DVD Review


THE SWORD IN THE STONE (45th Anniversary Edition)

By: Tim Janson
Review Date: Monday, June 30, 2008

The Sword In the Stone will never be considered one of Disney’s better animated feature films but it holds its own as solid family entertainment. This was Disney’s 18th animated feature and the last one released while Walt Disney was still alive. The story is based on T.H. White’s Arthurian works, The Once and Future King and is actually quite faithful (for a Disney film anyway). 

 

The tale focuses on Arthur’s (Known as Wart) life as a child and his education at the hands of the wizard, Merlin. Wart lives with his foster father Sir Ector (Voiced by Sebastian Cabot) and his foster brother, Kay. Sir Ector has plans for Wart to become Kay’s squire but Merlin “convinces” Sir Ector to let him educate the boy. Merlin’s lessons consist of him turning Wart into various animals in order to learn certain lessons about life. He’s transformed into a fish, a squirrel, and a bird. 

 

While in his bird form, Wart is captured by Madame Mim, a witch and Merlin’s rival. Merlin arrives to rescue the boy and challenges Mim to a magical duel. In the film’s best sequence, the two magic-users change shape into all sorts of creatures and Mim breaks the rules by transforming into a dragon. Merlin counters by changing into a germ, making Mim sick, winning the duel. Later, at a tournament for knights, Wart pulls the magical sword from the stone and is proclaimed the true and rightful King of England.

 
The Sword in the Stone is an enjoyable animated fantasy and deserving of a higher stature than it’s received in the 45 years since its original release. The biggest crime that the film commits is that it comes after such beloved Disney classics as Peter Pan, Sleeping Beauty, and 101 Dalmatians. It ends up sandwiched between Dalmatians and another all-time hit The Jungle Book. Because it isn’t as good as those films there has been a tendency to look down on The Sword in the Stone. The voice acting is quite good. Cabot pulled double-duty also serving as the narrator. Karl Swenson is fantastic as Merlin, bringing a sense of the dramatic and comedic to the part. The magical duel between Merlin and Madame Mim is a brilliantly animated sequence and one of the most memorable scenes in any Disney film.
 

The one glaring weakness is that you don’t get the memorable songs you’re used to getting in a Disney film. Music and song has always been integral in Disney animated features but none of the songs in The Sword and the Stone stand out. This is somewhat surprising as the songs were written by the Sherman Brothers, who won two Academy Awards for their work on Mary Poppins and they also wrote the songs for Jungle Book. 

 

While it’s no classic The Sword in the Stone is a lot of fun.

 
Extras
 

The extras are not as replete as those you get in Disney’s Platinum series but there are a few cool extras. 

 

“Music Magic” takes a look at the work of the Sherman Brothers including an interview with the pair.

 

“Merlin’s Magical Academy Game” is an game you can play with your DVD remote

 

“The Sword in the Stone Scrapbook” is an interactive behind-the-scenes look at the film featuting still frame galleries and trivia.

 

There’s a vintage Disney featurette as Walt Disney takes the viewer on a tour of the Disney prop vault.

 

The DVD also comes with two bonus animated shorts: “Brave Little Tailor” starring Mickey Mouse and “Knight for a Day” starring Goofy.



More Content By Tim Janson
DVD Review of Dexter Season 2
(Wednesday, September 3, 2008)
Book Review of The Art of Marc Silvestri
(Tuesday, September 2, 2008)
Book Review of Creepy Archives Vol. 1
(Monday, September 1, 2008)
Weekly Book Buzz: Romita Finds Himself Stranded
(Monday, September 1, 2008)
DVD Review of Phantasm 4: Oblivion
(Saturday, August 30, 2008)
DVD Review of Scorpion King 2: Rise of a Warrior
(Saturday, August 30, 2008)
DVD Review of Starship Troopers 3: Marauder
(Monday, August 25, 2008)
DVD Review of Witchblade the Complete Series
(Sunday, August 24, 2008)
Trade paperback Review: Indiana Jones Omnibus Vol. 2
(Wednesday, August 20, 2008)
Book Review of Comic Art Now
(Monday, August 18, 2008)
Comments/Responses
1
MrJawbreakingEquilibrium • Jun 30, 2008, 05:47am •
This movie and The Black Cauldron are my favorite Disney cartoon films. And the most overlooked. Shame.

Redshirt1 • Jun 30, 2008, 06:28am •
One thing, Because this film is overlooked there are many people that may not have seen it and this DVD review essentially gives the entire plot beginning to end. I think that as a reviewer you could have put this movie in the public eye without giving every detail including how Merlin defeats Mim. That's just my two cents though, but I am one of those people who hate it when trailers and reviewers give away toom many details about a movie.

noblenonsense • Jun 30, 2008, 07:30am •
Favorite Disney movie of all time. Even beats out Aladdin and Lion King.

galaga51 • Jun 30, 2008, 03:08pm •
"The one glaring weakness is that you don’t get the memorable songs you’re used to getting in a Disney film." That's funny, because I see that as one of it's greatest strengths. We don't all like Disney film for their music, as catchy as some of the tunes might be. Plus, I liked this simpler animation. Not my favorite, but definitely one of...

1
Login to post a comment!