TV Review


"Smallville: Crimson"

By: STEPHEN LACKEY
Review Date: Monday, February 05, 2007

I’m sort of an odd fan of Smallville, I watch every week even though I’m disappointed with the series more often than not.  The problem is that I remember that first season and the second, the good episodes of the show, and I hold out hope that the creators might get back to that level of quality at some point.  The past couple of episodes for me have been quite exceptional, featuring storylines that progressed Clark as a hero and didn’t get bogged down in over done soap opera romance.  Well, just as I was starting to really look forward to Thursday nights here comes a red kryptonite episode. 

In the past, the red kryptonite episodes were mostly there just for pandering and the events that happen just seem to work themselves out with few if any repercussions to the overall story arc.  We get that again with this episode, but there’s a little more here that helps keep the episode out of the “F” category.  Lois being down about her break up with Oliver accepts a gift of special lip stick from a mysterious woman who is selling all kinds of trinkets and potions.  The woman tells her that she will fall in love with the first person she sees while wearing the lip stick, and of course Lois sees Clark.  Clark fights Lois off until she finally kisses him and the red stuff kicks in.  At the same time Lana and Lex are preparing for their big engagement dinner.  In an attempt to prove to Lois that he’s more than just a farm boy, Clark leaps from one building to the clock tower holding Lois in his arms and he also lets out Oliver’s secret.  Just when they are about to get it on he sees Lois’ invitation to the dinner and he decides that they should crash it together. 


At the dinner, all hell breaks lose with Clark ripping everybody in the room a new one.  He tells Martha that she’s becoming more of a Luthor than a Kent less than a year after his father died.  He tells Chloe that he knows she’s pining away for him and that he’s thought about it, and he gives it to Lana and Lex too.  As much as I liked this scene I started to feel like “oh hell, here’s the pandering” and by the end of the episode somehow they’ll all have forgotten about it, but at least in regard to that scene, I was wrong.  Lex gets pissed and tries to take Clark down only to get knocked down himself.  Clark kidnaps Lana and takes her to the barn to get her to admit her love for him.  In the barn, Lex pulls a gun on Clark, and Clark turns into a bad ass ripping the gun from Lex’s hands telling him he doesn’t know the rules to the game.  Clark flings Lex though a wall and chokes him out a bit.  He also tells Lex that if he’d known what kind of man Lex would turn out to be he never would have saved him that day back in season one.  Lex grabs a tool and stabs Clark with it.  At the same time, Martha shows up hiding a chunk of green kryptonite so it looks like Clark goes down from the attempted stabbing. 

Now as is common for one of these episodes Lois does forget everything that happened between her and Clark, irritating but predictable.  But all the other stuff that happened sticks with the big zinger being Lana stealing the tool that Lex used to stab Clark.  It’s all gnarled and bent and she keeps it wrapped in a red cloth in one of her drawers back at the mansion.  When Clark apologizes to Martha she tells him that she believes there is a grain of truth in everything he said and that he has to deal with those feelings.  So it seems that much of what Clark said will have a ripple effect in the series.  The first ripple happens at the end of the episode when Jimmy breaks up with Chloe not being able to live with the secret relationship that she and Clark share.  She does a better job with this scene than Lana has done with her emotional scenes the entire run of the series.  We may see Martha step back and reconsider her relationship with Lionel too.  Lana ahs seen the worst in Lex, she saw him draw a gun on Clark and he tells her he doesn’t know what he’d be capable of if he lost her.  So she has to take a real look at the situation she has put herself in.  So, as much as I hate these episodes as a whole at least some of what happened in this episode seems like it’ll make an impact on the series. 

New story arcs do appear to be getting a start in this episode too.  Lana has really been pressuring Clark and Chloe over Clark’s secret.  She even tells Chloe in this episode that she’ll stop asking Chloe about it as long as Chloe stops pretending that it doesn’t exist.  Now that she has the bent tool she may be more impassioned than ever to discover the secret.  Also, in a meeting with Lana’s doctor it appears that there’s something “special” about Lana’s pregnancy and Lex has something to do with it.  Will it be interesting to see where these plot threads go?  I can’t say, but I’m hoping for the best.  There’s a bit of foreshadowing in this episode involving a future relationship between Clark and Lois, and that’s fine with me because the way these two act with each other is just about the only thing in this series that’s similar to the classic Superman story I grew up with. 

While this episode was nowhere near as terrible as I expected it to be, it’s still a red kryptonite episode and plenty happens that those involved suddenly forget, and what about the girl who sold the red kryptonite stuff to start with?  She was just a plot device and nothing more.  Yes, this episode did appear to serve more than the simple purpose of pandering but the red kryptonite crutch was worn out a long time ago.



More Content By STEPHEN LACKEY
PRISON BREAK: Five the Hard Way
(Friday, October 10, 2008)
TERMINATOR: THE SARAH CONNOR CHRONICLES: Goodbye to All That
(Wednesday, October 8, 2008)
TV Wasteland: Red Mars is Coming to AMC
(Monday, October 6, 2008)
TV Feature Interview: Ghost Hunters
(Saturday, October 4, 2008)
TV Feature Interview: Scare Tactics
(Saturday, October 4, 2008)
HEROES: One of Us, One of Them
(Thursday, October 2, 2008)
SANCTUARY: Sanctuary for All
(Thursday, October 2, 2008)
TERMINATOR: THE SARAH CONNOR CHRONICLES: Allison from Palmdale
(Wednesday, October 1, 2008)
TV Feature Interview: Josh Gates Talks Destination Truth
(Wednesday, October 1, 2008)
Feature Interview: Sanctuary's Amanda Tapping
(Tuesday, September 30, 2008)
Fandango Logo
Comments/Responses
1 2 > >>
doublerdiner • Feb 05, 2007, 03:55am •
I must say I do not agree with the ratio of forgotten:consequences in this episode as far as your review goes. The only things forgotten were Lois and Clark jumping and Green Arrow's identity. Even the rest of the Lois and Clark fiasco Lois ends up at least being aware of. Everything else in the episode is remembered.

