Superman vs. Hulk: Who Would Win in a Fight Comments - Mania.com



COMMENTS AND RESPONSES

Showing items 11 - 20 of 100
<<  <  1 2 3 4 5 >  >>  
HudsonTaco 9/17/2009 6:20:32 AM

Hulk would continually get strong until he took Supes down if we are talking about a Slug out, but Superman could just throw him out into space ealier in the fight and Hulks done, Supes is way too fast for Hulk to react and he'd be in orbit and beyond in seconds, This wouldn't have worked on Doomsday because he was as fast as the Man of Steel.

KillerTomato 9/17/2009 7:04:36 AM

Of course the whole mention of Hulk being thrown into space all depends on whether or not he lets Superman hold him long enough to get that far.  Hulk is fully capable of ripping Superman's arms out of his socket to break free.  You think a trapped wolf turns to desperate measures (ie gnawing off his own leg to escape a trap), just think what the Hulk would do.  I mean the Hulk is a virtually mindless mass of muscle who knows how to do one thing regardless, and that is he knows how to survive.  That's the reason he's so dangerous.  Also

Superman's moral compass is probably his biggest weakness in fights, and unless Betty Ross or Rick Jones are running around nearby, Hulk lacks that.  Plus, Hulk is strongest there is...

Also, come on, Brandon Routh vs Edward Norton?  Hands down, Edward is wiry, but he's fierce...

littlemikey979 9/17/2009 7:24:19 AM

I think what would be the deciding factor is supes super speed, superman could land a million hard hits to hulks head before hulk smarts up to what is going on, with hulk dazed supes could fly him into space and beat him there as hulk has no flight and would just float around between punches. over end of story

timesobserver 9/17/2009 7:33:09 AM

I've always been a fan of the Classic Hulk and Superman.

The way I always pictured a fight between the two would be like a Rocky movie. They'll go the distance for a long time but in the end, Superman will win. But in the next fight, the Hulk would win. I've always seen them flip-flopping and going back and forward over the "title", because they are so powerful.

Anyways, the Hulk maybe dumb, but even he can learn from his mistakes and figure out his enemy's weaknesses.

 

www.thetimesobserver.com

hanso 9/17/2009 7:36:07 AM

Batman takes them both.

timesobserver 9/17/2009 7:44:30 AM

Also, a lot of you guys are saying that Superman is god-like and he could easily take care of the Hulk. And I agree, I don't care for a god-like Superman.

Which is why I like the Superman from the 1986-revamp of the Man of Steel much better. His power levels went down greatly. He was still super strong, but he couldn't move a planet like the Silver Age Superman could or blow out a sun like it was a birthday candle.

And as someone mentioned Doomsday, I alway saw him as a Hulk clone. Granted, I like Doomsday a lot but let's face it, he was pretty much like the Hulk, except the Hulk doesn't intentionally kill anyone.

But yeah, I would love to see a fight against the Hulk and Doomsday. After all, the classic Hulk has fought Thor and most of all the Marvel heroes at the same time over the years, including a major fight in the 1970s or 1980s, plus World War Hulk. (Although, I guess you would call WWH a different Hulk than the classic one.)

So a fight between the Hulk and Doomsday would be something to see.

silversurfer 9/17/2009 7:49:51 AM

LMAO @ Hanso.....

I still think that this could end up being a win for Hulk because Superman has morals whereas Hulk doesn't because he dealing with primal strength that can be matched only by his own mind telling him that he's the strongest....and to prove it. To me, there is no match for that. Superman doesn't have the heart to let it all go and just rip shit up...he can't because he won't.

Hulk's own obsessiveness with wanting to destroy Superman would be Superman's own undoing, just as it was when he fought Doomsday. The only thing he could do is get to the Fortress of Solitude and hope that he can send the Hulk to the Phantom Zone and HOPE that The Hulk doesn't find a way out....he would be upset the whole while he's there fighting everything that's in it and adapting to that existence....World War Hulk showed us what he can do if given the opportunity to make up for lost time....

KillerTomato 9/17/2009 8:17:28 AM

@silversurfer

Oh yeah Hulk would totally find a way back from the Phantom Zone, just like he found a way back to Earth after Earth's "heroes" had gotten rid of him.  And boy would he be pissed, seriously...the DCU would have a mess on their hands that they never expected, plus Hulk would probably be bringing along other Phantom Zone refugees ("Zoners" in Smallville terminology), now that would be a Superman story I would pick up.

And I'm assuming that the Superman we're talking about is in fact the 1980-ish de-powered Superman, I mean Golden Age Superman, well he would just have powers that would show up whenever convenient, so he'd probably have like a gamma-removal vision or something...that version is a horse of a different color.

@Hanso...Batman (circa Bruce Wayne) totally takes the cake...AND he doesn't even bother sharing...

mbeckham1 9/17/2009 8:36:18 AM

In my version Superman gets a lot of punches in early on using is super speed, but when he grabs Hulk's arm to throw him into space and Hulk seeing an opportunity slaps his hands together creating one of those sonic booms and while the force doesn't bother Superman the sonic boom iteself hits Supierman's superhearing like a ton of Kryptonite, and while he's temporarily stuinned Hulk grabs scrawny Blue Man's cape(one again proving the old lady from Incredibles right) throws him down and pummels him until he volutntarily bexcomes unconscious to avoid civilian casualties and Hulk seeing his enemy defeated gerts tire abnsd reverts to Bruce Banner who explains to a brtuised a nd bloodiyesd Cjlark Kent tjhe physics of sonic booms and why extrademinsional muscles are better than solar power. Then the two have a coffee on the Dailey Planet's s dime.

mbeckham1 9/17/2009 9:02:11 AM

As for Superman's other powers. Heat vision and super cold breath? Come on this is the Hulk we're talkin about bitcches. You might as well attack him with a sun lamp and a snow ball. In fact throwing that sissy shit at Hulk would just make him madder abnd strronger. Superman's blasting away and Hulk says "Glowy eye man hurt Hulk. Hulk Smash glowy eye man." Hulk goes thump on Superman's head, then looks down at his chest and says., "Hulk tannest there is."

<<  <  1 2 3 4 5 >  >>  

ADD A COMMENT

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Please click here to login.