard is dressed like Roman Legionnaires.  Oh, and add ninjas into the mix, too because there’s a secret group called Cobra who is also trying to protect the Princess.  Apparently the wardrobe department got a good deal on costumes and decided to go with it and authenticity be damned!
The Scorpion King was said to have ruled around 3300 BC but the first Germanic tribes wouldn’t appear for another 1500 years so the inclusion of “Olaf” only further muddles this stew of historical inaccuracies.  Now maybe I’m being nit-picky here but it really wouldn’t have taken much of an effort to at least get the history somewhat accurate.  Things like this stand out in a big way.  It’s shoddy filmmaking from director Roel Reine but what do you expect from the guy who gave us such classics as “Death Race 2” and “The Marine 2”.  Apparently he’s going for the title of King of bad sequels.
Making matters worse is that you cannot even enjoy it as a fun action film.  The choreography is as bad as the actors and stunt people give each other love taps with their weapons.  Olaf and Mathayus engage in a knock-down fist fight early on yet neither has a scratch or a bruise to show for it.  As mentioned the assault on Ramusan’s castle is laughable as were talking about 60 soldiers on each side fighting inside a castle that is smaller than the average suburban middle class home.
In the entire morass there are a few faint beacons of positive light.  Billy Zane just goes all out and has a lot of fun in his role as Talus.  He gleefully over-dramatizes every line he has but at least he has some life.  More than you can say for Perlman who looks like he’s about to nod off.  Does he have a contract that says he has to be in every film made?  There’s also some great eye-candy in the forms of Krystal Vee and Selina Lo who have the film’s best fight scene.  And a word about Victor Webster in the starring role…he might not be much of an actor but he has a good look…tall, well-built.  I’d have loved to seen him play Conan the Barbarian…at least over Jason Mamoa.
Blu-Ray Extras
Audio Commentary with Director Roel Reine
Deleted/Extended Scenes (13:00)  Mostly extended scenes.  We do get a lot more of the fight between Olaf and Agromel (Played by former WWE wrestler Dave Batista) which was cut drastically short.
Deleted Shot Montage (4:14)
Gag Reel (2:12)
Swords and Scorpions: A Making of (13:18) – Standard making of documentary with interviews with cast and the director.
Preparing for Battle (6:00) – A look at the films action sequences and the preparation and training that the actors went through.


Showing items 1 - 10 of 13
1 2 >  >>  
InnerSanctum 1/17/2012 8:41:14 AM

 Based on the can you even give it a C -?  Sounds like a flat out F.  

tjanson 1/17/2012 9:26:54 AM

well like I said there were a couple of positives...Zanes performance, the female actors, decent extras, and Webster was passable. 

lusiphur 1/17/2012 10:16:40 AM

 When I saw the trailer for this and saw Dave Batista and Kimbo Slice in it, I knew it was doomed to mediocrity. 

tjanson 1/17/2012 11:03:33 AM

Well neither Batista or Slice are called on to do much more than grunt

zalder 1/17/2012 1:12:22 PM

heh well that definilty I am not going to see..but then I never saw the other scorpian movies either.  Was this straight to video as I haven't seen any marketing for it at all....which isn't to surprizing though as bad as it sounds like it was...

SarcasticCaveman 1/17/2012 1:19:07 PM

 I've not seen it, but why was this movie even dignified with a review?

tjanson 1/17/2012 2:04:41 PM

Sacastic...even bad movies get reviewed.  consider a Mania public service.

InnerSanctum 1/17/2012 4:38:54 PM

 tjanson:  LOL.  Seriously, get a "like" button on here.  ; )

You know, Perlman will go down as a working man's actor.  He has been the lead in both TV/film and doesn't even seem to bother reading a script anymore.  Period film...back lot...grey wig...sure...I need a new box of Cohibas.  He is a true B movie actor.  Put him and Campbell in a film and you have one hell of a guilty pleasure!



jppintar326 1/18/2012 2:32:06 PM

Sccording to the extras, the film was filmed in Thailand for budgetary reasons so I am willing to excuse that.  It was cheaper to produce there, get extras there, and I think nitpicking those aspects are a waste of time.  Yes, the movie itself is just cheesy and unnecessary, a video rental at best.

tjanson 1/18/2012 3:41:06 PM

Inner...very true about Perlman.  Hey you need to check out my Tuesday Terrors column...I know you're a horror buff.

Jppintar: It may be nitpicky but like I said...It would not have been that difficult to make the film somewhat more authentic.  Instead of a Germanic warrior why not make him a Sumerian, or Egyptian.  Perhaps, like I said the budget wasn't there for costumes but its still really weird to see guys dressed like Roman Legionnaires in a Pre-Egyptian dynasty era.  It's hard to overlook something that stands out so much

1 2 >  >>  


You must be logged in to leave a comment. Please click here to login.