I do believe it is not entirely fair or maybe just not entirely accurate to dismiss the episode, or so much of it at least, as just another Red-Kryptonite-leaves-no-stains episode. This time it really did cause some ripples. Personally I found it to be far more dramatic and fun than when I first saw/read about the plot synopsis.

I was expecting this to be a lesser episode of cooky Lois fawning over Clark hijinks, and it turned out to have a lot of repercussive moments and scenes. I have always watched Smallville without having high expectations, and if nothing else, being amused by the monster-of-the-week episodes, but when the characters and stories really started to evolve by season 3, I started to have higher hopes. Season 4 was absolutely my least favorite, aside from a few moments throughout that barely add up to a 42 min episode worth of good show. But the redemption came for me in season 5 and now 6, where they have risen the bar and taking it a bit more serious. I think that it's healthy. Also I should state that as much as I love Superman in general, I really don't care how much they stick to or break with comic book canon. I enjoy the references to Superman lore as much as any fanboy and giggle with at least the same amount of glee when they occur, but frankly if I wanted the comic, I'd read the comic. I like to be surprised by Smallville. Kudos to them, and here's to hoping they do whatever the hell they want so long as it continues to be of better quality than season 4 and all the monster-of-the-week episodes...

Also, Allison Mack, EXTREMELY underpraised actress? Or ABSURDLY and OFFENSIVELY underpraised?

noblenonsense • Feb 05, 2007, 07:13am •
Allison Mack extremely underpraised....and hot...:-)

dodgy • Feb 05, 2007, 08:58am •
Allison Mack/Cloe should have been Lois! I had hopes this would turn out to be the case when she started using Lois' name to write under for the planet, but no, denied! She's far hotter than Erica or Lana!

noblenonsense • Feb 05, 2007, 09:11am •
She's not hotter than Erica Durance...but still hot...more cute and wholesome..but not hotter...personal opinion

mbeckham1 • Feb 05, 2007, 10:29am •
I haven't seen this seasn since I do not get CW, but I like what I'm hearing for the most part.

I've been trying to catch up through Family channel reruns and my parents HD channels. Looks promising overall.

The part about Lois forgetting that Clark told her about himself and Oliver was dissapointing since it points to the old tactic of setting up scenes which look important on trailers but don't really mean anything. A tactic anyone whose even seen TV set since 1970 should be wise to.

I do like that they had some consequences.

That was what I loved about Buffy and Angel in episodes like Tabula Rasa and Spin the Bottle, or the Halloween episode.

Or in Farscape with episodes like Crackers Don't Matter and Out of Their Minds.


The out of character experience epsisodes had long term effects on the characters involved, and would be repeatedly referenced in the series. And sometimes be used to further major plot developments.

I hope that is the case hear. Lana getting the bent tool and the stuff with Chloe sounds promising.

dallaswinston • Feb 05, 2007, 01:08pm •
SMALLVILLE is the best series on TV. They can do no wrong.

Once the show ends they will need to do a Real Superman Movie with Tom Welling as The Man Of Steel !

spacekicker • Feb 05, 2007, 05:34pm •
I can't disagree with this column more

"The problem is that I remember that first season and the second, the good episodes of the show, and I hold out hope that the creators might get back to that level of quality at some point"

WHAAATTTT!!!???

the first few seasons were some of the most repetitive melodrama I've ever seen. Weekly Krypto persons causing havoc, and the non emotional lana anchoring some sort of love story...boooo!

It was around the second half of the 4th season when things started hopping.

I was so opposed to the introduction of Lois to the point where I stopped watching the show. It was a year and a half later when people were telling me how good it was that I picked it up.

They were right.

Introducing Lois to Clark with a cynical banter that somewhat betrays their attraction is awesome. It's no longer Lois looking at Clark like a buffoon, but as a square and SHE is the mighty one. It's hilarious, and Erica has become the role.

Allison Mack is a goddess.

But they have since then moved the mythology to a point where they could geniunely move the show into a Superman show. He's grown into his powers, come across the Justice League (to a degree) fought Zod, Brainiac, and escaped from the phantom zone. The Daily Planet is huge and Metropolis plays more of a role than smallville does.

the only thing that bothered me about this episode was that it somewhat resucitated the Clark/Lana story, when I could care less. How can I invest in a love story that we ALL know fails?

spacekicker • Feb 05, 2007, 06:54pm •
Crap I became the guy who writes an overly long comment. Ack!

ponyboy76 • Feb 06, 2007, 08:58am •
Its okay spacekicker, sometime it can`t be helped. I also totally disagree with the review of this episode. Yes, some of the big points weren`t forgotten, but the important ones are still there and will haunt the characters through the rest of the season. The fact that Lana may now discover Clark`s secret is a big on and they definitely continue to solidify the animosity that Clark and Lex feel for eachother just as they solidified their friendship in the early seasons. We all know that the red kryptonite makes people forget their actions as it did in the last ep they used it. Its been established, movie on. And I do hope that it doesn't actually resucitate the Lana/Clark story because I`m still hoping that she dies, which would cause an even larger rift in the whole Lex vs Clark story.

kiba101 • Feb 06, 2007, 01:05pm •
I agree with ponyboy76 if lana dies and it's lex's fault that would make the feud between lex and clark go high and who knows clark could get in a fight with lex and leave him in coma or something.

1 2 > >>
Login to post a comment!